How To Be Anti-Social

How To Be Anti-Social
SHARE
THIS



In this guest post, Edge planner Abbie Dubin Rhodin (pictured below), takes a look at a recent brand social media stuff-up and says there are plenty of lessons there for brands engaging with its customers in the social space…

When brands are trying harder than ever to appear relatable, what happens when the people tasked with representing brands can’t be bothered?

0

To start, I should state some facts. First, Deciem is a wildly popular Canadian skin care company. In addition to a number of other brands, it oversees the development, production and sales of a brand known as ‘The Ordinary’ – an affordable, minimally designed set of serums, acids, and creams that have won awards around the beauty industry. Also, the company was founded by Brandon Truaxe.

Deciem, and its discount darling line ‘The Ordinary’, are verifiable stars. With over 360,000 followers on Instagram, you’d anticipate a team of well-rehearsed social strategists would be running the show, delivering carefully curated shots of new stores, stories teasing celebrity sponsorships and constantly hyped new product launches.

Instead, you again get Brandon.

And in a world where consumers, regardless of age, gender or other standard markers of segmentation demand transparency and authenticity, having a direct line to the founder is a boon.

Right?

There are a number of interviews and think pieces across the web that would lead anyone to question the intelligence of having the mercurial and easily offended founder hold the keys to the social castle. At the same time, you can’t deny the success he’s had. And the most interesting part is that he’s following a number of social marketing constructs to the letter; specifically, the idea that to build a community, you should be there in the trenches with them, responding to comments and hearing complaints.

Brandon is definitely in the comments.

I wasn’t able to capture a shot from Deciem’s Instagram with its original caption, but the shot is of their soon-to-open 5th avenue store in New York City, with a homeless person and their belongings spread in front of the eventual entrance. I’m paraphrasing, but the caption indicated that “while the person was in the way, they wouldn’t be calling the cops, because compassion is important”. After a fair amount of acrimony in the comments, the caption was changed to “our upcoming store on Fifth Avenue. Never disrespect a harmless human in need of care. Heart emoji. Butterfly emoji.”

From a brand perspective, it’s not great, but it’s salvageable. Brands have people behind them, and those people are allowed to decide their original choice of words or phrasing wasn’t the best and make tweaks – that’s normal, and effective, mature brand building.

Here’s where an internationally renowned, well-loved, much-awarded brand went well off the rails.

Stage 1: a follower comments

 

Image 1

Stage 2: the owner of the social channel (again, in this case, the owner of the company, goes personal)

Image 2

 

Stage 3: cut back to the original photo (with edited caption) that drove the whole incident

image 3

 

Stage 4: the person in charge of a multi-national, much awarded, very powerful beauty brand links back to the private, personal page of a follower who criticised him.

image 4

 

 

This is a man, who oversees a brand that caters primarily to women, is using his personal power to drive fear into those same women. Sure, we want authenticity and transparency from brands. And as builders of those brands, we want to create something that people can relate to. Initially, The Ordinary (with Deciem behind it), achieved both those goals. With this recent bizarre shift toward eviscerating a customer for daring to question the brand’s transparent use of a disenfranchised person’s image (without their consent) in order to boost their social justice cache – we see that, with these requests that brands act like people, you get all the warts of actual people.

From just this single exchange, you can see this man’s Insta’ finger getting itchy. As a fan of the products and the brand behind them, I hope they change the account password. A brand that casts itself as a social hero by seeking to democratise an industry as hierarchical as beauty is laudable. But one that then switches and turns on its customers, while simultaneously aggravating the prejudice against the most vulnerable in our society doesn’t deserve the accolades or plaudits.

Be a brand and replace the man. Brandon, Bye.

** The heated exchange between Brandon and the commenter have now been deleted and Brandon has “apologise.

Please login with linkedin to comment

Abbie Dubin-Rhodin Edge

Latest News

Keeping Up with the Centennials: Buy Social, Pay Offline
  • Advertising
  • Media
  • Technology

Keeping Up with the Centennials: Buy Social, Pay Offline

Dentsu Aegis Network, in collaboration with Econsultancy, today launched Here Comes the Centennial: Southeast Asia’s New Generation of Shoppers. Here Comes the Centennial is a white paper investigating the online buying behaviour of centennials – consumers of the future – in the region. Launched on the sidelines of FUTR Asia 2018 Summit, the study finds […]

Tuesday TV Wrap: Ten Finds A Winner With ‘Ambulance Australia’
  • Media

Tuesday TV Wrap: Ten Finds A Winner With ‘Ambulance Australia’

Network Ten has set the sirens blaring after its fly-on-the wall doco-drama Ambulance Australia was the most watched entertainment show of Tuesday night. In just its second episode, Ambulance Australia pulled 684,000 viewers last night and was up a hefty 102,000 from last week’s debut. However, it was Seven that took last night’s honours, the network taking home […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Queensland Govt Launches ‘Find Your Happy Healthy’ Obesity Campaign Via Publicis
  • Advertising
  • Campaigns

Queensland Govt Launches ‘Find Your Happy Healthy’ Obesity Campaign Via Publicis

The Queensland Government is continuing its focus on reducing the State’s obesity rates with a transformative communications strategy and execution through agency Publicis Worldwide. Statistics reveal that 64 per cent of Queenslanders are overweight or obese. The Government’s goal is to increase the proportion of adults and children with a healthy body weight by 10 per […]

Why Influencers Should Still Be Part Of Your Plan
  • Marketing
  • Opinion

Why Influencers Should Still Be Part Of Your Plan

In this guest post, Erin Tierney (pictured below), a community consultant at Quiip, says using influencers for your brand shouldn’t be a short-term campaign element, but rather a long-term investment… Influencers. The topic creates a polar divide amongst the marketing profession, yet influencers have risen as an advertising method-of-choice, generally providing pretty pictures on social platforms in […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Viva & Taboola Bring News To 100M Mobile Users Across Asia
  • Media
  • Technology

Viva & Taboola Bring News To 100M Mobile Users Across Asia

Today, Taboola, the world’s leading discovery platform, announced a global strategic partnership with vivo, the fifth largest smartphone manufacturer in the world. Under the partnership, Taboola will deliver a fully personalised content experience for vivo’s customers helping the manufacturer drive engagement and monetisation and providing a significant new audience source to content publishers in the region. […]

Fiftyfive5 Expands APAC Presence With A Whopping 14 New Hires
  • Marketing
  • Technology

Fiftyfive5 Expands APAC Presence With A Whopping 14 New Hires

Independent research company Fiftyfive5 today announced that it has added 14 new staff across three offices following significant growth from local and global client demand. Boasting a roster of more than 100 clients, spanning Australia, New Zealand, Asia, the U.S. and Europe, Fiftyfive5 will add staff in its Sydney, Auckland and Singapore offices. In Sydney, […]

Keno & Clemenger Brisbane Team Up On New  ‘Fun Money’ Brand Platform
  • Campaigns
  • Media

Keno & Clemenger Brisbane Team Up On New ‘Fun Money’ Brand Platform

Keno and Clemenger Brisbane have teamed up to launch a new brand platform for the classic in-venue lottery game, encouraging people to spend their winnings in some weird and wonderful ways. Clemenger strategy director Erin Core said the platform was built out of an insight that money won on Keno is ‘Fun Money’. “Keno wins […]

The Yarra River Shines Bright With QMS
  • Advertising
  • Media

The Yarra River Shines Bright With QMS

The heart of Melbourne’s Southbank precinct has been transformed with the launch of QMS’ iconic digital billboard towering over the city’s famous Yarra River. The ‘Yarra Promenade’ stands tall amongst the city skyline, delivering 3.4 million contacts per month as it presides over Melbourne’s renowned Southbank and Crown Casino precinct. Its commanding CBD position captures […]

Seventh Street Media Launches Father-Focused Publication ‘The Brag Dad’
  • Media

Seventh Street Media Launches Father-Focused Publication ‘The Brag Dad’

Independent Aussie publisher Seventh Street Media has unveiled a new publication under its stable, The Brag Dad. The new publication provides important lessons and life hacks from dads who’ve been there – keeping young fathers in touch with everything they love from the outside world. While The Brag Dad is written with a larrikin tone, […]

CBS Snares Format Rights For Quiz Show ‘Have You Been Paying Attention?’
  • Media

CBS Snares Format Rights For Quiz Show ‘Have You Been Paying Attention?’

CBS Studios International has announced an agreement with Working Dog Productions for the exclusive, worldwide format rights to comedy quiz show Have You Been Paying Attention? Now in its sixth season, HYBPA? is broadcast on the CBS-owned Network Ten in Australia, and is the number one quiz show and the third-highest-rated overall show on the […]

Delacon Appoints Kenshoo Sales Chief As Director Of Operations
  • Marketing
  • Technology

Delacon Appoints Kenshoo Sales Chief As Director Of Operations

Call analytics provider Delacon has appointed Ezri Lerba to the newly created position of director of operations to manage partnerships and business development. Lerba joins Delacon after more than eight years with marketing technology company Kenshoo where he most recently held the role of director of sales across Australia and New Zealand. As first boots […]

Abstract spherical technology network background.
  • Advertising
  • Marketing
  • Media
  • Opinion
  • Technology

Why Tech Is The Best Thing That Happened To Agencies

In this opinion piece, Schedugram CEO Hugh Stephens (pictured) tackles the complexity of agency business models. Agency models are high touch, human resource heavy and require the constant balancing and correcting of clients to account managers. With too many clients, staff will struggle under the workload (a big part of high agency attrition rates) or […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine