Why Brands Spend Too Much On Social Media: Emotion Tops Logic
In this guest post, Strohfeldt Consulting founder and creative director, and advertising veteran, Robert Strohfeldt has a bone to pick with brands who insist on wasting their time with social media.
Professor Mark Ritson has been causing quite an uproar lately (or using today’s terminology “disruption”) by his claim that social media is overrated. He has since ratchetted up the emotion in the debate by stating marketers who rely on social media are “poorly trained idiots“.
Using a line from old spaghetti westerns “Thems fighten words”. Proponents of social media read his comments and arc up. I think it is a deliberate ploy by Ritson, because it is emotion that has driven social media to the heights it has now attained within the marketing and advertising worlds. (As opposed to any cold, objective logic).
The over emphasis on social media has been the elephant in the room for quite a number of years now. Finally, someone has come out and laid bare the facts. Ritson spells out very clearly why he takes this stance in his presentation in Canada late last year. (Though in Canada, he uses Australian examples and the principals apply equally here).
Before saying “bullshit”, have a look at his presentation. He quantifies what so many have garnered anecdotally, but have been reluctant to comment on and exposes the many myths about social media.
I doubt there is anyone in the industry who does not know about the “legendary” Oreo tweet during the 2013 Super Bowl broadcast blackout? I have lost count of the number of times I have read about “striving to create their own Oreo moment”.
Well, the “Tweet that was heard around the world”, was in fact seen by around 65,000 people. Or just 0.02 per cent of Oreo’s customer base. This was deemed to have “beaten” a well- crafted 60 second Budweiser TVC, which was seen by 50 million viewers. Yep, 65,000 versus 50 million is now deemed a ‘victory”. It achieved bugger all, except for a swag of awards. (More people in the advertising industry saw the tweet than existing and potential customers).
But you don’t need deep and meaningful statistical analysis to come to the conclusion that social media is overrated. Sure, it has been one of the most far reaching phenomena in human history. But it is SOCIAL media. It is about people, not brands.
Shane Warne has some 2.6 million Twitter followers. No brand in Australia comes close to that number. Ritson notes that as a relatively unknown marketing professor in Canada, he has more Twitter followers than the top 10 Canadian brands combined.
There is much talk about advertising being dead, or on its last legs. So people don’t like ads, but they will go to a brand’s Facebook page and read, sorry, engage with, the “content”? What a croc!
Well, they may enjoy the content, but it will have stuff all to do with the product or brand the Facebook page is for. Pick any big brand’s Facebook page and check out the number of people who view, like, or share. And of course, some of these figures go back for five, six or more years.
If people don’t like ads, why do TV programmes featuring “world’s funniest/best commercials” rate so highly? They don’t like shitty ads. But great creative always has and always will cut through.
And with the social media presence, brands are becoming anthropomorphic – acting as if a person, with the goal of building “relationships” with consumers. We are starting to take ourselves way too seriously. What’s next – online Dorothy Dix advice for brands?
- Should I expose my label on our first date?
- What if he/she is seeing another brand?
- Ten tips when meeting the family
Or Agony Aunt for people on how to “engage” with brands?
- My favourite brand passed away six months ago. Is it too soon to start seeing other brands?
- My favourite brand gets jealous so easily. How can I tell them I am only friends with these other brands?
- How do I know when I am ready to settle down with just one brand? I can’t help myself when I see an attractive brand.
I am being a tad harsh. There are a number of areas in which social media can play an important role – market research, local area marketing for franchised retail chains, tactical promotions etc. But it is definitely not for front line strategic brand and image building. And depending upon the type of business, social media will be more useful than for others e.g. fashion.
But most of the “literature” takes a one size fits all approach.
But as Ritson points out in his presentation, social media comprises 45 per cent or more of the coverage in major industry publications, as opposed to around eight per cent of advertising budgets. While over 50 per cent of editorial talks about the death of traditional media.
The lack of recognition of the strength and relevance of mainstream media is a major issue. A colleague referred to this as marketing fashion over function – traditional media is old fashioned. Many marketers want the latest, shiny new tools, even if their reach and effectiveness is questionable at best.
