Algorithm Or Alchemy: You Put Rubbish In, You Get Rubbish Out

Algorithm Or Alchemy: You Put Rubbish In, You Get Rubbish Out
SHARE
THIS



B&T’s regular columnist and contrarian, Robert Strohfeldt of Strohfeldt Consulting, argues we’re all too dependant on the latest algorithm – to our peril…

 Machines have been replacing people since the industrial revolution. The pyramids would be knocked up a hell of a lot faster (with much less loss of life) using modern machinery and techniques. (Though it could be argued that the build quality would not be improved upon – check out inner city Sydney units built in the last five years.)

Moving from the industrial to the information age, we are now experiencing machines (computers) taking over the thinking once done by people at an ever – increasing rate. And there is no argument that computers are much faster and more accurate than people.  They are also a hell of a lot cheaper and don’t carry the “baggage” that many people bring to a job. (Never had to fire a computer for making an unwanted pass at the photocopier).

As computers evolved, they have become smaller, faster and permeated virtually every aspect of our lives.  We now have a whole generation who have not experienced life without computers. (Nor could they imagine life without them).

I was helping a good friend who is a professional musician and guitar teacher research online guitar courses and came across the following:

“After playing guitar for over 12 years, we tried the most popular lessons online, rated each with a custom algorithm and then wrote reviews to help other guitarists choose.”

It reminded me of the numerous times I see the use of “algorithm”.  No matter what you want done, there is an algorithm available for it:

  • A business who monitors and does analyses of social media by: Aggregating all a company’s social media posts and using an algorithm to determine which are the most relevant.
  • A business started by a dual rugby league/union international uses “an algorithm” to identify power players with the most potential to change consumer behaviour. (Links brands to sports stars’ social media followers).
  • Media planning and buying: “An algorithm is used to select and buy the most cost effective schedule from available online media inventory.”

It seems that once an “algorithm” is brought into play, then the result it spits out is automatically deemed to be correct.

Should there be a rigorous examination of the said algorithm, rather than blind acceptance of the outcome?

Take the question of programmatic buying. With so much online media inventory, old style calculations would take an eternity. Computers literally calculate at the speed of light; therefore, it is obvious that the numbers are crunched by computer. There are too many combinations and permutations for an individual with a calculator to attempt.

So, the question is not “is programmatic buying” a feasible solution, rather how good is the program (or algorithm) being used? What calculations and assumptions were made and what is the accuracy or validity of each?

The same applies to the social media and sport stars’ algorithms.

For the social media algorithm, someone must first make assumptions on which words or phrases are deemed relevant. If any of these assumptions are incorrect, then the resulting algorithm is going to be incorrect.

Identifying sports’ stars with the ability to change human behaviour would logically extend to any celebrity or high profile individual. How the hell does one determine if a person can change human behaviour? Changing human behaviour is far more complex than asking the question ‘If (sport star a) recommended this product, how likely would you be to buy it?”

Having a magic algorithm sounds so far more in tune with the digital age. A victory for marketing fashion over function (again).

A basic fact often forgotten, or not understood – that a person does the thinking, a computer does as it is instructed.

Quite often the individual writing the code or algorithm knows very little about the topic for which the algorithm is being developed.

Airbnb, is a huge international success. As a disruptive business that would not exist if not for the internet, you would assume they have their act together. We use it for a property on the Gold Coast.

They introduced a new algorithm, called “Smart Pricing”. The price of accommodation varies – school holidays, Christmas, New Year, Easter etc. Instead of manually going through every day in each month of the calendar and entering a price, “Smart Pricing” uses an algorithm to calculate the pricing for you automatically. All you do is set a minimum and maximum price for it to work from.

A great idea in principal, saving a lot of time and for some, much guess work. It wasn’t long before we received a request for two nights, 4 months in advance – the price the algorithm quoted wasn’t sufficient to cover costs for cleaning. It was less than one quarter of the minimum price that was set. (Yet the “algorithm” asks to input your minimum and maximum prices). The person writing the code did not know how to do the maths to work out a price variance equation based on demand and a fluctuating occupancy continuum – minimum and maximum price of the property and because Airbnb asks for 100% of the accommodation cost at the time of booking, guests book “short” rather than “long” – a shit load of variables that require a detailed understanding of mathematics, not some code monkey’s basic statistics.  In this instance the mistake was so obvious, it was easily picked up.

But what if the calculation is for say, programmatic media planning? A good way to illustrate the difference between “calculating” and “thinking” is a headline and introduction for a recent story in TheDrum:

Mercedes-Benz asks agencies to ‘review’ safe media list as brands respond to ‘programmatic terror’ dilemma.

A report that some of the world’s biggest brands are inadvertently funding extremism and pornography through programmatic ads has prompted Mercedes-Benz to review the platforms and channels it considers safe.

The next “big thing” after programmatic is the development of algorithms to create advertising and content – computer generated creative. Good luck. Determining all the variables at play is close to an impossible task and adding further to the difficulty, the variables influencing the creative output vary from situation to situation, even when working within strict corporate guidelines. The human brain is the most complex piece of “machinery” on earth and many of its workings are still a mystery to research scientists. How the hell does one develop a computer programme (sorry, algorithm) to duplicate something that no one truly understands the workings of?

If anything, computers are dumbing us down – the Google syndrome: “I know the answer but have absolutely no understanding of how it is derived.”

We are still a long way from artificial intelligence. (Singularity, when artificial intelligence overtakes human intelligence.)  All algorithms are an analysis of a problem, using a pre-determined formula and assumptions developed by a person. Yes, some are incredibly complex and developed from “machine learning”, but the “learning” is programmed. Deduction is not imagination.

An algorithm cannot turn lead into gold any more than it is an infallible, “magic” solution to a problem or calculation to which the path to the answer is not already known.

So rather than merely accept a conclusion is correct because an algorithm was used, the question should be “can we see the formula and assumptions used to develop the algorithm”?

You don’t have to be a code writer or mathematician to do this. Understanding of and experience in your area of practice will tell you if the assumptions made are correct.

The basics really don’t change. And when it comes to algorithms, programmes or what- ever term is deemed the most fashionable, the absolute fundamental that has been around since the first computer was invented still holds true:

                                                   Rubbish In = Rubbish Out.

Please login with linkedin to comment

Latest News

Clems Melbourne Promotes Nick Jamieson To Creative Director Of Activation
  • Advertising

Clems Melbourne Promotes Nick Jamieson To Creative Director Of Activation

Clemenger BBDO Melbourne has announced the promotion of Nick Jamieson to creative director for its activation division. Jamieson joined Clems Melbourne in July 2015 as a senior copywriter before joining the agency’s shopper marketing division as its creative lead. During his time at Clems Melbourne, Jamieson has led the shopper marketing creative on a number […]

Ogilvy Melbourne Names Susannah George As New Head Of Film & Content Production
  • Marketing
  • Media

Ogilvy Melbourne Names Susannah George As New Head Of Film & Content Production

Following a year of continuous growth across its client portfolio, including the recent addition of the Cadbury account, Ogilvy Melbourne has lured Susannah George to join its senior team in the newly created role of head of film and content production. George joins Ogilvy from AJF Melbourne, where she spent the past four years as […]

TBWA And Eleven Partner With Gatorade & Usain Bolt For The ‘Bolt Rate’
  • Campaigns

TBWA And Eleven Partner With Gatorade & Usain Bolt For The ‘Bolt Rate’

Gatorade, in partnership with Eleven and TBWA, has created a new explosive cricket metric which has the potential to change the way the game is analysed, discussed and celebrated by fans. For the first time ever, the new measurement – Bolt Rate – will record the players’ run speed between wickets during the summer of […]

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA
  • Advertising
  • Marketing
  • Media

Former DDB Sydney Creative Director Simon Veksner Joins BuzzFeed

BuzzFeed has announced that award-winning advertising industry creative Simon Veksner will join its team in Sydney to oversee branded content across Australia and the Asia-Pacific (APAC) region. Veksner is the founder of social media agency Hungry Beast. He also previously worked as creative director at DDB Sydney, and prior to that, as head of ideas […]

Keep Left Wins Content Marketing Account For NEFF Australia
  • Marketing

Keep Left Wins Content Marketing Account For NEFF Australia

PR and content marketing agency Keep Left has won a competitive content marketing pitch for German home appliances company NEFF. As one of few appliance brands to focus exclusively on the home cooking experience, NEFF was looking to sign with an agency that could take its content marketing program to the next level. The key […]

PPR Appoints Allan Dib As Director Of Planning & Insights
  • Marketing

PPR Appoints Allan Dib As Director Of Planning & Insights

WPP AUNZ-owned public relations agency PPR has announced the appointment of Allan Dib as director of planning and insights to help clients better connect with the communities they are wanting to reach. After more than 20 years overseas, Dib is returning to Melbourne to work with PPR’s six teams across Australia and New Zealand to […]

Banjo Trades Pee For Pampering With Festivalgoers After NSW Health Campaign Win
  • Advertising
  • Campaigns

Banjo Trades Pee For Pampering With Festivalgoers After NSW Health Campaign Win

Ad agency Banjo has managed to lure music festival fans into taking a pee test for sexually transmitted infections (STIs) after winning the NSW government Sexual Health Festival activation campaign. Charged with convincing people to pee in a pot, Banjo developed the ‘Down to Test’ experience using the temptation of a VIP Chill Out Zone […]

Subway Gives Away 13 Million Meals To Hunger Relief Charities Via JWT Sydney
  • Campaigns
  • Marketing

Subway Gives Away 13 Million Meals To Hunger Relief Charities Via JWT Sydney

In a global, real-time data-led campaign devised and executed by J. Walter Thompson (JWT) Sydney, more than 40,000 Subway restaurants in more than 60 countries recently invited customers to join the Subway Live Feed to help fight hunger around the world. The concept, developed specifically to celebrate World Sandwich Day on Friday 3 November, saw […]

Editor Sacked Over Racist And Homophobic Tweets
  • Media

Editor Sacked Over Racist And Homophobic Tweets

The editor the UK’s influential Gay Times has been sacked by his bosses following a series of demeaning, racist and homophobic tweets from far back as five years ago. As reported on B&T last week, Josh Rivers had been in the editor’s chair for less than a month when the unsavoury tweets resurfaced forcing his bosses […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
How The VOTE YES Campaign Unlocked Creative Freedom For Marketers & Individuals
  • Marketing
  • Opinion

How The VOTE YES Campaign Unlocked Creative Freedom For Marketers & Individuals

In this opinion piece, PHD’s new business and marketing manager, Chloe Hooper (pictured below), reflects on how brands cleverly got involved in the same-sex marriage debate. It was announced last week that 61.6 per cent of the nation voted yes to legalising same-sex marriage. In the words of PM Malcom Turnbull, “Australians have voted yes […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Study: Nothing Beats TV Advertising For ROI On Ad Spends
  • Advertising

Study: Nothing Beats TV Advertising For ROI On Ad Spends

In what’s certain to be music to the ears of Australian TV bosses, a new study (albeit out of the UK) has found TV advertising generates the highest return on investment (ROI) of any media over both the short-term and the long-term. The study was commissioned by UK industry body Thinkbox and was carried out by marketing analysts at […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Free TV Begins Consultation Period For The Banning Of Gambling Ads During Live Sport
  • Advertising

Free TV Begins Consultation Period For The Banning Of Gambling Ads During Live Sport

Free TV Australia has announced the commencement of the consultation period on the new draft provisions of the Commercial Television Industry Code of Practice relating to gambling advertising during live sporting events. The new provisions further restrict gambling advertising during live sports following discussions with the Government. Free TV Acting CEO Pamela Longstaff said, “Free TV […]

Study: Aussie Online Shoppers Happy With Longer Delivery Times So Long As Delivery’s Free
  • Marketing

Study: Aussie Online Shoppers Happy With Longer Delivery Times So Long As Delivery’s Free

US tech firm Pitney Bowes has released its fourth annual Global Online Shopping Study which showed Australian shoppers continue to lead the world when it comes to the percentage of shoppers who buy cross-border. You can read the study in full here. However, the strong influence of shipping and delivery options is now changing the way Australians […]

AI – To Join It Or To Beat It
  • Media
  • Opinion

AI – To Join It Or To Beat It

I'm afraid we can't let you read this piece Dave! That's a joke about A Space Odyssey 2001, young B&T readers.

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
AnalogFolk Opens In Shanghai
  • Advertising

AnalogFolk Opens In Shanghai

AnalogFolk has opened in Shanghai and, as B&T's trusty Funk & Wagnalls atlas tell us, is somewhere near Wollongong.

Social TV – Will You Be At The Party?
  • Advertising
  • Marketing
  • Media
  • Opinion

Social TV – Will You Be At The Party?

Can't keep-up with the goings-on in the Aussie TV industry? Well, hit the couch, pull on the trakkie daks & peruse this.

Opinion

by Rochelle Burbury

Rochelle Burbury
JWT Melbourne Hooks John West’s Creative
  • Advertising

JWT Melbourne Hooks John West’s Creative

You'd only need snog a B&T staffer to know of our affection for the John West oysters in aspic & smoked mackerel ranges.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Sydney-Based Tech Marketing Firm, Law Of The Jungle, Scoops Top International Gong
  • Marketing

Sydney-Based Tech Marketing Firm, Law Of The Jungle, Scoops Top International Gong

Sydney-based online cloud solution for marketing compliance, Law of the Jungle, has beaten the world’s best firms to win a prestigious RegTech Markets 2017 Spotlight Award. RegTech Markets, a global community for regulatory technology, inaugurated these awards to “shine a light on the world’s best and brightest RegTech companies”.  A panel of 30 industry experts […]