Losing Relevance In A Fragmented World: We Need A New Agency Model

Losing Relevance In A Fragmented World: We Need A New Agency Model
SHARE
THIS



Agencies need a new model, as the current one is too expensive and ineffective. This will be the year it all changes, argues Jason Dooris, CEO of media agency Atomic212.

Many agencies have lost their way. Many have failed to maintain relevance, are too expensive and have lost their edge. However, agency leaders – not everyone, but a large mass – seem blissfully unaware of the dramatic scale of change going on around them.

Agencies scramble to prop up regimes that have simply lost connection with their customers, big agency CEOs have gone AWOL around the big issues and questions, and we continue to charge clients using remuneration models developed in the sixties. Customers have moved on, but the industry has not.

But it will in 2016. This is the year that everything will change, the year where there will be no place to hide for the stagnant. The new model agency will step up or step out. In a world where agency silos are rife and where the capabilities and services of agencies continue to expand and fracture, the businesses that succeed will be those that centralise their offer are streamlined KPIs, single P&Ls and effective internal account management processes and systems.

The past 18 months

We are entering the eye of a consumer storm. In meteorological terms the eye of a storm is the region of mostly calm weather found at the centre of strong tropical cyclones. An area preceded by great turbulence, uncertainty and devastation. This devastation is clearly reflected in the movement of client business, the mass departure of agency leadership across the industry, an erosion of trust in agency partners and a general feeling that 2015 was a very hard year on many people. How agencies emerge from the eye of the storm is up to those respective businesses and their leadership teams.

There are many contributing factors to the current demise of agencies, or at least agency models.

Technology continues to drive massive fragmentation of consumer media consumption. Agencies and the media have scrambled to keep up in meeting consumption habits and developing effective client media solutions. Agencies began by building verticals, silos and specialist capabilities such as digital, search, mobile, social or more recently – programmatic. But technology and innovation emerge relentlessly, such that more and more vertical silos are needed constantly to meet new demand. This has paved the way for smaller one-man specialists to compete with the biggest agencies in town, driving down costs to unsustainable levels for the bigger agencies, and occasionally driving behaviours best left unseen. The smaller agencies get snapped up by the bigger agencies which are trying to maintain momentum. The rest is history.

What does the future agency look like?

One successful model for the agency of the future is a slimmed down, streamlined network of three core creative media companies ring-fenced by a central communications advisory and management business (CCAMB).

The creative media companies are not vertical silos. Vertical silos are industry killers in disguise. The creative media companies are agencies or divisions defined by broad territory of expertise – there is no room for media verticals. The territories are:

  1.      CCAMB: Client service and management.
  2.      Strategy: Pioneering thinking and problem solving
  3.      Performance media: Driving retail outcomes
  4.      Brands: Driving brand outcomes

You could call this the Uber effect – clients want the same service as passengers, a service that is reliable, on brand and relevant at that given moment in time. They want one platform to make that happen for them, the Uber App or in the case of the future agency model the CCAMB.

The glue that integrates the divisions and capabilities together is the CCAMB. Yes that’s right. It’s that simple and it’s unbelievably functional.

But isn’t that exactly what we have now? In theory yes, but in practice no, which is why the agency world hurts so much, why clients are so frustrated and why nobody is making any money, at least not in the ways they should be. Agencies don’t actually have central control, and certainly not in an integrated fashion. We have separate P&Ls, separate businesses and separate agendas. We call it integration when it is in fact disintegration. It is this disintegration that has paved the way for management consultants and small start-ups to move into the traditional zones of marketing companies with such ease. They are very good at central management and neutrality is second nature. There are lessons to be learnt here.

Exactly what does the CCAMB do? It completely and entirely owns and manages the client’s business and the agency group’s business, with centralised control over P&L. The multiple chains of client service relationship increase costs and complexity, and create tension and disintegration. It is impossible to expect an agency to own the client relationship on behalf of other agencies and businesses with whom it does not share direct financial and P&L accountability. There will be readers now saying to themselves that this is simply a description of an account management function, but that is just the point, because a lack of ability to manage integrated, media neutral outcomes for clients is holding the industry back. There is a structural issue, not a creative one, and structural issues cost everyone money.

Think of the future agency model in the same way you would a truck full of stationery en route from the stationery shop to a customer. In the current model if the customer orders stationery a truck arrives to deliver the rubber, another to deliver a pen, another to deliver a ruler and so forth. The ruler, pen and rubber all look different, the rubber doesn’t rub out ink and the roads are jammed with trucks. The combined delivery cost is more than the cost of the stationery. It just doesn’t make sense. A central advisor and account management service works much better and saves costs that can be deployed in far more effective ways.

The good news is we have started to see the semblance of this structure developing across many agency groups. The bad news is none appear to have supported these developing divisional themes with internal centralised profit centres.

Agency divisions continue to compete with each other and do not work cohesively. The winners in 2016 will be the ones that do.

Please login with linkedin to comment

helloworld KDPR

Latest News

Nine Reveals Its 2019 Line-Up, Including The Return Of SeaChange, ABBA & Lego!
  • Media

Nine Reveals Its 2019 Line-Up, Including The Return Of SeaChange, ABBA & Lego!

Nine has unveiled its 2019 line-up of shows at its gala upfronts in Sydney on Wednesday night. A mix of old and a few new, probably the biggest surprise was news that the network had snared Aussie drama SeaChange – starring Sigrid Thornton and John Howard – that was last seen on the ABC in […]

Pause Fest Hits Play On Massive 2019 Line-up & Awards
  • Media

Pause Fest Hits Play On Massive 2019 Line-up & Awards

One of the industry’s biggest events is returning in 2019 with a huge speaker line-up, incredible activations and some seriously enviable networking opportunities. That’s right, Pause Fest is back, and it’s time to hit play on your ticket buying, because this is an event you cannot afford to miss. Pause Fest is boasting talent from […]

Partner Content

by pause fest

Nine Launches 9Voyager To Attract Small To Medium Advertisers
  • Media

Nine Launches 9Voyager To Attract Small To Medium Advertisers

Nine today unveiled the next stage of plans to simplify and further automate the buying of television through its unique proprietary technology 9Galaxy and launched 9Voyager, aimed at opening the TV market to more small and medium enterprise (SME) owners. 9Voyager, released at the media company’s 9Upfront event in Sydney, will allow Nine to better […]

Nine Sets Sights On Lucrative Premium Partnership Space
  • Marketing
  • Media

Nine Sets Sights On Lucrative Premium Partnership Space

Nine has showcased its premium partnership space through the strategic client solutions division, 9Powered, at its 2019 Upfront event on Wednesday evening. In unveiling its 2019 program slate, Nine highlighted how, through its schedule it delivers marketers cross-platform opportunity to align with powerful “water cooler” content and reach mass audiences at scale, delivering real, measurable […]

The Aussie Open & NRL Headline Nine’s 2019 Year Of Sport
  • Media

The Aussie Open & NRL Headline Nine’s 2019 Year Of Sport

Nine has used its upfronts to reveal its plans for Wide World of Sports for 2019. Nine’s Director of Sport, Tom Malone, used the Nine Upfront event to talk about the acquisition of tennis and the strategic rationale and power of Nine’s cross-platform suite of properties – tennis, rugby league, cricket, netball, basketball and golf. “It has been […]

Nine Reveals Its News & Current Affairs Plans For 2019
  • Media

Nine Reveals Its News & Current Affairs Plans For 2019

Nine has used Wednesday night’s Upfronts to reveal to media and advertisers its news and current affairs plans for 2019. From 5.00am, we present Nine News Early Edition with the latest in overnight breaking news from around the world. At 5.30am Today, hosted by Karl Stefanovic and Georgie Gardner. In 2019, Australia’s longest running breakfast […]

Bold Adshel Campaign Pays Off For SA Tourism Commission
  • Media

Bold Adshel Campaign Pays Off For SA Tourism Commission

South Australian Tourism Commission (SATC) has achieved outstanding results from a daring, unbranded ‘teaser’ campaign across the Adshel network. The campaign highlighted seven little-known parts of South Australia, repositioning them as hidden, luxury tourist destinations. The ‘Tell Us Where’ campaign rolled out across digital small format out-of-home Adshel sites in Sydney, Melbourne, Brisbane and Adelaide, […]

How Nike Missed The Mark On Digital
  • Marketing
  • Opinion

How Nike Missed The Mark On Digital

Nike may be the brand held up by pretty much every marketer, but as digital marketing consultant, Tam Al-Saad (pictured below), says in this guest post, when it comes to digital, the sports behemoths still needs to just “do it”… By now you should have seen or heard of the Nike “Dream Crazy” campaign. It’s the one […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine