Existential Threats To Agencies (& Why They Need To Focus On The Advertising)

Existential Threats To Agencies (& Why They Need To Focus On The Advertising)
SHARE
THIS



In the first of a four-part series aimed at threats and opportunities for agencies, regular B&T columnist, Robert Strothfeldt from Strothfeldt Consulting (pictured below), argues that, too often, advertising agencies want to provide every service bar advertising…

After 30 plus years in and around the advertising business it is not surprising to have seen some radical changes. “Disruption” is the term used to describe the impact of technology – wiping out some industries and creating others.

user_9522

The advertising industry is not immune to disruption and it has resulted in four existential threats to agencies (both creative and media). Advertising will always go on, but will the “service” be provided by agencies, or will it be dissected and absorbed by other service businesses?

The four threats are:

  • Identity
  • Credibility
  • Competition
  • Remuneration Structure.

Though addressed separately, they are interlinked.

1 Identity: There is debate about when the first advertising agency started. Some say William Taylor in 1786, others RF White and Son 1800 (both in London) – both placed ads created by clients in newspapers. In 1869 Francis Ayer opened the first full service agency in Philadelphia. Up until Ayer started, the industry was made up of advertising agents. They bought newspaper space for as little as possible and sold it to clients for as much as possible. (Sound familiar?). Francis Ayer added copy writing and graphic design to the media buying. Up until then media agents (media) and graphic designers (creative) were separate businesses.

And nearly 150 years later, we are back to the future with media and creative now two separate businesses. (Same holding company is about as close as they get). For the best part of 200 years, advertising agencies have planned and bought media and created and produced ads. Obviously these processes have become more far more sophisticated. And disciplines such as direct marketing, sales promotions, PR, etc. were added to the mix so advertising broadened and communications was coined to cover all above and below the line disciplines (market research is in there too).

In the past few years in particular, there has been an identity crisis in advertising. It seems we want to provide every service but advertising. There is no doubting the world has changed and mainstream media in no longer the only game in town. But it is still the number one medium to reach large numbers of consumers and hence a mandatory element of the advertising mix of any B2C mass market business. (It takes the biggest chunk of the budget, but receives the least attention.)

No business or industry can stand still as the environment around them rapidly changes. So it is only logical that with the advances in technology and fragmenting media landscape, both creative and media agencies must adapt and add new services. But there should be two considerations:

  • Are the new areas/service relevant to our core business?
  • Do we have the people, information and equipment to offer these services? (Not just offer, but to do so properly)

Innovation labs are a fairly recent “must have”. Some agencies have become totally besotted by technology, seeing it as the answer rather than a tool. There is no doubting that having a car’s panels “pulse” in tune with the driver’s heart beat is a very clever piece of technology. But is this what a client looks for in an agency? I know it was a joint client/agency initiative, but you wouldn’t see PwC involved in such projects. The advertising industry in Australia is not Silicon Valley, which is where one would expect this to be developed. And what did it prove? That driving a Lexus makes your heart beat faster – why? Because of the performance. Not only does it take several deductive steps to reach this conclusion, it does nothing to change the perception of Lexus – great car, but boring and driven by old farts. And most people would think the panels are pulsating faster because the old fart at the wheel is having a heart attack. Adding to the ludicrousness, Lexus stated:

  • A one-time collaboration (Maybe the technology can be used in other areas, but advertising/communications is not likely to be one of them)
  • Won’t go on sale (Emergency vehicles wouldn’t be pleased with the competition)
  • Demonstrates the connection between driver and car. (At a time when there are enormous resources being put into breaking this connection with driverless cars)

Businesses invest heavily in R&D. Agencies have neither the skills nor the money to be a second client R&D department. If agency innovation increases the effectiveness of their core business (through performance, cost or even a new area not previously considered) then it passes the relevance test. Otherwise it is money that could be better spent servicing clients. (The old adage still hold true – creative/ideas wins clients and service, or lack of it, loses clients.)

Just recently a major industry publication ran a feature on attribution. A “high level discussion of top industry professionals” and 10 key lessons to come out of these discussions. The same question can be asked – what the hell is an ad agency doing dicking around with this?

Anyone in advertising or marketing would have heard some variant of the quote: “Half the money I spend on advertising is wasted, the trouble is I don’t know which half.” It was made by John Wannamaker (1838 – 1922). I am not sure what year he said this, but as he fell off the perch way back in 1922, it has been around for a long, long time.

The term attribution is new. But the maths is not. It is a form of multi-variate analysis such as factor analysis, driver analysis – there are a number of techniques that could be used. Having started my career as a mathematician (BSc Pure and Statistical Maths), I know how incredibly complex this is because the number of variables involved in human behaviour are immense. (Some would say too many to consider). It is not something that a one-size-fits-all algorithm can solve. In fact, a PDF for each scenario is required i.e. No two scenarios are the same and hence a PDF, or equation, would have to be derived, then be programmed to produce an algorithm for each and every case. As the most of you would rather stick pins in your eyes than read me bang on about high level maths, let’s just say that a person who works in data and IT has no more chance of correctly doing attribution modelling than a paramedic has of being turned into a transplant surgeon with a bit of on the job training.

At least attribution has a high degree of relevance. The question is one of competency – do creative and/or media agencies have the required training, skills and equipment?

If unqualified people play around with attribution the odds of f …ing  it up are high. And since clients have been screwing our fees down for the past 30 years, you may just be giving some clown in the procurement department a reason to cut the ad budget even further.

The same reason agencies should not be involved in the nuts and bolts of attribution, apply to big data. Even more so as businesses such as advisory, the Big 4 (who started as Chartered Accountants), have far greater access to client data due to the nature of services such as Audit and Taxation.

Carat is an example of a media agency focusing on their core business. Their mission statement is: “Redefining the value of media through our command of convergence.”

From the late 90s, when the internet moved into the public realm, it was recognised that convergence was the future of media. None of this “digital media” versus “non-digital” or “traditional/legacy” media crap –consumers move seamlessly between the two.

Media (and creative) agencies have had to keep pace with the rapidly changing media landscape, but ultimately they are still media specialists. Compare this with some of the other major media players who are talking about diversifying their services into areas such as big data and content – it still astounds me how the latter, such an incredibly broad term, has grown into a specialist industry. (And no, Carat are not paying me to give them a plug.)

Splitting media and creative made sense when first mooted, but the result is the most basic of all equations in our business doesn’t really apply anymore:

Advertising = Media + Message

There has been a shift to try and bring creative and media back closer together, but even so they essentially still remain as two separate businesses in a world where integration is a pre-requisite to survival.

Instead of both working together in manner where the end result is greater than the sum of the parts, each is looking to find their own place in a digital world.

Both media and creative agencies should focus on what has always been the role of advertising – persuasion. Persuasion at each of the many touch points with consumers.

A big change today is that agencies need to offer an integrated persuasion service (As opposed to being above or below the line specialists). And this is much more than a series of mutually exclusive silos. Again it is another sum of the parts solution – all working together. The desired ultimate outcome is still the same – long-term profitable sales. Hence, how does persuasion help best achieve this result? (In its role as the fourth of the 4Ps, which still apply.)

When businesses think of persuasion, they should be thinking of advertising agencies. Not only for the messages, but also for the most impactful and cost effective way to distribute these messages to their target markets.

Next time – Credibility.

Latest News

Women In Media Profile: Naomi Shepherd
  • Media

Women In Media Profile: Naomi Shepherd

Need a Monday morning pick-me-up? You could stand naked next to the office fridge or read these inspiring words.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
HooZu Appoints Rebecca Evans As Client Services Director
  • Marketing

HooZu Appoints Rebecca Evans As Client Services Director

Influencer marketing agency HooZu has announced the appointment of Rebecca Evans to the position of client services director. Evans brings diverse professional experience to the HooZu team, having worked across some of the world’s most disruptive sharing economy businesses, including Deliveroo and Uber. Formerly a business account manager at Deliveroo, Evans played a crucial role […]

Bauer Media Brands Unite Against Tampon Tax with ‘No Gender Selective Tax’ Campaign
  • Advertising
  • Campaigns
  • Media

Bauer Media Brands Unite Against Tampon Tax with ‘No Gender Selective Tax’ Campaign

Publishing player Bauer Media has announced the launch of its ‘No Gender Selective Tax campaign – a push to end what is essentially a tax on being a woman. The No Gender Selective Tax campaign is a major cross-brand initiative to remove the Goods and Services Tax (GST) from the price of tampons, pads and […]

Fairfax Announces New Partnership With Taronga Zoo, Launches ‘Wrong Skin’ Podcast
  • Media

Fairfax Announces New Partnership With Taronga Zoo, Launches ‘Wrong Skin’ Podcast

Publishing giant Fairfax Media has announced a new and exclusive partnership with Taronga Zoo, along with a new podcast series. Fairfax will bolster support for both Taronga Zoo and Western Plains Zoo via its The Sydney Morning Herald and The Sun Herald, as well as through its suburban and regional networks. The new partnership builds […]

Shopper Media Group Partners With Mist To Offer New Tech & AI-Driven Capabilities
  • Advertising
  • Media

Shopper Media Group Partners With Mist To Offer New Tech & AI-Driven Capabilities

Australian retail out-of-home (OOH) business Shopper Media Group (SMG) has announced a partnership with AI-powered wireless networks provider Mist. The partnership will see SMG offer new WiFi, analytics and location-based services across the company’s portfolio of Australian shopping centres. Mist currently provides WiFi and location services using virtual Bluetooth LE technology to businesses across all […]

Indy Agency This Is Flow Wins Cruiseco’s $5 Million Media Account
  • Advertising
  • Media

Indy Agency This Is Flow Wins Cruiseco’s $5 Million Media Account

Travel organisation Cruiseco has announced the appointment of Sydney independent agency This is Flow (TIF) to handle its $5 million media account. This is the first time Cruiseco has appointed an agency, having managed its communications internally. Cruiseco is the largest and broadest distributor of cruise products in the Southern Hemisphere. With a membership base […]

APN Outdoor Takes Off With Queenstown Airport Contract
  • Advertising
  • Media

APN Outdoor Takes Off With Queenstown Airport Contract

Out-of-home media business APN Outdoor has won the tender for New Zealand’s Queenstown Airport. As part of the new agreement, APN Outdoor has flagged extensive development plans for Queenstown Airport’s advertising assets. The new contract adds Queenstown Airport to APN Outdoor’s existing portfolio of Auckland and Christchurch Airports. The media company will hire a South […]

Havas Secures Exclusive ‘Fight Of Champions’ Broadcast Rights With Foxtel For Australia & NZ
  • Media

Havas Secures Exclusive ‘Fight Of Champions’ Broadcast Rights With Foxtel For Australia & NZ

Havas Sports & Entertainment ANZ, a division of the broader global full-service agency Havas, has confirmed an exclusive deal with Foxtel to showcase the World Boxing Association (WBA) Welterweight Championship across the trans-Tasman. Billed as the ‘Fight of Champions’, Manny Pacquiao and Lucas Matthysse will square off for the WBA Welterweight belt this Sunday. Havas […]

The Question On Everybody’s Lips At Cannes: How Did Tesco Win The Grand Prix Media Lion?
  • Media
  • Opinion

The Question On Everybody’s Lips At Cannes: How Did Tesco Win The Grand Prix Media Lion?

