A hotbed of hate or forum for debate?

A hotbed of hate or forum for debate?
SHARE
THIS



Advertising by its nature divides opinion and stirs debate. Because of this, the people who create it must expect a certain amount of criticism of their work. In the best cases comment threads on industry websites can become a forum for robust, open and honest discussion.

At their worst they can descend into petty and unjustified personal abuse and a forum to settle vendettas and embarrass a rival. This is what M&C Saatchi regional creative director Tom McFarlane describes as a “hotbed of hate”.

“The industry blogs are eating, and destroying, our young,” he says. “The blogs should be a showcase for young talent – somewhere they can receive encouragement, or informed opinion on how to improve their work. I have seen young copywriters and art directors devastated by the vitriol directed at their work – often their very first TV or major print campaign.”

Founder of recruitment firm Hourigan International, Anthony Hourigan says the culture around the comments is giving Australia a bad reputation in the rest of the world. “I think it’s a blight on the Australian advertising industry, and the comments are absolutely gutless. It reflects very poorly on our industry globally,” he says. “It’s a unique issue to our industry, and I think we have an awful reputation abroad for not supporting each other and the work out of this market.”

The debate around anonymous commenting is not new. Despite this Communications Council CEO Margaret Zabel says it is still something which is bubbling away in the background” and is regularly mentioned to her by agency heads.

Campaign Brief was the first ‘blog site’ to launch in 2006, allowing people to have their say anonymously. Initially unmoderated, it unsurprisingly led to a steady stream of personal, and often borderline libelous commentary.

In 2008 Mumbrella was born, and founder Tim Burrowes admits he was “surprised” by the culture which sprung up around commenting on the site, quickly moving to pre-moderation, filtering the most dangerous remarks. AdNews and B&T soon followed suit, and suddenly the advertising industry had multiple channels to air their thoughts and frustrations.

Comments taken from the threads of various industry sites.

In 2008, the suicide of a creative in Chicago was attributed to vitriol sprayed at him on a US industry site with unmoderated comments. This led to consternation amongst many creatives, and in 2011 the Communications Council tried to organise a round-table event for editors from the various trade press to discuss the issue, but it was called off at the last minute and never made it back onto the agenda.

According to Burrowes, the move by all the sites to pre-moderation has led to a dampening down of the vitriol, with the truly personal attacks and most libelous comments never published.

Despite this he admits: “Every single time we post about a creative agency’s work, it brings out the worst behaviour. Unfortunately that behaviour has become normalised within the agencies. It might be those behaviours formed very early on, but we see different levels in creative than in other parts of the industry.”

Campaign Brief founder Michael Lynch says the vast majority of negative comments are about the campaigns themselves, rather than the people who created them.

“Although they take it personally, they’re normally about it being a really crap ad,” he says. “It’s more often than not about the work. I think people are honest if ads are good or bad. It’s the bad agencies that are scared, that’s the real truth.”

Both admit there is a problem with some agencies taking to comment threads to slag off rivals, especially if there has been a contentious pitch, although there is also the phenomenon of “astroturfing”, with agencies posting positive comments en-masse to make their work look better.

Burrowes adds it can be a challenge knowing when to moderate commentary, especially when a slew of personal comments come through from different people about the same person: “You wonder whether you’re stopping people from having a fair say at some points”.

But, both Hourigan and McFarlane say the tone of some commentary makes the industry look unprofessional, both to clients and to the international community. “How does their (clients’) agency look when they go to the industry blogs and see their new campaign trashed?” adds McFarlane.

“They’ll feel embarrassed, and then they’ll blame their agency. The knock-on effect is less trust next time they are presented with a less-than-orthodox creative approach.”

Hourigan says while other countries do have sites allowing anonymous commenting, which attract derogatory comments, “it doesn’t seem to have the impact and power”, with many of the international talent he has recruited telling him they are “shocked” by the culture on the sites.

Both say the culture is stifling creativity within the industry, with would-be innovators increasingly playing safe, for fear of a backlash. Hourigan adds: “Creatives should feel free and be supported by their own. Where is the nurturing support? If people put their names to opinion, it would stop so much of the negativity, and force bullies to stop hiding behind the internet.”

