The $6 Million (US) Dollar Tweet?

The $6 Million (US) Dollar Tweet?
SHARE
THIS



One of the best methods for getting your brand message across to thousands of people at very little expense is to utilise social media and engage a celebrity with a post, particularly on Twitter, in the hope that they share it with their many thousands or millions of followers.

Perhaps this is what the Duane Reade publicity team were hoping to achieve when they posted an image that showed Katherine Heigl emerging from its New York store recently. The pharmacy’s tweet (see image) was seemingly innocent enough and received a modest (if not paltry) number of retweets and favourites – none of which were sadly by Heigl. Instead, what they got was a lawsuit for $6 million in damages (roughly half of what she earns per film – not bad work for the couple of minutes the post would have taken to write, although it should be noted she has pledged any and all funds to her charity).

Image source: supplied

Over the last few years social media has opened the door for brands to engage with celebrities like never before with free and paid for opportunities. But this has blurred the lines of what is acceptable, and the Heigl case reflects how unsolicited engagement can leave brands susceptible to legal action.

The crux of the issue is this – does the tweet construe advertising? Has it been worded in such a way that it implies that Katherine Heigl is endorsing Duane Reade pharmacy? Well, that’s what Heigl’s lawyers are arguing.

In documents released by the New York Post, it states that the suit is being brought against the pharmacy for the use of the unsolicited image and promotional caption on its Twitter and Facebook accounts, in an act that is defined as for its own ‘commercial advertising’ without Heigl’s knowledge or approval. The suit also infers that the posts were ‘aimed at attracting customers and revenue, especially social media savvy customers’.   

The image itself came from the paparazzi site Just Jared. But how Duane Reade came across it is a mystery, as the image has not been used widely by the site and only appears when explicitly searching for the star on the site. Also, it brings into question if the unsolicited picture was used in a newspaper or on a TV broadcast, is that not then also promoting that paper, magazine or TV brand? Is Duane Read’s crime that they used it on social media with wording that is ambiguous? In fact, do they even have permission to use the image? The tweet didn’t seem to credit Just Jared – awkward.

Whatever your contention, Maryland Professor of Law, James Grimmelman, affirms that grounds of the suit will be considered by the US legal system. When speaking with AdWeek last week he said: “Courts are perfectly willing to treat these kind of tweets as advertising and promotion. That means that despite the spontaneity of what comes up in social media, brands need to be thinking about it with the foresight that they use with advertising and in magazines.”

The question now then is ‘what is acceptable?’ If a celebrity posts an image to their social media channels enjoying a drink, with some new sunglasses or at a particular bar etc that they post themselves, what happens when that brand engages with the post referencing said star enjoying their product?  Is that grounds for a lawsuit or is the issue the wording in the Heigl matter or the fact that it’s an attempt by the pharmacy to spark a conversation? 

Whilst this is an American case, it has worldwide implications. For years, I have worked with brands on their social media trying to educate them as to the differences of using social media personally and professionally. For me, this seems to be where the lines have blurred. There have been numerous instances where the different brands that I’ve worked with have utilised a celebrity post and what this case demonstrates is the lack of clear guidance as to what’s acceptable.

In essence, this could be a definitive turning point in the use of social media by brands in relation to what pertains to advertising and promotion. At the very least, it is a warning about what is and is not acceptable in relation to celebrity posting.

However, allow me to play devil’s advocate if I may and refer to an old adage that may go some way to easing the woes of Duane Reade and that’s ‘There’s no such thing as bad publicity.’ Whilst the case may be ongoing and a possible settlement reached before its conclusion, Duane Reade has received coverage that conservatively is worth a couple of million dollars at least and has made the pharmacy infamous in the last week.

Unlikely supporters of the brand have also emerged from the woodwork, including Piers Morgan who tweeted to his 4 million followers “Hi @DuaneRead – unlike @KatieHeigl , I am very happy to be photographed coming out of your excellent stores. And feel free to tweet it.” (Although the jury is still out if this will entice more patrons or drive them away for fear of running into Piers Morgan).

Whatever the outcome, the pharmacy chain will undoubtedly benefit from the massive amount of publicity the case has received and will continue to receive over the next few weeks. But one thing’s for sure, next time I’m in America and need to visit a pharmacy, I’ll be looking for a Duane Reade (I’ll even let them tweet it… for a small price).

Lee Hall, InsideOut PR

Please login with linkedin to comment

Latest News

Bauer’s Cosmo Named Official Mardi Gras Media Partner
  • Marketing
  • Media

Bauer’s Cosmo Named Official Mardi Gras Media Partner

Bauer Media has announced Cosmopolitan magazine as an official media partner of the 2018 Sydney Gay and Lesbian Mardi Gras. COSMO’s Mardi Gras sponsorship will deliver a month-long celebration of activities in the Parade’s 40th anniversary year. In addition to the event sponsorship, COSMO is producing its second Pride Issue for March, on sale 5th […]

A Guide To Understanding Your Digital Marketer
  • Opinion

A Guide To Understanding Your Digital Marketer

In this guest column, Logie-nominated journalist, Leisa Goddard (main photo), who is also the managing director of media, PR and digital agency, Adoni Media, offers her personal guide to making your way through digital marketing buzzwords and gobbledygook… Do you feel as though your digital marketer speaks to you in a language you don’t understand? In today’s highly-competitive world […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
SpotX Appoints Gavin Buxton As Asia MD
  • Advertising

SpotX Appoints Gavin Buxton As Asia MD

Video advertising platform SpotX has announced it has appointed Gavin Buxton as managing director of Asia to lead the company’s expansion in the region. Buxton has over 17 years’ global experience in the digital advertising space, having worked in leadership roles at tech and publishing companies, including Microsoft, Turner Broadcasting, and LinkedIn, with the last […]

Big Mobile Doubles Down On Ad Tech & Rebrands
  • Advertising
  • Technology

Big Mobile Doubles Down On Ad Tech & Rebrands

B&T Awards 2017 finalist Big Mobile has unveiled a fresh look to reflect its new ad tech credentials. The company successfully pivoted its business from ad network to mobile ad tech vendor when it announced a joint venture (JV) with Widespace in October last year. As a result of the business changes, Big Mobile wanted […]

March One Appoints New Senior Account Manager
  • Advertising

March One Appoints New Senior Account Manager

Independent ad agency March One has appointed a fresh face to the team, with Melanie Tozer to reinforce its mission to put humans first as a senior account manager. Tozer (pictured above), an up-and-coming talent from New Zealand, will align her extensive experience in FMCG marketing with March One, having worked on accounts for Bunnings […]

What To Expect From The App Economy In 2018
  • Opinion
  • Technology

What To Expect From The App Economy In 2018

Here's an insightful, authoritative synopsis of the app economy. So, you're right, it wasn't written by a B&T journo.

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Farm Foods Rebrands To Target Modern Aussie Families Via Tiny Hunter
  • Marketing

Farm Foods Rebrands To Target Modern Aussie Families Via Tiny Hunter

Seasoned meat supplier Farm Foods Butchers has rebranded its selection of sausages, burgers, meatballs and ready-to-cook meat products to appeal to the modern Aussie family. The 100 per cent family-owned and operated business based in Breakwater, Victoria worked with Sydney-based branding and packaging design company Tiny Hunter. Together, they created a brand which connects with […]

Animal Logic Shows Off New Website In Collaboration With Protein One
  • Marketing
  • Media

Animal Logic Shows Off New Website In Collaboration With Protein One

Aussie visual FX and feature animation studio Animal Logic has unveiled its new web experience – a reimagined website – in collaboration with Sydney digital agency Protein One. Animal Logic felt it was important to engage a local digital agency to represent its brand online. The company’s online personality was one that required a team […]

Raunchy Marathon Ad Causes Utter Confusion
  • Campaigns

Raunchy Marathon Ad Causes Utter Confusion

B&T likes to award the "dumbest ad of the day" with a 15-inch devon knob. And this would be a processed meats shoe-in.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Red Agency Wins Bio-Oil PR Account
  • Marketing

Red Agency Wins Bio-Oil PR Account

Red Agency staff set to challenge for the record for most people to squeeze into a lift after winning Bio-Oil business.