The Art Of Getting It So Wrong

The Art Of Getting It So Wrong
SHARE
THIS



In this guest piece, Oliver Shawyer (pictured below), managing director of digital solutions business Feel and global marketing director at 180 Degrees Consulting, provides some words of wisdom for those about to embark on a start-up.

Oliver Shawyer

Today, loads of start-ups are receiving millions of dollars in investment. The service, the product, the offering… it all feels right, it all feels like the next big thing – the next Uber (blah, blah, blah) – but a story I came across recently reminded me that no matter how good you or the people around you think it is, it’s not about you. If it works for everyone but the person it’s intended for, then you’re doomed. Sure, this is a “no shit” statement, but yet here we are.

Have you ever heard of the story of Trevor Field?

In 1989, he visited an agricultural fair in Pretoria, South Africa, where he met a water engineer named Ronnie Stuiver, who was demonstrating a model for a new type of water pump. Skipping across a chunk of the detail (because I want you to read on to the punchline), the showcase reminded him of a fishing trip he’d taken many years before, during which he watched the women of a rural village wait for hours next to a windmill-powered water pump. He recalled that there had been no wind that day, but in light of the near-desperate need of supplying their homes with water, they simply sat and waited for the water to flow. He thought to himself then that there had to be a better way, and here in front of him at the fair was the potential solution – the PlayPump.

Unlike the typical hand and windmill pumps found in many villages of the poor countries, Stuiver’s invention seemed brilliant because it doubled as a merry-go-round. The scenario that played over in Trevor’s head made perfect sense: the children would play on the merry-go-round, it would spin, and in doing so it would pump water from the ground into a tank. No longer would the women of the village need to trek for miles to draw water, and at the same time, the children (who have almost nothing) had something to entertain them for hours upon hours. A product that utilised the power of playing children to provide sustainable water supply for the community. It was the best idea Trevor had ever seen, and so fittingly, he bought the patent and then spent the next five years improving the design, which also included the idea of placing billboard advertisements on the sides of the water tank as a way to generate revenue to pay for pump maintenance.

Throughout these years and those that followed, Trevor delivered some monumental milestones including:

  • Registration of the charity PlayPumps International.
  • Installation of the first PlayPump in 1995.
  • Securing the first sponsor, Colgate Palmolive, in 1995.
  • Installed 50 pumps across Africa by the turn of the millennium.
  • Out of 3,000 applications, won a World Bank Development Marketplace Award that was given to ‘innovative, early stage development projects that are scalable and/or replicable, while also having high potential for development impact’.
  • Attracted funding, including from AOL chief executive Steve Case, who then worked with Field to set up an American arm of PlayPumps International with the aim of rolling out thousands of new PlayPumps across Africa.
  • Executing significantly successful fundraising marketing campaigns, including the launch of One Water, through The One Foundation, which donated all profits to PlayPump International (just to note, One Water became the official bottled water of Live 8 concerns and the ‘Make Poverty History’ campaign).
  • Became the darling of international media and celebrity endorsement, that included proclamation from Bill Clinton in a Time article in 2016, and backing from Jay-Z.
  • Awarded a $16.4 million grant by First Lady Laura Bush whilst launching a campaign designed to raise $60 million to fund 4,000 PlayPumps across Africa by 2010.
  • By 2009, 1,800 PlayPumps had been installed across South Africa, Mozambique, Swaziland and Zambia.

PlayPumps were the biggest thing since sliced bread, and the milestones above were just a few of the key indicators to how berserk it really went.

But here’s the catch.

For all it’s proclaimed business success and milestones – all the PR, the money raised, the products developed – for all of that, there was very little success on the ground. You know, the part where the product actually gets used. The only real part that matters.

Shortly after 2009, two damning reports were released by World Vision/UNICEF and the Swiss Resource Centre and Consultancies for Development respectively. It turned out that despite all the noise, the awards, and the millions of dollars spent, no one had really considered the practicalities and realities of the PlayPump for the end-user.