A recent example comes in an article I saw had the headline “Young Viewers Switch Off TV”. The “doom and gloom” figures are in bold. Nearly one in five of 14 to 24 year olds don’t watch any Free to Air TV. That could be written as “Over 80 per cent of 14 to 24 year olds still watch Free to Air TV”. Conclusion. Free to Air still most single powerful advertising medium.
You get the idea. The industry is inundated with stories on how wonderful social media is and traditional media is all but dead. Ritson also points out the ludicrous situation where two thirds of marketing directors/managers surveyed are unsure of their ROI from social media, yet two thirds say they intend to increase their social budget. Can you imagine that happening for any other form of media?
The media landscape has changed dramatically over the past 20 years and become far more fragmented, so logic dictates that an integrated approach is now critical, unavoidable. But even so, a brand (B2C) of any significance can survive without social media, but not traditional media advertising. (Apple, as an example, didn’t do too badly).
It is 2016, not 2026. Plan for the future but live in the present. As mentioned previously, it is emotion driving the social media circus. The people who work in social media, be it agency or client side, are of course strongly emotively attached to social media. It is their livelihood and in most cases, probably all, an integral part of their everyday life.
Call anyone a fool and you are liable to get a negative reaction. Call someone a fool because of their love for and involvement in a particular pursuit and you can expect a strong reaction. No other form of advertising medium has ever, or does now, involve the practitioner in such a manner – they don’t just “work on it”, “they live in it.”
Latest News
The Mars Agency Announces Latest Findings Of Retail Media Report Card
The Mars Agency has developed a scorecard that assesses the capabilities of leading platforms across key criteria required to optimally plan, execute, and measure effective retail media programs. The scorecard aims To help brands efficiently evaluate their spending options across retail media networks in Australia (and New Zealand). With spending on retail media advertising in […]
‘It’s The Lesser Of Two Evils’ – NRL Eyes US Betting Market As Aussie Regulators Circle
US betting firms will be delighted by the circa 50,000 Americans who could soon watch the NRL on their favourite app.
A-League In Deep Discussions With New Partner To Keep Games On TV After Production Company Enters Administration
The A-League's insatiable appetite for scoring own goals continues.
TV Ratings (27/03/2024): Jungle Members At War Over Concealed Lipstick
A heated argument between two jungle members did the numbers for Ten last night, with I’m A Celeb obtaining a total national reach of 1,282,000. Fans were delighted as Candice Warner and influencer Skye Wheatley got into it over a stick of lipstick, leading Warner to dub the Instagram star “selfish.” Wheatley, best known for […]
Is The Australian Music Industry In Trouble? Inquiry Launched Following Splendour Cancellation
Earlier this week, an inquiry was launched into the challenges and opportunities currently facing the Australian live music industry in the wake of multiple festival cancellations. On 25 March 2024, the Minister for the Arts, the Hon. Tony Burke MP, asked the Committee on Communications and the Arts to inquire into and report on the […]
Liana Dubois, Leandro Perez, Aimee Buchanan & More Gather For Inaugural Compadres Leadership Event
Didn't get the invite? Perhaps you're not as important as you thought.
Cathay Captures The Unforgettable Thrill Of Cathay/HSBC Hong Kong Rugby Sevens, Via Publicis
Nobody does rugby like Hong Kong, apparently. Certainly nobody does it as badly as Australia.
Cocogun Nabs Christine Watts, Kirsty Reynolds & Shev Tan Bolstering Management & Creative Teams
Cocogun bolsters its team with new hires. Committed to purchasing a bigger sofa, too.
The Media Store’s Jacquie Alley & Sam Cousins Take The Plunge With Pro-Bono Work For Cure Cancer
B&T chats with The Media Store bosses about their great pro-bono work and sponsored swim.
Hawke’s Brewing Co. Taps Rocket Comms For PR Agency Following Competitive Pitch
We're expecting Rocket Comms productivity to crash in spectacular fashion following this win.
Spotlight On Sponsors: Patties Serves Up A Taste Of Home For Olympians & South Sydney Rabbitohs Recommit To Gambling Reform
While the Rabbitohs commits to gambling reform, B&T reckons the team should commit to a decent auto sponsor.
Google: “Inevitable” That Bad Actors Will Abuse Ads Platform As Advertiser Account Suspensions Double
Google maintains it's simply impossible for it to entirely stop bad people placing & paying for ads using its service.
Quantcast Expands APAC Sales Team With Appointment Of News Corp Account Manager
No pressure at all when you are appointed as a client success manager.
Publicis Sapient Tests Microsoft-Powered Gen AI Search Tool With Homes & Villas By Marriott Bonvoy
Given Gen AI's record for mangling stuff, B&T cannot see the problem with letting it decide your next holiday digs.
Volkswagen & DDB Group’s “Roo Badge” To Reduce Kangaroo Related Road Collisions
Watch out for RooBadge as Cannes Lions' most debated campaign this year.
Twilio Launches Unified Profiles & Agent Copilot Features To Boost Productivity & Engagement
Agent Copilot sounds like James Bond's less interesting cousin.
Reebok & Honda Among New Clients For onetwo agency
OneTwo finally lives up to its name with this double billing.
Ogilvy Report: Throw Out The Social Strategy Rule Book, The Rules Of The Past No Longer Apply
B&T was puzzled that all 'influencers' aren't, effectively, 'virtual', but here we are.
WhiteGREY & AKQA Merge In Australia, Lee Simpson Departs
Fortunately, the combined agencies aren't opting for a trite portmanteau for the new name.
Splendour In The Grass 2024 Music Festival Cancelled!
Music fans all over the country reportedly relieved they can pack away their rain coats and gumboots for another year.
TV Ratings (26/03/2024): “Fairy Bread, F***ing Disgusting”: Gordon Ramsay Slams Aussie Food In Food Stars Launch
Ramsay not one for mincing his words, even when it comes to minced meat pies.
Paramount+ International Boss Doubles Down On Aussie Content, Says Ad-Tier will Grow Audiences And Revenue
Good news as Paramount will not be binning I’m A Celebrity for re-runs of Frasier.
Brent Smart: Telstra Pushing For 50-50 Brand-Performance Split But Warns Numbers ‘Won’t Look Great’ Initially
The old brand vs performance debate continues. But here, Brent is firmly sitting on the fence.
Crowded House, Tones And I & Dom Dolla Win Big At The Shure Rolling Stone Music Awards
B&T staffer reports back with humdinger of a hangover & feeling seriously uncool after mixing with music types.
Opinion: Dyslexia “A Hidden Gem” For Brands & Agencies
Dyslexics offer underappreciated benefits in the corporate field, according to this op-ed.
David Jones Taps Criteo To Power Online Retail Media Arm
Want to see ads for things you probably can't afford? David Jones has got you covered with new retail media play.
oOh!media Sets Up Team To Target Business Audiences Across Airports & Offices
oOh! wants brands to harass you every minute of your next business trip.
QMS Launches Australian First DOOH & TV Partnership With Samba TV
Samba TV, of course, is not a channel dedicated to dancing. Much to our dismany.
Slew Of New Hires At Amplify
Four new faces join the Amplify offices. Team say desk scarcity becoming "acute".
Adobe Announces Content Authenticity Initiative Expansions To Counter Deep Fakes
Try as they might to enlighten them, we suspect Trump supporters will continue to watch and believe Fox News.
The PR Group Appoints TechCrunch Senior Reporter Catherine Shu As Director Of Content & Media
Catherine Shu makes the bold leap from journalism to PR. Says inevitable pay bump was "unrelated".
HERO Nabs Ebony Santin From AMPR
Rumours Santin cleared out the stationery cupboard before departing are as yet unconfirmed.
Karena Noble Checks Out Of EVT Hotels & Resorts To Launch Comms Consultancy
Noble still managed to squeezed in a continental breakfast before departing.
Canva Acquires Design Platform Affinity To Bring Professional Design Tools To Every Organisation
Canva & Adobe face off continues. We're not picking sides but keenly aware that Canva's office is next door to ours.
“Lean On Our Team To Help You Find An Audience”: Why Understanding Audience Engagement Is Essential In Journalism
Engaging the audience is critical to journos, apparently. We'd thought self-loathing & alcoholism were key.
Adobe Summit: Major Gen AI Developments, Data Concessions & Partnerships
What happens in Vegas stays there. Unless it's the Adobe Summit and then you get to read about in B&T.