Why Beating Up Google Over Search Results Is A Double Standard Indeed

Why Beating Up Google Over Search Results Is A Double Standard Indeed
SHARE
THIS



In this opinion piece, Anna Russell, director at Polynomial, a Sydney-based analytics and strategy consultancy, argues it’s wrong to beat-up on Google over massaging search results when everybody’s playing the same game…

The economics of internet content pivot around advertising – paying for the right eyeballs and clicks – which imposes an implicit bias on all that is displayed. If regulators are going to go after Google for tailoring search results, should they go after publishers for using audience targeting or tailored homepage content to users?

Perhaps they should slap Amazon on the wrist for offering up ‘next logical purchase’ items that differ between buyers. Whilst there is some validity in preventing a dominant player from acting like a monopoly, wrapping the critique in a consumer welfare coat is a poor argument.

Recent studies into the way Google presents search results have once again caused consumers to questions whether Google abandoned its ‘do no evil’ mandate in search of greater profits? Or is it just trying to make a buck fair and square?

Over recent months, Google’s trouble with EU regulators over alleged violation of antitrust rules has made front page news.

The European Competition Commission filed antitrust charges against Google in April this year, pivoting around the assertion that Google’s decision to place paid search listings at the top of search results means Google is manipulating search to grow it’s advertising business – and that by doing so it is harming competitors and consumers alike.

This isn’t the first time the search giant has faced antitrust proceedings – numerous complaints of anti-competitive behaviour have been lodged over the last 5 years in the EU and in 2011 Google fronted court in Ohio to battle (and win) an antitrust allegation in which it was alleged to be giving preferential results to Google owned entities in its search results.

Fanning the flames of the latest allegations, Columbia Law School’s Tim Wu, (pictured below) a former Google ally and respected internet theorist, has released a paper asserting that Google’s decision to bias search results towards paid listings has serious antitrust and consumer wellbeing implications.

Some description

In the paper, called Is Google degrading Search? Consumer harm from universal search co-authored with Harvard Business School professor Michael Luca, Wu is strongly critical of Google’s actions, claiming that rather than enhancing the relevance of results, the implementation of paid search prioritisation contradicts the organic ‘best results’ rankings of Google’s famously neutral Pagerank algorithm.

This, Wu and Luca claim, means the ‘product enhancement’ of paid search prioritisation is not pro-competitive as Google asserts, and may in fact have negative welfare effects on the end consumer. This is an attention-grabbing claim but there are some troubling things about the paper’s logic and provenance that dilute the veracity of its claims.

Firstly, the paper makes some dangerous leaps of logic, most profoundly its fallacious assumption that just because a business or site ranks highly on Pagerank it implicitly offers a ‘better’ product or service to the consumer.

We respectfully suggest that the quality of one’s SEO is not necessarily indicative of one’s ability to provide superior service, but more an indication of how SEO-savvy one’s web design agency is. Secondly, Wu and Luca are not exactly operating from a position of neutrality: the research around which the paper is based was sponsored by rival search and listings provider Yelp, which most certainly has a vested interest in seeing Google’s dominance taken down a notch.

It’s clear that Google’s near monopoly and willingness to use its dominance to its own advantage has ruffled both regulatory and commercial feathers. Whilst the regulatory furore is easily articulated and understood as being a matter of legislative non-compliance, the wider issues raised in Wu’s paper, specifically that Google’s choice to favour paid content is both damaging its competitors and reducing the welfare of consumers is worth further interrogation.

Just google undertow

On the surface, the indignation is around a dominant player making it harder for smaller players to compete, however one suspects that there is an undercurrent of worry as to just how smart and subtle Google can be in its search ranking bias. If organic rankings can be over-ridden for commercial end, might Google also start adjusting the Pagerank algorithm in other ways to invisibly alter the ‘reality’ of the internet?

When it comes to the idea that search bias may cause ‘harm’ to consumers, the paper seems to have ‘nanny state’ inclinations. With all due respect to Professor Wu’s impeccable academic credentials, his position on this matter suggests much time spent in the ivory towers of academia, and little in the dog-eat-dog world of technology commercialisation.