In this guest post, PHD’s Chloe Hooper (pictured below) analyses the campaign that claimed top honours in the Media category at Cannes this year. I sat in the auditorium as the Cannes Media Lion winners for 2018 were awarded. One thing became instantly clear to me: it is all about taking home Gold or the Grand Prix. […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
MINI Australia Showcases New ‘Connected’ Vehicles Via Vizeum & Posterscope
  • Advertising
  • Campaigns

MINI Australia Showcases New ‘Connected’ Vehicles Via Vizeum & Posterscope

An integrated campaign by Vizeum Melbourne for MINI Australia’s new ‘Connected’ vehicles will see digital out-of-home (DOOH) served via Posterscope’s Liveposter platform. Delivered centrally, the campaign will showcase the flexible qualities DOOH provides via multiple creatives targeted with specific data overlays such as location, traffic, time of day, and weather triggers such as rain. The […]

Women In Media Profile: Lisa Sheehan
  • Media

Women In Media Profile: Lisa Sheehan

The delightful Lisa Sheehan straps into B&T's "cage of truth" we actually prefer to call our Women in Media profiles.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
News Corp, Storyful & Fox Sports Join Forces To Support AIME Hoodie Day
  • Advertising
  • Campaigns
  • Marketing
  • Media

News Corp, Storyful & Fox Sports Join Forces To Support AIME Hoodie Day

News Corp Australia, Storyful and Fox Sports have joined forces in support of 2018 AIME Hoodie Day with a creative advertising, PR, social media and editorial campaign across print, digital, and broadcast media. Fox League presenter Hannah Hollis (pictured above) fronts the AIME Hoodie Day campaign, conceptualised, designed and created by News Corp’s trade marketing […]

Storyation Finalist For Global Content Marketing Agency Of The Year
  • Marketing

Storyation Finalist For Global Content Marketing Agency Of The Year

Sydney content marketing agency Storyation has been named a finalist for global Content Marketing Agency of the Year in the Content Marketing Association Awards in the US.  The only Australian agency on the short-list, Storyation was founded by two former Fairfax Media executives Lauren Quaintance (right in photo) and Mimi Cullen (left) and its clients include Tourism […]

Jaden Social Claims Integrated Marketing Tender For NSW Schools Spectacular
  • Marketing

Jaden Social Claims Integrated Marketing Tender For NSW Schools Spectacular

Jaden Social has been awarded the tender to handle integrated marketing for the NSW Schools Spectacular. The agreement will see Jaden Social manage marketing, media, digital and social across the 2018 to 2020 productions of Schools Spectacular, held at Qudos Bank Arena in November. Jaden Social underwent a competitive pitch to secure the account, in […]

APD Australia Appoints New Head Of Digital Product & Strategy
  • Marketing
  • Technology

APD Australia Appoints New Head Of Digital Product & Strategy

Digital transformation business APD has announced the appointment of Chris Butterworth as its Australian head of digital product and strategy. Based in Melbourne, Butterworth (pictured above) will be responsible for building on APD’s owned media team, growing its range of services and developing cross-channel products. Butterworth joins APD from Reprise Digital, where he was most […]

Apparent Appoints Joint Creative Directors From Within
  • Marketing

Apparent Appoints Joint Creative Directors From Within

Customer engagement agency Apparent has promoted Michelle Turchini and Simon Bloomfield to the newly created roles of joint creative directors, following strong business growth. Over the past 12 months, the independent Sydney agency has increased its staff to more than 60 people and moved into larger offices off the back of new and organic business […]

Targus Reinvigorates Brand Across The Trans-Tasman With First-Ever OOH Campaign
  • Advertising
  • Campaigns
  • Marketing

Targus Reinvigorates Brand Across The Trans-Tasman With First-Ever OOH Campaign

Targus Australia New Zealand has today unveiled its first-ever out-of-home media campaign to show off the brand’s fresh look and reinvigorated proposition. Showcasing how Targus connects people and technology, the campaign has been developed by the local arm of international independent brand design agency SomeOne, alongside a media strategy developed in collaboration with Sydney-based agency […]

