Hey, Agency Land – It’s Still The BIG Idea, Stupid!

Hey, Agency Land – It’s Still The BIG Idea, Stupid!
SHARE
THIS



B&T’s regular guest posters, Brian Mitchell (PhD) and Evan Mitchell, the directors of Love & Wine and founders of Gen Y brand specialists HOW&Y (howandy.net) reminisce back to a time when “creativity was king” in Adland…

“It’s the economy, stupid” was the mantra behind Bill Clinton’s successful ’92 tilt at the White House. A sharp reminder to stay focused on the one big thing that really matters, in times of confusion.

The sentiment deserves dusting off for an advertising industry facing no shortage of disruption these days.

Once upon a time, a diary entry “the agency” promised fun and stimulation, clever conversation and some serious pampering. No longer – symptomatic of advertising’s fading star.

In his remorseless analysis of this loss of cachet, Madison Avenue Manslaughter, Michael Farmer dissects the causes. Some he ascribes to unavoidable forces – impact of new management philosophies, globalisation, emergence of digital specialities. But as befits a Greek tragedy, at its heart lay human factors, hubris, greed, and stubborn denial of reality.

In those days, creativity ruled. The picture Farmer paints of today is a copywriter’s hell and a bean counter’s wet dream. No longer the big idea that works, now it’s “statement of work”. Farmer’s efficiency solutions to the industry’s woes are both logical and depressing.

Twenty years ago, they might just have rescued the industry from itself, without the loss of its soul. But now the spirit of adland, its very raison d’être – creativity – has lost its privileged place. Denied even the dignity of being passed over, it’s passed off as a given.

Creativity a given – how can that be? What, all agencies are equally creative? All creative people are equally creative? Or is it that in this new world, all ideas are equally creative? The end of the “big idea” – when all ideas are big ideas. That works fine for those who believe creativity in advertising can’t be measured, and are happy to throw the baby out with the bath water.

Nature abhors a vacuum. If creativity is to take a back seat, what’s going to replace it? Currently there are two candidates, digital media and big data. Siblings, but not quite soul mates, focused on opposite ends of the funnel – the first obsessed with micro-managing what goes in, the other entranced by the possibilities of what comes out. Both have their zealous supporters.

Meanwhile, who’ll defend creativity? Plenty, still. But their arguments preach to the choir. No one with a commitment to the tech side is readily persuaded. Unless it’s those, to quote John Hegarty, who “are dependent on technology to be creative” – a distortion of the very concept.

Fact is, the big idea is a tough sell nowadays. But know what? It doesn’t matter. Creativity doesn’t need a white knight. Its status and future are secured by demographics and a generational cultural revolution. Try marketing successfully and sustainingly to a population of Gen Y-ers, without targeting their values through big ideas. The success of creativity is guaranteed by the consequences of its absence.

The industry will be saved from itself – and the winners will be those who understand that creativity can’t be taken as given. The real stuff requires real talent.

Latest News

Enero Agencies Team Up To Reveal What Makes A Brand Truly Great
  • Marketing

Enero Agencies Team Up To Reveal What Makes A Brand Truly Great

Insight and strategy consultancy The Leading Edge has conducted research into what makes a brand great. In partnership with its sister Enero group agencies Hotwire and Orchard, the report identifies five specific roads that take brands from good to great to greatness. The findings reveal that brands which encompass greatness have five distinct qualities: passionate vision, a sense […]

HP & Planet Ark Help Aussies Face Up To Plastic Pollution With Monster Installation
  • Campaigns

HP & Planet Ark Help Aussies Face Up To Plastic Pollution With Monster Installation

Australia is home to some of the deadliest predators in the world. But nothing has posed a greater threat to our environment and marine life than single-use plastic. A new report by HP and Planet Ark released last week found that Aussies rate marine plastic pollution as their top concern when it comes to environmental […]

HP & Spikes Asia Announce Finalists Of ‘Young Spikes Design Competition’
  • Media

HP & Spikes Asia Announce Finalists Of ‘Young Spikes Design Competition’

Ten teams of young creatives will vie for the prestigious Young Spikes Design Competition Award at Spikes Asia 2018, a three-day festival of creativity held between 26-28 September 2018. The competition garnered 123 submissions – the most of any Young Spikes competition – from executives aged 30 and under across the Asia Pacific and Japan. […]

Director Appointment Strengthens Corporate Affairs Specialist Wilkinson Butler
  • Media

Director Appointment Strengthens Corporate Affairs Specialist Wilkinson Butler

Corporate affairs agency Wilkinson Butler is delighted to welcome Nick Albrow to join its board as a director. Albrow joins chairman Peter Wilkinson and managing director Andrew Butler as the business builds on its reputation as one of the leading crisis and issues firms in Australia. Joining in September 2017 as an account director, Albrow has […]

Mastercard Marketing Chief Sarah Pike Exits
  • Marketing

Mastercard Marketing Chief Sarah Pike Exits

Mastercard marketing boss Sarah Pike has exited. Sadly, not via a half-pike somersault with twist, but the actual exit.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Adobe Appoints New ANZ Marketing Director
  • Marketing
  • Technology

Adobe Appoints New ANZ Marketing Director

Adobe announces new ANZ marketing 'big cheese' who's set to go by the title of marketing director and not Queen Gouda.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Publicis Media Agencies Named ‘Leaders’ By Independent Research Firm
  • Media

Publicis Media Agencies Named ‘Leaders’ By Independent Research Firm

Publicis Media agencies Zenith and Starcom were named a ‘Leader’ and a ‘Strong Performer’, respectively, in The Forrester Wave: Global Media Agencies, Q3 2018. Both agencies were among the select companies that Forrester invited to participate in this evaluation of the media agency landscape. Zenith received the second-highest score in the ‘Strategy’ and ‘Current Offering’ […]