Whilst concerns about intentional bias and consumer harm have validity from a social equity/ consumer care perspective, Wu and Luca miss a critical point – it’s not jut Google, and it’s not a new thing.

Google is, and has been for the last 15 years, a viable and at times hugely profitable commercial entity. And to be profitable, Google has to sell things – like priority search rankings, advertising and local search listings. The approach is very similar to that of advertorial and paid content in media sites, and to their credit Google makes no effort to obfuscate this.

Wu’s research brings to the forefront a consumer expectation from the early, non-commercial days of the internet that content would be neutral, raw and truthful, and assumes that consumers still have this expectation today. Whilst this may be true of certain demographics, in today’s highly commercialised digital ecosystem it is improbable that most Internet users are so naïve as to expect commercially produced content or services to be neutral of bias.

This article originally appeared at www.which-50.com

Latest News

QUT Creative Enterprise Australia Accepts 10 Start-Ups Into Its Creative Tech Accelerator
  • Technology

QUT Creative Enterprise Australia Accepts 10 Start-Ups Into Its Creative Tech Accelerator

QUT Creative Enterprise Australia (CEA) has announced the 10 start-ups that have been accepted in its Collider Accelerator. The three-month accelerator is a proud Australian first which is carving the way for start-ups specialising across the creative tech verticals. Commencing this week, the 10 participating companies will receive coaching from international mentors and deep domain […]

The Works Launches Podcast With RXP Services & Global Law Firm Norton Rose Fulbright
  • Advertising
  • Technology

The Works Launches Podcast With RXP Services & Global Law Firm Norton Rose Fulbright

Expert insights on what’s trending in the world of technology, data and innovation will be discussed in a new podcast powered by The Works, digital services consultancy RXP Services, and global law firm Norton Rose Fulbright. The Smart Dust podcast – named after micro-electromechanical computers that that can be breathed in to monitor the human […]

Why We Need To Make Consequences Cool
  • Opinion

Why We Need To Make Consequences Cool

Here at B&T, we have a trendy communal black leather jacket for staff to wear while suffering consequences.

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Lovatts Media Acquires Nourish Magazine From Blitz Publications
  • Media

Lovatts Media Acquires Nourish Magazine From Blitz Publications

Lovatts Media has purchased Nourish magazine from Blitz Publications in a last-minute deal that has ensured the title continues to be published in Australia. Rachael Northey, CEO of Lovatts Media, believes the demand for high-quality niche magazines is growing rather than declining. Building on the successful 2017 launches of their popular mindfulness titles Breathe, Teen […]

Women In Media Profile: Elaine Herlihy
  • Advertising
  • Marketing

Women In Media Profile: Elaine Herlihy

If you've come here looking for Elaine Herlihy's famed scone recipe then it'll be the only disappointment you'll endure.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Thrive PR + Communications Opens Fifth Office & Appoints New Staff
  • Marketing

Thrive PR + Communications Opens Fifth Office & Appoints New Staff

Independent PR agency Thrive PR + Communications has announced the launch of its fifth office, opening its doors permanently on the Gold Coast and making multiple team appointments. In response to client demand, and embracing the growth of Australia’s emerging innovation hotspot, the Gold Coast will be Thrive’s second Queensland location following the opening of […]

China Social Solutions Reveal The Massive Market Brands Are Missing
  • Partner Content

China Social Solutions Reveal The Massive Market Brands Are Missing

Advertising, in its essence, is about reaching the largest number of people, in the most seamless, creative way. However, reaching a large audience can often be the biggest hurdle, so how does a crowd of a few hundred million users sound? Weibo, China’s answer to Facebook, WhatsApp, Instagram and every other app combined, has hit […]

Partner Content

by China Social Solutions logo

How To Thrive In An Age Of Disruption
  • Opinion

How To Thrive In An Age Of Disruption

Has the age of disruption left you fearful? Well, you'll be singing Helen Reddy's 'I Am Woman, Hear Me Roar' after this.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Monash University And Y&R Melbourne Launch Wristbands To Deter Drink-Spikers
  • Campaigns
  • Technology

Monash University And Y&R Melbourne Launch Wristbands To Deter Drink-Spikers

Y&R Melbourne has an innovative wristband on campus at Monash University that detect drugs by simply placing a drop of your drink onto the band itself. Designed for widespread use across festivals, events, bars, nightclubs and other venues where patrons are already accustomed to using wristbands, the ‘Sip Safe’ wristband is equal parts a utility, […]

Global Brand Events Agency INVNT Opens Sydney Office
  • Marketing

Global Brand Events Agency INVNT Opens Sydney Office

Brand events agency INVNT has announced it has expanded its operations to the Asia-Pacific region with a new office in Sydney. Originally founded in New York in 2008 by Scott Cullather and Kristina McCoobery, INVNT creates and produces brand engagements for every audience segment, including employees, customers, partners, investors, the media, and consumers. Cullather said […]

The Copyright Agency Invites Visual Artists To Claim Image Royalties
  • Media

The Copyright Agency Invites Visual Artists To Claim Image Royalties

The Copyright Agency is inviting Australian artists and their heirs to nominate about where their works have been published or used on TV to receive payment for their copyright-protected work as part of a month-long campaign. The Copyright Agency, which recently merged with Viscopy, is Australia’s national copyright licensing organisation for the publishing, media, surveying […]

Pac Mags’ Emily Sak Joins Shopper Media Group As Its First Data & Insights Chief
  • Marketing
  • Media

Pac Mags’ Emily Sak Joins Shopper Media Group As Its First Data & Insights Chief

Digital retail out-of-home media business Shopper Media Group has announced the appointment of Emily Sak to the newly created position of head of data and insights. The new role forms part of Shopper Media Group’s expansion plan to keep up with the accelerated growth that has seen its portfolio surpass more than 220 shopping centres […]

CX Lavender Appoints Business Development Director For Melbourne
  • Marketing

CX Lavender Appoints Business Development Director For Melbourne

Customer experience agency CX Lavender has announced the appointment of Michael Rummery to the role of business development director for Melbourne. Rummery (pictured above) was previously account director of client services at global marketing and digital recruitment firm Aquent, and has held roles at a number of talent agents and recruitment firms with a focus […]

The New York Times Appoints WeThinkMedia As Its Aussie Advertising Rep
  • Advertising
  • Media

The New York Times Appoints WeThinkMedia As Its Aussie Advertising Rep

The New York Times Company has announced the appointment of media representation agency WeThinkMedia to represent its advertising business in Australia. WeThinkMedia will be responsible for all advertising in the region, including print, digital, branded content, programmatic, and events. The partnership will be overseen by Tom Armstrong, vice president of advertising for The New York […]

The Future Of Influencer Marketing: More Than Just A One-Night Stand
  • Marketing
  • Opinion

The Future Of Influencer Marketing: More Than Just A One-Night Stand

Influencers are the new powerhouses in driving stock off shelves, but brands are yet to find the right recipe for successful collaboration, according to Guillaume Deront of Gleam Futures @ The Story Lab (pictured below). Here, he argues that marketers need to look beyond purely targeting an audience and channel their energy towards building long-term […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Designing Cultural And Organisational Change
  • Opinion

Designing Cultural And Organisational Change

In this guest post, Bronwyn Van Der Merwe (pictured below), managing director of Fjord Australia and New Zealand (part of Accenture Interactive), details the four traits of a ‘living business’ – something she believes organisations have to become in order to transform successfully. The digital age has created a plethora of challenges for modern organisations, […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Facebook founder and CEO Mark Zuckerberg arrives to testify during a Senate Commerce, Science and Transportation Committee and Senate Judiciary Committee joint hearing about Facebook on Capitol Hill in Washington, DC, April 10, 2018. / AFP PHOTO / SAUL LOEB        (Photo credit should read SAUL LOEB/AFP/Getty Images)
  • Media

Free TV Calls For ACCC Oversight Of Facebook & Google

In a submission lodged with the ACCC inquiry into digital platforms, industry body Free TV today called for greater regulatory oversight of Facebook and Google. The FreeTV submission identifies a number of key areas of concern: Heavy regulation on traditional media providers and almost none on Facebook and Google Questionable claims about the reach, viewability, […]

APN Outdoor Confirms Retention Of Three Key Contracts
  • Media

APN Outdoor Confirms Retention Of Three Key Contracts

APN Outdoor has used its annual general meeting to announce three key contract renewals: Transport for Brisbane, Transdev Melbourne and Adelaide & Parafield Airports, for multiple years. Company CEO and managing director, James Warburton, said: “These contracts represent an important part of our advertising offering. The far-reaching impact they provide delivers a compelling proposition and cements our commitment […]

Women In Media Profile: Olivia Warren
  • Media

Women In Media Profile: Olivia Warren

It's the latest in our Women In Media profiles, and this one is so good you'll possibly get a nervous twitch somewhere.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
LIDA Delivers Series Of Animated Info Bites For Busy Marketers
  • Marketing
  • Media

LIDA Delivers Series Of Animated Info Bites For Busy Marketers

M&C Saatchi Group’s customer engagement specialist agency, LIDA, has crafted an initial eight-episode series of bite-sized animated videos designed to help busy marketers stay ahead of the game. ‘60 Second Gets’ draws on LIDA’s wealth of experience to unpack the latest industry tools, tech and thinking. Launching today, the first video, ‘Success in 6 Seconds’, […]

Naked And Gidget Foundation Want Australians To Start Talking
  • Campaigns

Naked And Gidget Foundation Want Australians To Start Talking

Today Naked launches its ‘Start Talking’ campaign for Gidget Foundation Australia; a not-for-profit that provides support for families who are affected by perinatal depression and anxiety (PNDA). The centrepiece of the campaign is a powerful TVC that brings to life this common, but often hidden illness, and shows how Gidget Foundation’s ‘Start Talking’ telehealth program […]

MKTG Integrates Telstra Tracker Data With LED Signage At AFL Stadiums
  • Marketing
  • Technology

MKTG Integrates Telstra Tracker Data With LED Signage At AFL Stadiums

For the first time ever, AFL spectators will be able to view real-time Telstra Tracker player data via in-stadium LED signage, thanks to the combined efforts of Telstra, Champion Data and MKTG. By integrating the Telstra Tracker data into the LED signage at the MCG and Etihad Stadium, fans will receive contextually relevant information from […]

Westfield Shows Off New Visual Identity In Line With Fresh Digital Offering
  • Marketing

Westfield Shows Off New Visual Identity In Line With Fresh Digital Offering

Scentre Group has unveiled a new brand look and feel coinciding with the re-launch of the Westfield.com.au and Westfield.co.nz sites. This digital-first visual identity sees a shift towards creating a more contemporary, invigorated and colourful brand, reflective of Westfield’s in-centre experience. The iconic Westfield logo will continue to lead brand communications, supported with a new […]

The Age Of The Ephemeral: Why Experiential Marketing Is Compulsory This Year
  • Marketing
  • Opinion

The Age Of The Ephemeral: Why Experiential Marketing Is Compulsory This Year

In this guest post, Keep Left’s head of consumer engagement, Johanna Murray (pictured below), explains the merits of experiential marketing, as well as sharing some tips on how to do it – and do it well. Humans love to label things – especially intangible things, like time. We like eras and ages and eons because they […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
The Top Social Media Marketing Trends For 2018
  • Advertising
  • Marketing
  • Technology

The Top Social Media Marketing Trends For 2018

This trends report is a must-read for all marketers, although it contains no news on the return of the bubble perm.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
How To Give And Take Feedback At Work
  • Opinion

How To Give And Take Feedback At Work

Georgia Murch (pictured below) is an expert in creating feedback cultures and author of Feedback Flow; The Ultimate Illustrated Guide to Embed Change in 90 Days. In this guest post, Murch offers her tips on giving (and receiving) feedback from colleagues without botching it up… We all know that feedback matters.  Most of us want the good, the bad and the […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Dentsu X Expands Operations To Sydney
  • Advertising
  • Media

Dentsu X Expands Operations To Sydney

Have you completely forgotten what Sydney looks like? Well, thankfully this story comes with a handy pictorial reminder.