Sure, Digital’s Getting All The Dollars, But No One Remembers The Ads!
It’s B&T columnist extraordinaire Robert Strohfeldt to the rescue once again. In today’s piece he argues that adland’s undoubtedly seen a momentous shift to the digital stratosphere, but when it comes to remembering the actual creative, it would appear consumers have all contracted Alzheimer’s…
The research commissioned by Magnum Opus Partners (Think Tank Global), highlights the growing result of the obsession with “Digital First” and the relegation of the message (creative) to a poor second behind media planning and buying.
“57% of Aussies cannot recall an ad they feel positive about” (Compared to past where have traditionally been clear winners).
Stephen Yolland, from MOP, sums it up well:“We also suspect that the big switch of media dollars into online has resulted in a fall in product and brand awareness from the days when the vast majority of media money was spent on TV. Nearly two billion Australian advertising dollars now go into online. That’s a huge switch in advertiser behaviour. Where that growth in online expenditure has replaced expenditure in other mediums, as opposed to supplementing it, there may well have been a fall in both ad and brand standout.”
Online ads might be useful – indeed they are, just as with any medium – but we think these findings suggest that they are pretty much useless in terms of creating brand positivity, as they are nearly always transactional in nature. And frankly, it is very hard to convey emotion in a banner ad or create an emotional connection with it, when all’s said and done.”
Then there is mobile – I subscribe to and most days receive papers and advice on mobile. Mostly they all make sense (though I go through them like most people do with junk mail and decide in a second whether to read or delete) – generally common sense that any person with solid sales experience would agree with. (Though frequently packaged in acronyms and buzz words and phrases to make it appear more complex than it really is.) One issue is rarely, if ever addressed. The average consumer is not just going to receive your well- crafted Push Notifications, In App Messages etc. They will also be getting thousands of others – you are not the only person who wants to use mobile to sell (or I should say market) to them. As with banner ads, the higher the regard for the product or service, the greater the chance of the being the handful that get through. (Out some 13,000 brands the average consumer encounters in just one year).
Highly regarded/desired brands can run effective, simple retail offer advertising (in all forms) as the success of these activities is predicated on a strong brand franchise. The advertising does nothing to enhance the image of the brand. It is simply leveraging a brand image that has already been built. Of course, each element of the 4Ps must be working in harmony to achieve this highly regarded brand image. (Product, Price, Place/Distribution and Promotion) and great advertising is not going to help a poor or overly priced product. (May do more harm than good).
These research results are an early warning sign of the longer consequences of a “digital first” strategy and a world in which media is thought of as the advertising solution, not part of it.
We are continuously told how “everything is different today”. Consumer behaviour will change with shifts in technology, but human behaviour does not. (Convenience and price have always been major drivers. On-line shopping, offers this. But we are social animal and there are also products people will want to see, touch and try before buying, so bricks and mortar will always have a place). Emotion plays a major role in high image products – From long established fashion brands such as Armani to new “uber cool” brands such as Supreme, logic takes a back seat to emotion. If the purchase was based purely on logic, then no one would pay the huge price premiums for products that can be identically produced for a fraction of the cost.
Supermarkets have discovered that many FMGC brands can no longer ask for the price premium over what are essentially house brands. Today, house or generic brands have changed their approach from when they first appeared using names such as “No Frills” in horrible two colour (blue and white) packaging. The idea was to make them look cheap and they succeeded at doing this.
I have mentioned numerous times the propensity of today’s marketers to take a “one size fits all approach”. Many years ago, I ran focus groups for J&B scotch with young, high-achieving males. One respondent from a group of young investment bankers summed up the prevailing attitude with the statement:“If I kick a goal and bring home a girl, I would not have any concern about her seeing “No Frills” orange juice in my fridge, but I would not want her to see “No Frills” after shave in my bathroom.”
This may offend some of today’s politically correct, but nothing has really changed and it demonstrates the difference emotion and image plays in different product categories.
Digital advertising has many advantages, but it also has major weaknesses which rarely, or are ever addressed by the media players. Take the current logic and approach back to the pre-digital era and the media solution for most products would be 1 column x 1 cm ads in newspapers. You could buy them by the truckload and be in front of the target continuously, but what you say and how you can express it would be severely limited.
Mr Yolland was one of the very few people I have heard talk about the restrictive qualities online advertising presents. To put it bluntly, it is a lousy creative canvas in comparison to TV, radio and print. I liken banner ads to outdoor advertising. But great outdoor is more noticeable (and effective) than banner ads. The latter have an average click through rate of 0.06 per cent (lower than the failure rate of birth control) and around 40% of these are due to “fat finger syndrome” i.e. a mistake.
This is not to say online and social do not have important roles to play. But they should be viewed in the context of the type of product category and how they best fit into an integrated campaign, making use of their strengths and utilising alternatives to cover their weaknesses.
Ironic. Advertising is evolving to a point where the ads themselves are just an after- thought. Not particularly important or relevant – Unfortunately it is the consumer telling us this.
Latest News
EMG/Gravity Media Names New Managing Director
The makers of Australia's Got Talent has been a magnet for senior hires in recent times.
Opinion: Shark Tank’s Sabri Suby Slams Politicians Jumping On TikTok Ban Bandwagon
Are politicians actually scaremongering about TikTok or just fed up of you doom-scrolling in the work bogs?
TV Ratings: “Ivana Was Robbed” – Final Three Contestants Revealed On Australian Idol
B&T's unsure if these Idol contestants look extra young or whether we are as old as we feel.
Veridooh Snatches Prashand Menon From ScentreGroup
Out-of-home OOH) and digital media leader Prashand Menon (lead image) has joined OOH ad tech company Veridooh as group business director within NSW and QLD. Menon joins Veridooh from his most recent role as ScentreGroup’s group business director and brings with him more than 10 years of experience in Australian media. Previously, he held positions […]
Creative Content Studio OK COOL Answers APAC’s Call, Opening In Melbourne
Life set to get extra confusing for new agency staffers mistaking OK COOL for a pass-ag housemate text message.
Harry’s Cafe de Wheels & Hipages Launch New Pie To Fuel Tradies While On The Tools
The pies should apparently be better for tradies' health, apparently but won't be better for on-site ribbing.
Women Leading Tech’s Woman Of The Year Megan Dalla-Camina: What’s The True Cost Of Cutting DEI Spending?
Cutting DE&I spending might seem easy but you might change your mind when faced with Dalla-Camina's ire.
Thrive Introduces A Batch Of New Senior Leadership Roles
You could say that Thrive is set to thrive with these new hires. But that would be too obvious.
It’s Coming Home! Sponsors Make Subbuteo World Cup Finals Free
No idea what Subbuteo is? You clearly had a more exciting childhood than our editorial team.
Media Bigwigs Bet On Predictive Intelligence Platform Prophet In $5M Seed Funding
Prophet, profit, geddit? Must be laugh-a-minute in this startup's office.
CommsDeclare Brands Shell Energy An “Olympic Gaslighter” & Urges Agencies Not To Pitch For Creative Account
And we thought the gaslight Olympics took place in the Coogee Bay Hotel smoking area!
AFL Wins Battle With Warner Bros. As New AFL Team Is Revealed
There hasn't been this much wrangling over a cartoon animal since, well, ever!
BBC Podcasts Go Global With Amazon Music
Ironically, BBC podcasts unlikely to be available in the Amazon given the lack of signal.
Johnson & Johnson’s Former Consumer Healthcare Arm Reviews Creative
J&J inspired by Scottish term for knowledge 'ken' in its rebrand; nothing says 'wise' like a shot of Listerine.
Kat & Co Transforms Into THE WORLD OF Experiential Agency
After more than twelve years of producing experiences for some of the world’s most innovative brands, including Hermes, Van Cleef & Arpels, Louis Vuitton, and Tiffany & Co, Kat & Co has quietly metamorphosed into THE WORLD OF. THE WORLD OF is an experiential agency at the juncture of culture, technology and the human condition. […]
Adobe Brings Firefly Generative AI Into Substance 3D Workflows
Still unclear of what generative AI actually is? Steer clear of this story.
Clemenger BBDO Introduces Saucy Campaign With Declan Cleary & Lee Kum Kee
When we heard this was a saucy campaign, we thought it be the barbecue and ketchup showdown we'd been waiting for.
Gawk Acquires 40 Billboard Locations From Transad
Gawk makes it move out of VIC into NSW with acquisition. Has promised to stop going on about Melbourne nightlife.
All About Attribution: Commission Factory Releases New eBook
Ever wanted to dive deep into channel attribution? Consider this the perfect springboard.
SMG Studio Launches Risk: Global Domination X Dune Part Two
Through a licensing agreement with Legendary Entertainment, SMG Studio inked the rights to adapt Dune: Part Two into a game based on Risk: Global Domination, Hasbro’s interactive board game. Inspired by Denis Villeneuve’s cinematic masterpiece, Dune: Part Two, this new digital adaptation, RISK: Global Domination X Dune: Part Two, is poised to captivate players from […]
RMIT Study Reveals That 73% Of Employees Don’t Believe Gen AI Is Relevant
Noticing staff switching off when you tell them about gen AI? Understand why here.
Australian Eggs Launches Egg-citing New Campaign Via Connecting Plots
How do you like your eggs in the morning? We usually skip them and go straight for the darts and whisky.
Future Lions 2024 Invites Young People To Be Heard With Spotify
Future Lions, of course, is the AKQA-backed student initiative at Cannes Lions, not a feeder for the rugby team.
QMS: Taylor Swift, Lunar New Year & Mardi Gras Were Boon For OOH Market
Taylor Swift, Lunar New Year and the Sydney Gay and Lesbian Mardi Gras Festival have had a dramatic impact on the number of people moving in and around Sydney over the past month, drawing big crowds into the heart of the city and its surrounding suburbs. New data from digital outdoor company QMS reveals a […]
Legend John McEnroe Joins Pepperstone’s Team Of Global Tennis Ambassadors
Despite the deal, McEnroe remains confused about difference between above- and below-the-line marketing.
LinkedIn Launches New Thought Leader Ads For Companies To Promote Member Posts
Though LinkedIn couldn't get any more insufferable? You thought wrong.
Latrell Mitchell Smacked On Wrist After Dropping Multiple F-Bombs In Post-Match Triple M Interview
Andrew Abdo has confirmed he is not angry... just disappointed.
TV Ratings: “When You Do Love Yourself, You’re Amazing” – Is This MAFS Most Heart-breaking Split?
Hold the press. MAFS groom and bride actually shown to be nice people.
Opinion: The Only Drag Marketers Should Be Worried About
Thought Transactional Drag was a lifeless club night in Newtown? Read this and you'll think again.
AWARD School Welcomes Class Of 2024
It's best to think of AWARD School like Survivor but with pitch decks instead of swimwear.
Interest In Motorsports Reaches New Heights As Formula 1 Grand Prix Revenue Expected To Surpass $100 Million
Need to get a dull sports client some quick results? Rustle up a Netflix series and watch the dollars roll in.
Chair Rob Murray To Depart As SCA Considers ARN’s Latest Takeover Bid
Struggling to make heads or tails of the SCA & ARN saga? Add this to your woes.
Adland Legend John Singleton Separates From Seventh Wife
Singo calls it quits with seventh wife as his race with Rupert Murdoch to become the most-married man continues.
ACCC Eyes Search Competition, Citing ‘Decreasing’ Quality & Rise In Generative AI
The only decline in search quality we notice is when B&T doesn't appear at the top of Google.
“Imagine A Career Above The Clouds”: Royal Australian Air Force Launches New Campaign Via VML
Don't worry about the forthcoming war with China - at least you'll get a bird's-eye view of the apocalypse.
MKTG Launches PR & Talent Division Realigning Business Structure
Dentsu‘s MKTG Sports and Entertainment has unveiled a significant evolution, including the launch of a specialised PR and Talent Marketing division, investment in expanding its Creative Services group, and a centralised approach to brand and rights holder servicing with increased production capabilities and a strengthened in-stadium sports presentation team. Lead Image: MKTG CD Ross Allen; […]