Media Rebates Rife In Media Buying Claims Damning Industry Report

Media Rebates Rife In Media Buying Claims Damning Industry Report
SHARE
THIS



There’s a number of dodgy practices afoot in the media buying landscape in the States, a new study has found.

Industry body for US Adland, the National Association of Advertisers (ANA), has released a damning report of buying practices, claiming a number of cash rebates and non-transparent practices from media agencies were rife in the US landscape. The report also found a disconnect between the way media agencies and clients think of each other. Clients believe the agencies will act in their best interests, many agencies said they just fulfill contractual obligations.

The practices within the report were not limited to any one kind of medium or particular type of agency. The findings were detailed in the 58 page report, which you can download here.

“Advertisers and their agencies are lacking ‘full disclosure’ as the cornerstone principle of their media management practices,” said Bob Liodice, president and CEO of the ANA in a statement.

“Such disclosure is absolutely essential if they are to build trust as the foundation of their relationships with their long-term business partners.

“Whether acting as agency or principal, vast changes in technology, the complex digital supply chain, and the proliferation of media outlets provided agencies with additional opportunities to increase their profit margins beyond agency fees.

“This has led to disconcerting conflicts of interest and a lack of transparency.”

The study was conducted by research company K2. K2 interviewed 150 individual sources in all aspects of media buying over eight months. The ANA wanted to conduct a proper analysis of the current landscape due to the mounting concern in the States of lack of transparency and a lack of common perspective regarding what practices were appropriate or not. K2 said it was not intended as a ‘pointing-the-finger’ blame game.

During a conference call about this report, Liodice said he couldn’t comment on the legalities of the widespread practices found in the report, according to AdAge. However, many media agencies have already hit back at the report, claiming inconsistencies and “subjective methodologies”.

Below is further detail on the report.

Rebate Deals

In this context, the study defined a rebate broadly as “a benefit that a media supplier provides to a media agency”. And of the 150 sources interviewed for the study, 41 had firsthand knowledge of these kinds of deals happening, with 34 saying the deals hadn’t been disclosed to the advertiser.

The report said the rebate deals were conducted in different ways. Some were incentives in the form of cash or free media, and others were service agreements – however the service suggested, such as research or consulting, was often not carried out.

And many of the rebates were not disclosed to the advertiser. This lack of transparency had K2 suggesting it forged “potentially problematic conduct” – where the practices may not be in the best interests of the advertiser.

Another practice highlighted in the report was from agencies that held stakes in media suppliers. A number of former senior execs at these agencies said they’d felt pressure from higher up to spend in these suppliers because of the stakes held, the study claimed.

Client/Agency relationship disconnect

Another key finding from the report was a mismatch between how agencies and clients think of each other. Advertisers were under the belief agencies would act in the client’s best interests, with many adamant it would extend beyond just the agency’s contractual obligations. In the report, K2 cited a number of senior marketing execs who expressed similar connotations to “my agency has to be my agent”.

Generally speaking, there was the assumption the agency and client were in an equal partnership. And there were a number of agencies who felt the same and did their best to act in their clients’ best interests.

However, there were also a fair few agency side who said they were just there to fulfil their contractual obligations. Similarly, some agency heads were feeling the pressure from the agency’s holding groups to act in their best interests, which sometimes conflicts with the client’s best interests.

“The K2 Intelligence report unearthed a ‘fundamental disconnect’ between advertisers and their media agencies,” said ANA chairman Tony Pace.

“As media practices have become more complex, stewardship and oversight needs to become more precise, more thorough, and more fully transparent.”

Download the full study here.

 

Latest News

Why Programmatic Needs To Become A Branding Machine
  • Advertising
  • Marketing
  • Opinion
  • Technology

Why Programmatic Needs To Become A Branding Machine

In this opinion piece, Phil Murrell (pictured below), country manager for Australia and New Zealand at Sizmek, argues that programmatic ad spend needs to move up the branding funnel. When I started in digital advertising way back in 2004, we got our media insertion orders via the fax machine. We relied on that machine to […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Do Not Disconnect… Why The Telephone Is Still As Relevant For Advertisers As Ever
  • Opinion

Do Not Disconnect… Why The Telephone Is Still As Relevant For Advertisers As Ever

In this guest post, CEO of Delacon, Michael Center (pictured below), argues in favour of something we don’t hear too much a bout these days – the good old fashioned telephone… It’s 142 years since Alexander Graham Bell made his first call on 10 March 1876 to his assistant Thomas Watson, where he uttered the […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
An Apology To Salmat’s Karen Lewis
  • Media

An Apology To Salmat’s Karen Lewis

Whoops! B&T's stuffed up and this certainly comes with our sincerest apologies for any offence caused.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Adland Execs To Be Locked Up
  • Media

Adland Execs To Be Locked Up

Continuing adland's fascination with prison when it comes to charitable causes comes this latest trip to the slammer.

Australian Directors’ Guild Announces Mentorship Winners
  • Campaigns
  • Media

Australian Directors’ Guild Announces Mentorship Winners

Now in its second year, the Australian Directors’ Guild’s (ADG) Commercial & Content Directing Mentorship program announced its next round of eight mentoree recipients. The winners were announced at a special event held last night at FINCH, Sydney and attended by members of the screen and advertising industries. Acclaimed director, and ADG President, Samantha Lang, […]

Diversity Case Study Series: OMD
  • Advertising
  • Marketing
  • Media

Diversity Case Study Series: OMD

One need only look at the Cadbury Favourites chocolate selection to know it has nought to do with industry diversity.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Eyeota Deep Dives Into Australian Automotive Purchase Behaviour
  • Media

Eyeota Deep Dives Into Australian Automotive Purchase Behaviour

Eyeota, the global leader in audience data, has today released its latest results on automotive purchase intentions in Australia. The results provide a deep dive into what motivates the buyer and segments those into six different personas.

APN Outdoor Joins The AANA
  • Marketing
  • Media

APN Outdoor Joins The AANA

AANA's annual Christmas dinner and dance got a teensy bit more crowded following this announcement this morning.

QMS Introduces ‘The Lonsdale’ To Melbourne
  • Advertising
  • Media

QMS Introduces ‘The Lonsdale’ To Melbourne

Digital outdoor media company QMS Media has turned on a new premium landmark digital billboard situated in the heart of Melbourne’s CBD. Delivering a commanding presence at the major intersection of Lonsdale and Russell Streets, ‘The Lonsdale’ offers extended dwell times to both vehicle and pedestrian traffic, impacting more than 2.2 million contacts per month. […]

Portrait of a woman looking through out the blinds. Office worker looking through window blinds
  • Opinion

The Lurking Brand Threats Facing CMOs

Treading on gardening rakes and possible alien abduction notable omissions from this CMO threats piece.

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Women In Media Profile: Susannah George
  • Media

Women In Media Profile: Susannah George

B&T is delighted to profile Urbanlist supremo Susannah George who, we understand, is not related to George Brandis.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Ikon Lands Avis Budget Group Account
  • Advertising
  • Marketing
  • Media

Ikon Lands Avis Budget Group Account

B&T chooses and recommends Avis and John Karandonis shoes. Hang on, that was the end of Sale Of The Century.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Principals Appoints New Creative Director For Melbourne
  • Marketing

Principals Appoints New Creative Director For Melbourne

Branding design agency Principals has announced the appointment of Pip Ireland as its Melbourne creative director. Ireland, who has been freelancing with the agency for the past six months, has previously held roles at Designworks in New Zealand and Melbourne as well as Moon Communications in Sydney. Principals executive creative director Simon Wright said: “We’ve […]

Pureprofile Unveils Next-Level Audience Segmentation Offering With RDA Research
  • Media
  • Technology

Pureprofile Unveils Next-Level Audience Segmentation Offering With RDA Research

Global media and technology company Pureprofile has partnered with RDA Research to enable further audience segmentation across its audience profiles. RDA Research’s geoTribes is a unique classification system that rivals traditional geodemographic approaches by grouping consumers into fifteen ‘tribes’ based on their life stage and socio-economic status. Clients are then able to better understand consumer […]