Bedshed Reveals What Aussies Get Up To In Their Bedrooms In Fresh Campaign By Rare Perth
  • Advertising
  • Campaigns

Bedshed Reveals What Aussies Get Up To In Their Bedrooms In Fresh Campaign By Rare Perth

Last year, Bedshed commissioned a nationwide survey asking people right across the country what they get up to in the privacy of their bedrooms. It then gathered all the personal revelations together into a report, and now they’re sharing those details with everyone in Australia. The Bedroom Report reveals everything from our favourite sleeping positions […]

MediaMath Secures $US225 Million In New Funding
  • Advertising
  • Technology

MediaMath Secures $US225 Million In New Funding

Programmatic advertising player MediaMath has announced an integrated set of initiatives designed to advance the next generation architecture for digital marketing. The company is unveiling a range of investments in technology, people and relationships, as well as US$225 million in new financing, to accelerate its mission to connect marketers with consumers in a manner that […]

Christie Spaces Chooses The Wired Agency To Lead Digital Marketing
  • Marketing

Christie Spaces Chooses The Wired Agency To Lead Digital Marketing

Co-working space company Christie Spaces has announced the appointment of The Wired Agency as its new digital marketing agency in Australia. Tasked with maximising campaign performance through their trademarked hyper-segmentation and hyper-optimisation techniques, The Wired Agency will be leading search advertising, display advertising, and SEO for Christie Spaces. The company exists to provide a space […]

Realestate.com.au & Mazda Unveil Property Construction Video Series
  • Marketing
  • Media

Realestate.com.au & Mazda Unveil Property Construction Video Series

Property website realestate.com.au has launched a video series showcasing the trials and tribulations of an epic demolition and transformation by interior stylist and well-known Instagrammer Catherine Hegarty. The Heraghty family bulldozed their quaint weatherboard in Sydney to make way for a duplex, which will be the focus of the 2 in Twelve series, which you […]

Jimmy Brings & Spotify Curate Limited Edition Wine & Music Pairings Via Eleven
  • Campaigns
  • Marketing

Jimmy Brings & Spotify Curate Limited Edition Wine & Music Pairings Via Eleven

Eleven has worked with alcohol delivery service Jimmy Brings and Spotify to launch three limited edition wines that marry perfectly with music. The Songmelier Edition range features an Australian sparkling, sauvignon blanc and reserve shiraz, each paired with a Spotify playlist accessible via a code on the label. Wine lovers can simply scan the code […]

IPG’s 303 MullenLowe Appoints WA Creative Duo
  • Advertising

IPG’s 303 MullenLowe Appoints WA Creative Duo

Interpublic Group’s 303 MullenLowe has announced the appointment of Western Australian creatives Melita Masters and Bianca Galan-Dwyer to its team. Masters (pictured above, left) and Galan-Dwyer (pictured above, right) joined forces in 2016 at The Brand Agency, quickly establishing themselves as a first-rate creative duo with their multi-award-winning campaign ‘Let’s Thursday Like We Friday’ for the […]

Top Marketers Join Forces To Explore Best Practice
  • Marketing

Top Marketers Join Forces To Explore Best Practice

Some of Sydney’s top senior marketers have banded together to form a council that aims to develop best practice around launch marketing. The Launch Marketing Council (LMC) is an initiative by global independent launch agency Five by Five and will meet twice a year to share experiences around various launch marketing topics. The panel is […]

My Top Takeaways From Programmatic Week
  • Advertising
  • Marketing
  • Opinion

My Top Takeaways From Programmatic Week

In this guest post, Amnet MD Indy Khabra (pictured above) shares his top takeouts from Programmatic Week – a week dedicated to educating Dentsu Aegis Network staff on the very latest innovation and changes to the industry. The speed of technological disruption is accelerating. Keeping on top of the latest developments is challenging – even […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine