WORLD VIEW: Where should Foursquare check-in next?

WORLD VIEW: Where should Foursquare check-in next?
SHARE
THIS



I’m the mayor of 14 places in Amsterdam.

Not long ago that might have sounded pretty sweet to you. It likely doesn’t anymore. Me either.

I love Foursquare, but more for what they’ve done than what they’re doing. The game is running a bit stale several years in, and co-founder Dennis Crowley has not been shy in saying “Foursquare is about personalised search, not gamification”. But gamification got us here. That’s the reason I’m on and love Foursquare. Is personalised search enough to keep it going?

Foursquare was never going to be the biggest thing out there, but its genius is undeniable. When it launched in March 2009, it was into a world where humans were not compelled in the least to share their location. Even my ‘early adopter’ compadres couldn’t understand why they would share their location with the internet. It wasn’t that it was private. Nobody needed to know.

And that’s why Foursquare succeeded where others failed. It didn’t just ask us for our location. It needed our location for the novel and somewhat compelling game to be played. Every single check-in was a play in the game. There was no way to forward your position without sharing. And suddenly, a significant amount of people didn’t have a problem sharing. Foursquare felt like a good deal, and the act of pressing that button to check-in, almost like the handshake. Honest and straightforward. It worked.

But only for so long. They never released the new game features, goals or upgrades which would keep the game engaging, leaving it somewhat stale, and interesting only to the new users. But this wasn’t laziness or the collapse of their idea. Quite the contrary. As it turns out, this was their plan.

The founders of Foursquare felt early on that check-ins would be an amazing recommendation engine – if you had enough of them. So that’s where the game comes in. And as soon as the game put enough data in their hands to begin making reasonable assumptions (March 2011) they released Explore. To date, they have upwards of 30 million users responsible for some 4 billion data points.

Foursquare seems to believe they don’t need to evolve the game because there is a steady stream of new users to their platform for whom the game is still fresh. If they can sustain user growth, they can keep getting check-ins.

But that seems like a dangerous theory to me. It’s been proven that the game works. Will recommendations and Explore be compelling enough to keep veterans of the platform checking in? 

The first problem with recommendations is accuracy. It’s a complicated endeavour to try and suggest things to humans. The first Foursquare mashup I ever saw set out to show you the ‘hottest’ places to go in NYC at any given time. It was an early form of using the check-in as a recommendation engine. In the space of a week Explore informed me that the ‘hottest’ place in NYC was the Port Authority Bus Terminal, which is about as close to hell as I’ve ever been. Visited a lot? Sure. Would I describe it to my friends as a ‘hot’ place to go? Not unless you hate yourself and are looking for more hate.

The technology has progressed since then, but it is still difficult to overcome these reasonable inaccuracies. For me, most of the places I check in to are places I would love never to return to. The obligations of life put me there.

So how do they combat that? Some smart tech (to be sure) and some additional effort from you. Check-ins alone are not enough to generate amazing recommendation results. Explore compounds the amount of effort required from users inside the platform. If it’s to work properly, you need to go beyond the check-in. Comments, likes, tips, likes on tips, saving to a list, etc. All of these are necessary. In a world where location tracking is becoming ever more passive (there are plenty of apps and devices that monitor this) it seems counter-intuitive to focus on getting more from your users.

There are other things that keep Explore from being really compelling to me. You’ll hear it framed in the context of being ‘local’ a lot. And though it is local, it’s actually most helpful when you aren’t a ‘local’. The Explore feature surfaces its utility largely when you’re away from home.

I’m fine with the fact that the game only existed to get my data. It was a fair trade. But I came to Foursquare because of a compelling offer, and if they need my check-in, it will take one to keep me. Explore isn’t it for me. So what are some of the options?

Evolve the game. It was great fun in the beginning and we know it works. Develop some additional features or rules that deepen it. If you need me to like and comment to make the recommendations better, put some game mechanics around those features. If it’s compelling enough, I’m happy to help.

Do more with my data. They have billions of points of data, some 1600 points from me alone. I’d love to see them keep innovating with this data. The new Time Machine feature is a tiny step toward that.

Give me contextual map directions. They know the places I know. Use that data to make map directions more efficient. The first 5 to 15 steps are almost always steps you know by heart: how to get out of your apartment, around the corner and into that subway. When I’m looking to get somewhere, I want the simplest, most direct directions, so that I can memorise them and not have to take screenshots or make notes. Foursquare could help.

Contextual weather would work as well. The abstraction of temperatures hasn’t ever sat well in my brain. Foursquare knows where I was yesterday, and at what time, so let’s use that to eliminate the abstraction in temperature reporting. Telling me it’s 23 outside still doesn’t do much for me (and not only because I’m a child of Fahrenheit). Tell me it’s a tiny bit cooler and cloudier than yesterday. I immediately understand what that means. That’s value.

There are a myriad of options, but it seems that Foursquare is focused on Explore for now and is putting the burden of continuing innovation with your location in the hands of the some 40,000 or so developers utilising their API.

It’s a risky move, but I hope it pays off. I love what Foursquare has done for location and for pushing things forward, and I would love nothing more than to feel compelled to keep using it.

Andrew Allen is director of interactive production at Wieden + Kennedy Amsterdam.

This World View piece first appeared in the September issue of B&T magazine. 

Please login with linkedin to comment

Latest News

Image lead story UnLtd’s ‘Big Clash’ Raises Over $120K, With Media Owners & Media Agencies Crowned Champions
  • Advertising
  • Media
  • Technology

UnLtd’s ‘Big Clash’ Raises Over $120K, With Media Owners & Media Agencies Crowned Champions

With over 50 companies taking part, the fourth annual Big Clash cricket tournament has been the biggest yet, raising $124,000. The event once again brought the industry together for a great afternoon of cricket, drinks, music, and charity activations. This year, the event was expanded to have Media Owners, Media Agencies, Techies and Creatives all […]

SCA’s Profit Drops 21% Due To “Years Of Heavy Lifting”
  • Media

SCA’s Profit Drops 21% Due To “Years Of Heavy Lifting”

Southern Cross Austereo (SCA) has experienced a negative first half of the 2018 financial year, posting a dramatic drop in overall profit and a slight drop in revenue. The group’s net profit after tax fell 21.2 per cent to $48.5 million in the six months to 31 December 2017 (compared to the previous corresponding period), […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Lord Of The Fries Pays Homage To Kanye West & Kendrick Lamar In Clever Ads Via Milkman
  • Advertising
  • Campaigns

Lord Of The Fries Pays Homage To Kanye West & Kendrick Lamar In Clever Ads Via Milkman

Creative digital agency Milkman has helped Lord of the Fries (LOTF) pay homage to two of the fast food outlet’s favourite artists through a series of clever art poster adverts. Milkman re-created the latest album covers of Kanye West and Kendrick Lamar with a LOTR vibe to highlight the brand’s hip-hop roots and its favourite albums […]

Keep Left Wins PR Account For Greening Australia
  • Marketing

Keep Left Wins PR Account For Greening Australia

PR and content marketing agency Keep Left has been selected by proactive conservation organisation Greening Australia to raise public awareness of its flagship programs and national footprint. The relationship began in 2017 when Greening Australia engaged Keep Left in support of Reef Aid, a project launched with corporate partner Virgin Australia to improve water quality […]

Now Screen Repositions Organic Care Brand With New Campaign
  • Advertising
  • Campaigns

Now Screen Repositions Organic Care Brand With New Campaign

Aussie agency Now Screen has teamed up with Organic Care to reposition the brand in what has become one of the most competitive FMCG spaces. The new campaign, ‘Caring Comes Naturally’, celebrates what Organic Care has created since its inception: products that are as good for your body as they are for the environment. In […]

Can You Speak Data?
  • Marketing
  • Opinion

Can You Speak Data?

We're certainly fluent in gibberish, balderdash and claptrap here at B&T, but sadly data isn't part of the lexicon.

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Social Change Maker Profile: Emma Heath
  • Advertising
  • Marketing
  • Media

Social Change Maker Profile: Emma Heath

B&T has partnered with UnLtd to showcase industry heroes! Well, it's arguably more heroine in the case of Emma Heath.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Ad Fraud: A Problem We Can Solve
  • Advertising
  • Opinion
  • Technology

Ad Fraud: A Problem We Can Solve

Unlike B&T's mystery office farter, this columnist argues ad fraud is a problem that can possibly be solved.

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Why We Pivoted Our ‘Specialist’ Agency Five Times In 15 Years
  • Marketing
  • Opinion

Why We Pivoted Our ‘Specialist’ Agency Five Times In 15 Years

In this opinion piece, Gavin McDonough (pictured above, co-founder and managing partner of Urban, shares through his own experience some valuable advice for independent specialist agencies. In November 2017, my brother Ryan and I celebrated 15 years in business. We started business out of my front room in Melbourne in 2002 – not with any grand […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
W+K’s Susan Hoffman Chosen As 39th AWARD Awards Chair Of Judges
  • Advertising

W+K’s Susan Hoffman Chosen As 39th AWARD Awards Chair Of Judges

Susan Hoffman, co-chief creative officer at Wieden+Kennedy (W+K), has been appointed chair of judges for the 39th AWARD Awards. Known to challenge the status quo, Hoffman is behind some of W+K’s most memorable and game-changing ads, including Nike’s ‘Revolution’, Old Spice’s ‘The Man Your Man Could Smell Like’ and Chrysler’s Super Bowl spots starring Eminem and Clint […]

Experiential Agency Kreate Gets Bought Out By Staffers
  • Marketing

Experiential Agency Kreate Gets Bought Out By Staffers

Leading experiential marketing agency, Kreate Australia is embarking on an exciting growth strategy following its purchase by three of the agency’s existing management team from its UK founder, Steve Evans.

Hurry! B&T 30 Under 30 Entries Closing Friday!
  • Advertising
  • Marketing
  • Media

Hurry! B&T 30 Under 30 Entries Closing Friday!

This is a clarion call for B&T 30 Under 30 entries, although it's probably more mariachi band than angelic harbinger.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
The Hit Network Chooses Comedian Tanya Hennessy To Host Weekend Breakfast
  • Media

The Hit Network Chooses Comedian Tanya Hennessy To Host Weekend Breakfast

Southern Cross Austereo’s Hit Network has announced that rising radio star and comedian Tanya Hennessy will take over hosting duties for its weekend breakfast slot in 2018. Hennessy will bring content to the airwaves each Saturday and Sunday morning from 7am to 9am with a regular rotation of guest co-hosts. The self-described talker, not walker […]

Straight Up PR Wins Five New Clients
  • Marketing

Straight Up PR Wins Five New Clients

Health, wellbeing and lifestyle PR agency Straight Up PR has welcomed Changing Habits, Unichi Wellness, enerGi, SleepX, and Healthie Hampers to its client portfolio. Straight Up PR’s projects will include bespoke PR services and influencer marketing packages specifically focusing on communications strategy and execution, media and influencer relations, PR launch events, product seeding and gifting, […]

March One Creates ‘Cheese For Change’ Fundraising Campaign For White Ribbon Australia
  • Advertising
  • Campaigns
  • Marketing

March One Creates ‘Cheese For Change’ Fundraising Campaign For White Ribbon Australia

Independent creative agency March One has developed a new fundraising event for White Ribbon Australia that turns a social moment into a social movement. Starting on Thursday 22 March and going until Sunday 25 March, Cheese for Change will ask Aussies to create a cheese platter that matters by gathering friends, family or co-workers together […]

Sixth Annual IGN Select Awards Winners Announced
  • Marketing

Sixth Annual IGN Select Awards Winners Announced

The winners of IGN Australia’s sixth annual Select Awards were revealed during a huge special event at the Australian National Maritime Museum in Sydney on Friday, February 16. Some 225 Media & Game Publishers alongside 320 IGN Community Gamers attended the annual event. 2017 was absolutely crammed with terrific games and several categories were extremely tightly-contested. The top […]

Meet Your Mentors For B&T Bootcamp 2018!
  • Advertising
  • Marketing
  • Media

Meet Your Mentors For B&T Bootcamp 2018!

When it comes to an industry "who's who", you'll find there won't be too much who-ing with this impressionable lot.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
ANZ Unveils Its 2018 GAYTMs
  • Marketing

ANZ Unveils Its 2018 GAYTMs

Mardi Gras is only weeks away and B&T has already hoisted the mirror ball and donned the hotpants to bring you this.