But the right for anonymous commentary is defended by both Burrowes and Lynch, who say it allows readers to have the safety to express their honest opinions, while sign-up processes are inevitably laborious, and time-consuming, and ultimately put people off contributing.

Lynch adds: “It doesn’t work. Everyone’s shit scared, no matter who they are they don’t even want to be seen as liking something because other people will come after them. They’d rather stay anonymous, even if it’s a good piece.”

Burrowes also points to those who are able to contribute because of their anonymity adding real value to debates and clearing up misconceptions, where they would otherwise be forced to stay silent.

But McFarlane is quick to dismiss the notion of anonymity facilitating free speech and honest debate. “Frankly how can it be honest discussion if you don’t know who you are talking to?” he says.

“Would anybody watch a Geoffrey Robertson hypothetical if all the panelists were masked? Would David Stratton movie reviews have any more clout if he were anonymous? It’s absolute heresy to use the word ‘honest’ in the context of anonymous blogging.”

The Communications Council is working to quell the deluge of commentary by speaking not only to publishers, but also asking agencies to integrate their new social media guidelines into their HR policies, giving staff a stricter code of conduct.

“People on both sides need to take responsibility, and everyone needs to do more. There is still a long way to go before people in our industry feel comfortable expressing their opinion freely,” Zabel concludes.

This article first appeared in the February 15 edition of B&T Magazine.

Please feel free to leave your thoughts on this topic, either named or anonymously, below.

Please login with linkedin to comment

Latest News

Women In Media Profile: Alison Michalk
  • Media

Women In Media Profile: Alison Michalk

If B&T's Women in Media profiles were an animal they would be a gazelle or lioness, or even a lioness eating a gazelle.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
M&C Saatchi Group’s 1440 Shuts Up Shop
  • Marketing

M&C Saatchi Group’s 1440 Shuts Up Shop

Sadly, M&C Saatchi's 1440 is no more. And chances of it being reborn as 1550 not looking much chop either.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Luke Kelly Becomes A Partner At HBT
  • Advertising
  • Marketing
  • Technology

Luke Kelly Becomes A Partner At HBT

B&T's not sure what's with that twirly thing in the press photo, suffice to say a vortex to an alternate dimension?

Grant Broadcasters Makes Several Changes To Senior Executive Team
  • Media

Grant Broadcasters Makes Several Changes To Senior Executive Team

Independent media company Grant Broadcasters has announced a number of changes to its executive ranks. Grant Cameron will move up to become non-executive chairman for the company, and Alison Cameron (pictured above) – currently the chief operating officer – will assume the CEO role. Dugald Cameron remains responsible for the family’s investment portfolio and is […]

Shopper Media Group Partners With Mist To Offer New Tech & AI-Driven Capabilities
  • Advertising
  • Media

Shopper Media Group Partners With Mist To Offer New Tech & AI-Driven Capabilities

Australian retail out-of-home (OOH) business Shopper Media Group (SMG) has announced a partnership with AI-powered wireless networks provider Mist. The partnership will see SMG offer new WiFi, analytics and location-based services across the company’s portfolio of Australian shopping centres. Mist currently provides WiFi and location services using virtual Bluetooth LE technology to businesses across all […]

Indy Agency This Is Flow Wins Cruiseco’s $5 Million Media Account
  • Advertising
  • Media

Indy Agency This Is Flow Wins Cruiseco’s $5 Million Media Account

Travel organisation Cruiseco has announced the appointment of Sydney independent agency This is Flow (TIF) to handle its $5 million media account. This is the first time Cruiseco has appointed an agency, having managed its communications internally. Cruiseco is the largest and broadest distributor of cruise products in the Southern Hemisphere. With a membership base […]

Women In Media Profile: Naomi Shepherd
  • Media

Women In Media Profile: Naomi Shepherd

Need a Monday morning pick-me-up? You could stand naked next to the office fridge or read these inspiring words.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
APN Outdoor Takes Off With Queenstown Airport Contract
  • Advertising
  • Media

APN Outdoor Takes Off With Queenstown Airport Contract

Out-of-home media business APN Outdoor has won the tender for New Zealand’s Queenstown Airport. As part of the new agreement, APN Outdoor has flagged extensive development plans for Queenstown Airport’s advertising assets. The new contract adds Queenstown Airport to APN Outdoor’s existing portfolio of Auckland and Christchurch Airports. The media company will hire a South […]

Havas Secures Exclusive ‘Fight Of Champions’ Broadcast Rights With Foxtel For Australia & NZ
  • Media

Havas Secures Exclusive ‘Fight Of Champions’ Broadcast Rights With Foxtel For Australia & NZ

Havas Sports & Entertainment ANZ, a division of the broader global full-service agency Havas, has confirmed an exclusive deal with Foxtel to showcase the World Boxing Association (WBA) Welterweight Championship across the trans-Tasman. Billed as the ‘Fight of Champions’, Manny Pacquiao and Lucas Matthysse will square off for the WBA Welterweight belt this Sunday. Havas […]

The Question On Everybody’s Lips At Cannes: How Did Tesco Win The Grand Prix Media Lion?
  • Media
  • Opinion

The Question On Everybody’s Lips At Cannes: How Did Tesco Win The Grand Prix Media Lion?

In this guest post, PHD’s Chloe Hooper (pictured below) analyses the campaign that claimed top honours in the Media category at Cannes this year. I sat in the auditorium as the Cannes Media Lion winners for 2018 were awarded. One thing became instantly clear to me: it is all about taking home Gold or the Grand Prix. […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
MINI Australia Showcases New ‘Connected’ Vehicles Via Vizeum & Posterscope
  • Advertising
  • Campaigns

MINI Australia Showcases New ‘Connected’ Vehicles Via Vizeum & Posterscope

An integrated campaign by Vizeum Melbourne for MINI Australia’s new ‘Connected’ vehicles will see digital out-of-home (DOOH) served via Posterscope’s Liveposter platform. Delivered centrally, the campaign will showcase the flexible qualities DOOH provides via multiple creatives targeted with specific data overlays such as location, traffic, time of day, and weather triggers such as rain. The […]

Women In Media Profile: Lisa Sheehan
  • Media

Women In Media Profile: Lisa Sheehan

The delightful Lisa Sheehan straps into B&T's "cage of truth" we actually prefer to call our Women in Media profiles.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
News Corp, Storyful & Fox Sports Join Forces To Support AIME Hoodie Day
  • Advertising
  • Campaigns
  • Marketing
  • Media

News Corp, Storyful & Fox Sports Join Forces To Support AIME Hoodie Day

News Corp Australia, Storyful and Fox Sports have joined forces in support of 2018 AIME Hoodie Day with a creative advertising, PR, social media and editorial campaign across print, digital, and broadcast media. Fox League presenter Hannah Hollis (pictured above) fronts the AIME Hoodie Day campaign, conceptualised, designed and created by News Corp’s trade marketing […]

Storyation Finalist For Global Content Marketing Agency Of The Year
  • Marketing

Storyation Finalist For Global Content Marketing Agency Of The Year

Sydney content marketing agency Storyation has been named a finalist for global Content Marketing Agency of the Year in the Content Marketing Association Awards in the US.  The only Australian agency on the short-list, Storyation was founded by two former Fairfax Media executives Lauren Quaintance (right in photo) and Mimi Cullen (left) and its clients include Tourism […]

Jaden Social Claims Integrated Marketing Tender For NSW Schools Spectacular
  • Marketing

Jaden Social Claims Integrated Marketing Tender For NSW Schools Spectacular

Jaden Social has been awarded the tender to handle integrated marketing for the NSW Schools Spectacular. The agreement will see Jaden Social manage marketing, media, digital and social across the 2018 to 2020 productions of Schools Spectacular, held at Qudos Bank Arena in November. Jaden Social underwent a competitive pitch to secure the account, in […]

APD Australia Appoints New Head Of Digital Product & Strategy
  • Marketing
  • Technology

APD Australia Appoints New Head Of Digital Product & Strategy

Digital transformation business APD has announced the appointment of Chris Butterworth as its Australian head of digital product and strategy. Based in Melbourne, Butterworth (pictured above) will be responsible for building on APD’s owned media team, growing its range of services and developing cross-channel products. Butterworth joins APD from Reprise Digital, where he was most […]