For instance:

  • Most merry-go-rounds spin freely once they’ve gained enough momentum, but in order for water to pump, PlayPumps needed constant force. This is exhausting for any adult, let alone a child.
  • Children were known to fall off and break limbs or vomit from the spinning.
  • The $14,000 PlayPump was inferior in almost every way to the ‘unsexy’ functional hand pumps it competed with (which, by the way, cost approximately four times less).
  • With less effort, some hand pumps (that they used before the PlayPump) would provide nearly five times the amount of water than the PlayPump. One reporter estimated that in order to provide a typical village’s water needs, the merry-go-round would have to spin for 27 hours per day.
  • The billboards on the storage tanks lay bare because the rural communities were too poor for companies interested in paying for advertising.

The incentive for the children was minimal (and wore off completely), to the point where some were even paid to ‘play’. And much of the time the women of the local village ended up pushing the merry-go-round themselves, which as a task was tiring and demeaning.

When asked, many of them said they preferred what they previously had to use and do.

The outcome of PlayPumps, albeit sad, probably doesn’t feel to foreign for a lot of you. In our short lifetimes alone, we’ve all seen many products full of such hype and potential fail miserably when implemented, even more so now in this digital age (when barriers to entry are lower and opportunity appears broader).

But regardless of how often or how close to home, we’re often left asking the same question:

How did everyone get it so wrong, and on such a scale?

Obviously, I don’t have the definitive answers. I couldn’t, because I’ve not experienced it to the extent that people like Trevor have.

But, in unpacking this story plus many others, some things you may find worth considering (notably if you’re also in the process of building your own business or product) could include:

  • Understanding your audience. Not just what they say they would do, but in understanding what they will actually do in true context. You do not know better than them.
  • Engaging your audience and testing hypotheses with them throughout the entire process. It’s the only way to truly understand the context of the problem you’re trying to address.
  • Appreciating that user research is no longer just about unpacking what, you need to know why. We’re all driven by inherited biases and developed heuristics – it’s important to understand what sub consciously drives our behaviour and decisions.
  • Beware the thrill of new technology. Just because it’s shiny and sparkles doesn’t mean it’s immediately better (or more demanded). This is a huge trap in the world we live in today, so stay true to your objective and delivering on that in the most effective and efficient way.
  • Appreciating the power of familiarity. Anything that feels too different brings with it the fear of new. The power of the status quo is compelling so work with it rather than against it.
  • Unpacking you’re own downfall. Don’t be driven solely by emotion, understand the facts and digest all the evidence. Having the right intentions is always a great place to start, but it’s shouldn’t be the only place.

I’m about to endeavour on tech start-up, so the key will be putting my money where my mouth is. After all, surely I’ll know if I’ve got it all wrong… won’t I?

Please login with linkedin to comment

Latest News

Zenith Sydney MD Karen Halligan To Depart
  • Media

Zenith Sydney MD Karen Halligan To Depart

Zenith Sydney's Karen Halligan has pulled-up stumps, although that's not to infer bad light had anything to do with it.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
PR Agency Hotwire Rebrands
  • Marketing
  • Media

PR Agency Hotwire Rebrands

PR agency Hotwire has rebranded, yet sadly not to "Hot Cocks Who Rock Your Socks Off". Which would've been far cooler.

Challenger Agency VCCP Wins Creative Account For Torrens University Australia
  • Advertising

Challenger Agency VCCP Wins Creative Account For Torrens University Australia

After a competitive pitching process involving five agencies, Torrens University Australia has appointed challenger agency VCCP as its new brand strategy partner and creative agency for 2018. Acclaimed for its work on dynamic brands including ING and Compare the Market in the financial services sector, Laureate Australia CMO Anne Da Cunha said VCCP’s reputation as […]

GumGum Appoints Ansible’s Sarah Baskerville As Victorian Sales Director
  • Advertising
  • Technology

GumGum Appoints Ansible’s Sarah Baskerville As Victorian Sales Director

AI advertising company GumGum has announced the appointment of Sarah Baskerville as its sales director for Victoria. Baskerville joins GumGum from Ansible, where she spent two years as its Melbourne mobile director. Prior to joining Ansible, she was head of specialist sales and partnerships at News Corp Australia, and also held a number of sales […]

The Diamond Concierge Gives Away $85K Ring In Campaign By McCann Queensland
  • Advertising
  • Campaigns

The Diamond Concierge Gives Away $85K Ring In Campaign By McCann Queensland

McCann Queensland’s second instalment of ‘The 5th C’ campaign launched over the weekend for online diamond retailer The Diamond Concierge, which received over 47million views around the world in the first 48 hours of it being released. In this second phase of the campaign, The Diamond Concierge gave away an $85,000 diamond ring, with Gold […]

Sparro Recruits Key Account Director Following Client Wins
  • Marketing

Sparro Recruits Key Account Director Following Client Wins

Digital marketing agency Sparro has announced the appointment of Hannah Jones (pictured above) as a key account director following a spate of client wins. Jones joins Sparro’s senior team alongside founders Cameron and Morris Bryant, overseeing a portfolio of accounts that includes Webjet, Domino’s Pizza, TAFE NSW, Temple & Webster, F45 Training and Bing Lee. […]

Women’s Health’s Jacqui Mooney On Driving A Women’s Brand In An Evolving Industry
  • Media

Women’s Health’s Jacqui Mooney On Driving A Women’s Brand In An Evolving Industry

In an industry facing change, Jacqui Mooney, editor of Women’s Health believes brands such as hers will continue to be a constant. Please note: this article was contributed by Magazine Networks. The magazine industry may be seeing substantial change but Jacqui Mooney has a goal that remains firm: to create happier, healthier lives for Australian women. […]

Why Consumer Brands Are Failing Aussie Mums
  • Marketing
  • Opinion

Why Consumer Brands Are Failing Aussie Mums

Is your game chainsaws or large marlin wall-hangings? Can't seem to attract the mums? This couldn't come soon enough.

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Network Ten Creditors Approve CBS Deal
  • Media

Network Ten Creditors Approve CBS Deal

It seems the fight for Ten between CBS and media moguls Lachlan Murdoch and Bruce Gordon may finally be over.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
MKTG Signs Exclusive Commercial Partnership With PlayersVoice
  • Marketing
  • Media

MKTG Signs Exclusive Commercial Partnership With PlayersVoice

MKTG has announced it has signed an exclusive commercial partnership with newly-launched sports storytelling site PlayersVoice.com.au – an agreement that will see the agency move into a new territory of sports marketing. The partnership between MKTG and PlayersVoice will see the business managing brand partnership opportunities for the new platform; working with clients to deliver […]

Domo Introduces New Data Security Software Solution
  • Marketing
  • Technology

Domo Introduces New Data Security Software Solution

Domo has announced it has introduced new cloud security technology for its Bring Your Own Key (BYOK) software, which includes unique capabilities like rolling generation of data encryption keys and a built-in kill switch. Domo BYOK is the first BYOK enterprise software solution for cloud analytics and business intelligence, and builds on the company’s existing security, compliance and […]

Shopper Media Group Grows Sydney & Melbourne Sales Teams
  • Advertising
  • Marketing
  • Media

Shopper Media Group Grows Sydney & Melbourne Sales Teams

Shopper Media Group (SMG) has continued to grow its Sydney and Melbourne sales teams to keep up with the demand for Smartlite Panels for shopping centres. Ashley Munro joins SMG as group sales manager for Sydney, having previously worked in a similar role at NOVA Entertainment. Laura Mason has been appointed as SMG’s business manager […]

RIO DE JANEIRO, BRAZIL - AUGUST 14:  Usain Bolt of Jamaica competes in the Men's 100 meter semifinal on Day 9 of the Rio 2016 Olympic Games at the Olympic Stadium on August 14, 2016 in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil.  (Photo by Cameron Spencer/Getty Images)
  • Advertising
  • Media

Olympics, Census Prove Tough Hurdles For Media Agencies: SMI

Australia’s media agency market has experienced another tough month in August, according to the latest data by Standard Media Index (SMI). SMI noted the softer demand this time around was primarily due to the Rio Olympics and Census providing abnormal bookings last year, resulting in demand for August 2017 so far being back 12.1 per […]