Why The NRL (And Not The AFL) Rights Deal Is Set To Be The Real Winner

Why The NRL (And Not The AFL) Rights Deal Is Set To Be The Real Winner
SHARE
THIS



In this opinion piece Luke Parry (pictured below) from Sydney digital consulting firm Wilson Fletcher says there’s a lot to learn from the way the big European and American sports bodies do their TV rights deals. And, on that, he argues the NRL’s recent deal looks a lot, lot better than perhaps the nasty things being said about it…

As any TV executive will lament – and sport executive will relish – live sport is one of the last vestiges of consistent linear viewership.

Screen Shot 2015-09-02 at 4.39.52 PM

Sports rights have been an increasingly powerful marketing device underpinning pay TV models ever since Sky lured subscribers with their 191.5m five-year football Premier League deal in 1992.

As a result of the EU’s legislation against Sky’s monopoly and the resulting collapse of Setanta, BT were able to purchase their own rather expensive marketing device for their broadband & TV services. This has proven successful for BT in recent years, but with the latest Premier League deal ringing in 70 per cent higher than last time at £5.1 billion for three seasons, one has to wonder how long this strategy can be commercially viable.

These meteoric deals haven’t been beneficial for sports viewers, but that pattern is slowly changing as governing bodies and content providers wise up to fans’ demands.

Fresh models, fresh revenue

Originally a semi-complementary service to linear TV, Netflix filled a void. It’s now a service loved by millions that creates its own world-class content. It offers superior consumer satisfaction, and is significantly denting the subscriber base of traditional TV.

But you knew all that.

While the rumours are unlikely to come to fruition, it should certainly come as no surprise that Netflix have been in discussions with the NRL and AFL here in Australia. When you consider that sports rights are typically the only thing stopping pay TV subscribers from cancelling their subscription, that could be the final nail in the coffin for the traditional bundled model.

Of course, there are also entire portions of the internet devoted to both legal & illegal alternatives to traditional sports channels. Increasingly, today’s consumers can access the content they love without being tied to the cross that is a pay TV subscription.

Nothing beats a real-world example. I needed to look no further than my 15-year-old brother-in-law who, while we were watching NRL on Foxtel one evening exclaimed entirely unprompted “I don’t know why people pay for TV anymore; apart from sports, you can get everything online.” Some 26 per cent of Australian internet users have consumed illegal content. The top two reasons which would encourage people to stop infringing were A) a reduction in the cost of legal content (39 per cent) and B) legal content being more readily available (38 per cent).

Consumer dependence on traditional pay TV is becoming less and less common, and nowhere is the trend stronger than in the US. The National Basketball Association struck a deal in October 2014 that was (unsurprisingly) unprecedented in financial value for the sport. Nothing new there. What was new: the Over-The-Top service partnership with ESPN that, while being complementary to existing subscriptions, will permit non-cable subscribers to watch any and all of the NBA games they want.

The new NBA deal saw ESPN’s average annual fees rocket from US$485 million to around US$1.47 billion: this in the midst of a cord-cutting upheaval which saw ESPN lose 3.2 million subscribers in little over a year.

Flip to baseball for a moment, and the incredible success story that is Major League Baseball Advanced Media: one of the few sporting bodies which had the strategic foresight to go out on a limb and create its own proprietary digital platform. BAM is now reaping the rewards of reliable subscriptions and satisfied users, and is also a core technology provider to the likes of HBO, WWE and Sony. Deals with the NHL and PGA have been inked recently, and BAM now stands at the forefront of sports broadcasting as it rides the unbundling wave and starts selling sports content over the internet.

Attracting users and capitalising on internet advertising growth

Yahoo has skipped the toe and dipped its whole foot into the frigid water of sports streaming with an incredible US$20 million purchase of a single NFL game being played at London’s Wembley stadium. Kick-off will be at 9.30am ET, so the audience will undoubtedly be significantly lower than other games, but factoring in that it will broadcast for free globally, and that over 30 million people visit Yahoo’s various products every single day: the audience won’t be small. Yahoo’s punt is testament to the fully-fledged power of internet advertising revenue and sponsorships.

Let’s step back for some perspective on non-linear broadcast and take a look at the burgeoning world of e-sports (competitive video gaming to the layperson). The fairly nascent Amazon-owned streaming service Twitch is already larger than 70 per cent of American TV networks after just four years in operation. More surprising still, the flagship e-sports event ‘League of Legends’ was broadcast via Twitch in 2014 and reached a global audience of 30 million people – more than the combined viewership of the 2014 MLB and NBA finals. Most compelling though is that the majority of viewers were in the under-35 demographic – the most coveted segment for internet advertisers.

Development down under

Here in Australia, the AFL and NRL have historically taken minimal steps towards a digital approach in their partnerships with Telstra. However, the Digital Pass model is somewhat restrictive, verging on pointless, as it doesn’t permit you to stream via a TV (the stream will automatically shut down when it detects an HDMI cable). It seems that the tide could be turning in favour of the fan however, and the recent news that Channel Nine has acquired digital and terrestrial rights for four games a week is a step in the right direction, as is NRL CEO Dave Smith’s accompanying pronouncement that “our focus will be on ensuring the most widespread coverage on whatever platform fans choose to watch rugby league”.

This NRL free-to-air agreement was viewed by many as a snub of Foxtel, prompting the direct involvement of Rupert Murdoch in the recent AFL rights deal. Unfortunately, it seems that the AFL have stuck with the status quo. A record $A2.5 billion deal with Foxtel, Seven and Telstra was agreed this week. Telstra’s $A300 million extends their partnership with AFL to official technology and data provider, but fans will still only be able to watch live games on tablet or mobile. No desktop or TV streaming is allowed. Even Telstra’s own upcoming Roku-powered TV service will be restricted to “extended highlights and replays”.

For all the money that’s changing hands between codes and broadcasters; the consideration for the consumer’s experience is being lost

All this means that the sole way to watch every AFL game is by paying for Foxtel; only a third of the games will be available to non-paying fans, and if you support one of the less powerful clubs then you’ll probably miss out altogether. Essentially, this “major financial windfall” for the sport is highly engineered to drive people to Foxtel subscriptions, with streaming and free-to-air viewers treated as second-class citizens.

The AFL do have one thing right though: they offer paid access to live match streams for fans living overseas. This is something they need to build on to prepare for the changing habits of their fans, but that’s not happening any time soon.

A bit further down the digital product track, Cricket Australia have taken a refreshing approach which, in the words of their GM of Media, Ben Amarfio, promises to bring fans “closer to the action via any platform”, and for a rather reasonable price too. This is an excellent example of the sport prioritising the fans and heeding the prevalence of second-screen behaviour.

An April study found that 32 per cent of sports fans now watch live sports on their mobile, up from 20 per cent in 2010. Seven West Media is paying attention to this with their “anywhere, anytime” model, which enables Australian fans to watch select live sports such as Wimbledon and Royal Ascot for free via beautifully-designed apps. Seven have got their priorities right, given that forecasts indicate the Australian internet advertising market will reach $A8.2 billion by 2019: compare that to the free-to-air TV forecast of AU$3.8 billion, and I’d want a piece of both pies too.

Help existing fans stay fans, and new supporters become fans

Sport should always be a melting pot of companionship and rivalry. Relentless commercial drivers are diluting this essence and souring our relationship with players, teams, and broadcasters. Even the Olympics are now subject to an “exclusive rights deal”.

By all means, obtaining the best deal for the sport is vital to ensure it can be sufficiently progressed, but such a strong focus on financial benefits can be detrimental to the perception of the game and push fans away.

Services that don’t bridge locations and timezones are limiting their audience growth and potential revenue: because lessons from Pirate Bay to Popcorn Time demonstrate that if you don’t provide your audience with the content they want at a price deemed reasonable, someone else will, regardless of the legality. Recent government research found that 26 per cent of the Australian internet users have consumed illegal content. Perhaps expectedly, the top two reasons which would encourage people to stop infringing were a) a reduction in the cost of legal content (39 per cent) and b) legal content being more readily available (38 per cent).

Neil Pilson, sports media consultant and former president of CBS Sports, said recently: “You’re going to be able to see major sports properties no matter where you are in the world, which is certainly a service to fans and increases the value of the property. It allows you to generate more revenue against these platforms.”

For all the money that’s changing hands between codes and broadcasters; the consideration for the consumer’s experience is being lost.

Naturally there is no industry-wide silver bullet, but it’s plain to see that with a considered approach, it’s entirely possible to design a digital product strategy that exceeds fans’ expectations and fulfils financial goals.

Full rights control is within reach of sports bodies – they just need to find the courage and expertise to get out of defence and onto the attack.

As an average fan trying to watch my favourite sport, whether I have a TV or not, I’m generally left thinking:

“Why isn’t this easier?”

As a sport broadcaster trying to create sustainable profit, I should be thinking:

“How do I keep global fans coming back?”

Every problem warrants a musical solution, so to quote the O’Jays, you’ve got to give the people what they want.

Please login with linkedin to comment

Latest News

Comexposium Takes Over NZ Partner MTS To Become Largest Trans-Tasman Events Group
  • Marketing

Comexposium Takes Over NZ Partner MTS To Become Largest Trans-Tasman Events Group

Marketing events group Comexposium has absorbed its New Zealand joint venture partner MTS to deliver an expanded event solutions business across the Trans-Tasman. The deal will see Ryf Quail (pictured above) return to Sydney to lead Comexposium Australian and Kiwi team, while his current MTS team remains in place as Comexposium employees. While the business […]

Eyeota Kick-Starts 2018 With $15.6 Million In Additional Funding
  • Marketing

Eyeota Kick-Starts 2018 With $15.6 Million In Additional Funding

Audience data provider Eyeota has announced a $15.6 million Series B capital raise to spearhead additional growth in 2018. The company was founded simultaneously in Singapore, Australia and Europe in 2010, and has remained independent and enjoyed strong growth locally, as well as launching into the US. Peter Hunter (pictured above), Eyeota’s general manager for […]

Poem Wins Four New Clients
  • Marketing

Poem Wins Four New Clients

Sydney-based PR and social agency Poem has announced it has won four new clients following another strong year of growth. The four clients are Property NSW (The Rocks and Darling Harbour), Fantastic Furniture, Ovolo Hotels and Purpose (a conference on purpose-driven business). Poem co-founder Matt Holmes said: “We’ve hit a nerve with clients who are […]

Facebook Makes Another News Feed Change
  • Media

Facebook Makes Another News Feed Change

Social media behemoth Facebook has announced its second major update for News Feed to make sure the news people see, while less overall, is high quality. This week, Facebook announced that the platform will launch a small test in the US focused on prioritising news from publishers that users find trustworthy. Facebook is also exploring ways […]

Attention! B&T’s Inaugural Bootcamp Launches!
  • Advertising
  • Marketing
  • Media
  • Technology

Attention! B&T’s Inaugural Bootcamp Launches!

B&T announces its new industry bootcamp! And, if you're like us & didn't know anything about it, all's revealed here.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Domain Boss Antony Catalano Exits
  • Media

Domain Boss Antony Catalano Exits

Mystery surrounds Domain boss's surprise exit, although the Mystery Machine nor a talking dog not spotted at Fairfax.

PHOTOPLAY Offers A Ghost Train Ride Like No Other At Sydney Festival
  • Media

PHOTOPLAY Offers A Ghost Train Ride Like No Other At Sydney Festival

Jasmin Tarasin, director at boutique production company PHOTOPLAY, is inviting invites audiences to take a trip through the inner-workings of the mind in ‘Ghost Train’, her latest multi-sensory VR project set to feature at this year’s Sydney Festival. Working in collaboration with musician and co-creative director Jonnine Standish, Tarasin’s uniquely immersive ‘Ghost Train’ is a […]

March One To Rebrand Fundraising Institute Australia
  • Marketing

March One To Rebrand Fundraising Institute Australia

Independent advertising and branding agency March One has been appointed to oversee the rebrand and repositioning of Fundraising Institute Australia (FIA). FIA is the national peak body representing professional fundraising in Australia. It was established to advance advocacy and professional standards, and has identified the need to better promote its role as the industry self-regulator, […]

Victorian Government Launches VR Bushfire Experience Via The Fuel Agency
  • Advertising
  • Campaigns
  • Technology

Victorian Government Launches VR Bushfire Experience Via The Fuel Agency

As part of its summer fire campaign, the Victorian government has launched a virtual reality (VR) bushfire experience and content series via The Fuel Agency. The VR experience places the user in the midst of a large bushfire, and is designed to encourage people to leave early on high-risk days before it’s too late. The […]

Local Ad Tech Company VeNA Partners With RugbyPass
  • Advertising
  • Media
  • Technology

Local Ad Tech Company VeNA Partners With RugbyPass

ad tech company VeNA has signed an exclusive reseller partnership covering Australia and New Zealand with digital rugby network RugbyPass. Across Asia and parts of Europe, RugbyPass is the exclusive digital rights holder and over-the-top broadcaster for live rugby, including the Super Rugby, the Rugby Championship and autumn internationals, the Six Nations, the Aviva Premiership, […]