Is Metadata A Marketer’s Best Friend Or Possible Worst Enemy?

Is Metadata A Marketer’s Best Friend Or Possible Worst Enemy?
SHARE
THIS



Corporations are starting to keep a heap of data on all of us. But who owns it, who can access it and what are the implications if you do? Here, ContactAbility managing director, Zoe Catchlove, says a recent Australian court case will have implications for all of us.

Last month Ben Grubb – a Fairfax telco and tech journalist – won a court case against Telstra to obtain access to his metadata[1]. The decision was two years in the making highlighting how important the issue of metadata privacy is. It is safe to say this is not going away and there’s no doubt it will play out in the world of marketing very soon – a good reason for marketers to keep up to speed with it now. In other words, Ben Grubb is just the beginning.

 

The case in point

This case is not about what information is being collected but rather whether consumers can have access to all their information that’s is collected.

Grubb asked the Privacy Commissioner to agree that the metadata Telstra had on him was “personal information” and that he has a right to access it. After all, law-enforcement and intelligence agencies can access it without a warrant – as can councils and the RSPCA – so why can’t he?

Grubb’s intention in pursing this with Telstra was to show Australians what metadata is and what is being done with it. (For more on Grubb’s perspective watch this video explaining the issue and the case.)

In the time it took Grubbto win the court case he not only gained access to his metadata, he – just as importantly – gained agreement from the Privacy Commissioner that metadata is indeed deemed to be personal information. This is significant because metadata (by its definition) does often not contain a consumer’s name, address or email details.

So, what is metadata exactly?

Essentially metadata is ‘data about data’ in relation to telephone and internet activity. The Australian Attorney General defines it as 1) Information that allows a communication to occur and 2) Information about the parties to the communications.[2]

In Understanding Metadata Guenther and Radebaugh explain that it “assists in resource discovery by allowing resources to be found by relevant criteria, identifying resources, bringing similar resources together, distinguishing dissimilar resources, and giving location information.”[3]

So even though metadata does not show the content of emails, texts, calls and web browsing history it does record a whole lot of other information that can be used to track a person down and reveal their identity. Although not content specific this metadata can be used to identify when, where, for how long and with whom a person is communicating. [4] Needless to say, analogies like ‘metatdata is what’s written on the envelope not the letter’ (as some politicians have stated) shouldn’t be used because they are misleading and downplay the issue of privacy considerably.

The greatest challenge from the Privacy Commissioner’s perspective is to accurately define metadata. In the Grubb/Telstra ruling a consumer’s metadata includes the phone numbers called but not, for example, the numbers of incoming calls to Grubb’s phone as this would be a breach of the caller’s privacy.

Metadata disclosure comes with a challenge

Customers like Ben Grubb (and so many others) view access to their metadata as a personal right. And why shouldn’t they know what information a company holds on them? What’s more, it’s not their problem what the business challenges are in providing it. And oh, there are some challenges. Some identified during this court case were:

1) Ability to provide

Organisations need to figure out ways to efficiently and securely provide customers with their metadata on request. By Telstra’s own admission there appear to be only 120 staff in the entire business that could access all the internal systems (and interrogate them appropriately) that house pieces of an individuals metadata to get the information required. That’s a huge headache for companies – how do they resource these requests when they have, in this case, data spread across 30 different systems?

2) Cost

What technology and human capital are businesses going to need to make this process efficient and cost effective? Government, business and/or consumers will have to pay for the storage and security of release. The Government’s new data retention laws which allow 85 security and policing agencies to access two years of a person’s metadata is predicted to cost $400 million per year. If there were no Government support for this it would cost the customer about $3.98 per year.[5] Some would say this is a small price to pay for reducing crime, others would say it’s far too hefty a price for the potential invasion of privacy.

3) A universal definition

We need to ascertain a universal definition of metadata. For example, is the location of a mobile phone tower that carried a phone call a consumer made their information? Probably not, or is it? It’s likely to be a security risk to the telco at the very least.

Another thing to consider is that technology allows marketers (and their big businesses employers) to collect huge volumes of data from many locations (e.g. Twitter, Facebook, their own database, call centre agents, consumers themselves filling out forms and webpages etc). This of course widens the landscape for personal information requests even further but must be included if a universal definition if to be accurate.

4) Data security

An organisation that deals with big data should consider the impact this case has on their data security. Just because a customer’s name or other identifiers are left off the data it doesn’t mean that someone’s identity cannot be found. Former Deputy Privacy Commissioner for NSW, Anna Johnston warns: “The cautious thing for organisations to do now is to assume that even ‘anonymised’ data meets the definition of ‘personal information’… [and that if data] was lost the organisation could be fined by the Privacy Commissioner if it didn’t take reasonable steps to protect it.”[6]

Every single person who touches a customer’s personal information or has any interaction with a customer should be cautious with what they do with the information they record. The challenge is not only making the data available to share on demand but also ensuring that it is appropriate to store. You can no longer get away with writing ‘painful customer’ in the call notes when someone complains to your customer service team as the customer may read it!

The customer’s perspective

How many customers are like Ben Grubb? How many would like to know what their privacy rights are and what’s being done with their metadata? I’m betting a lot. To start the investigation rolling, however, a customer will immediately come up against one giant hurdle: information overload – unfortunately for them it’s not of the ‘personal metadata’ kind.

A recent study in the US showed that if you read the privacy policies of the top 100 websites it would take 30 days every year to stay up-to-date with them.[7] We’re guessing most people aren’t going to read the policy for every website they visit considering it is estimated we visit just under 90 domains a month.[8] As information and security law specialist Professor Fred Cate put it: “Privacy policies are pretty much useless. You wouldn’t sit down and read Hamlet, you’re not very likely to sit down and read the privacy policy.”[9]

Others with strong views on the subject (like Anthony Bendall, Victoria’s 2012 acting Privacy Commissioner) believe that data retention is “characteristic of a police state” and “is premised on the assumption that all citizens should be monitored”.[10]

You can see why this is such a hot (as in inflammatory!) subject. Hence why I’m encouraging marketers to consider and follow developments closely.

Tap here for a real life (and quite neat) example of how metadata can be used to breach privacy.

Metadata: a Marketer’s friend or foe?

The privacy commissioner is opening the floodgates to many more consumers requesting their metadata by handing down the ruling in favour of Grubb. The Government is also obviously expecting more of these sorts of challenges given they have just given additional funding in the recent budget to help guide the telcos regarding privacy. (See: National Security Funding)

Marketers should study the Australian Privacy Principles carefully. The Principles state that companies must only collect the information they need in order to deliver their services or products. They should not collect information they might need in the future about someone or any ‘nice-to-haves’. This is more important than ever given the result of the Grubb/Telstra case.

The Grubb/Telstra case could be a game-changer for the marketing profession with transparency and security set to have a makeover. Whether marketers like it or not the metadata issue is not going away which is why I suggest self-regulating now.

Here are some questions every marketer should be asking:

  • What metadata do we currently have stored on our customers?
  • Is there anything we don’t need and could stop collecting?
  • How easy is it for customers to access their metadata?
  • How can we regulate our metadata privacy practices better?

 

 

[1] Wikipedia, Metadata, viewed 29.5.2015

[2] Read: What is ‘metadata’ and should you worry if yours is stored by law? for a comprehensive explanation on what metadata is.

[3] National Information Standards Organization; Rebecca Guenther and Jaqueline Radebaugh (2004). Understanding Metadata (PDF). Bethesda, MD: NISO Press. ISBN 1-880124-62-9. Retrieved 2 April 2014.

[4] ABC News, Privacy Commissioner rules metadata personal, viewed 29.5.2015

[5] SMH, Elise Scott, Senate passes controversial metadata laws, viewed 29.5.2015

[6] SMH, Ben Grubb, Me and my metadata: How I beat Telstra after my 22-month legal battle, viewed 29.5.2015

[7] ABC News, Privacy Commissioner rules metadata personal, viewed 29.5.2015

[8] Credit Loan, How The World Spends Its Time Online, viewed 29.5.2015

[9] ABC News, Privacy Commissioner rules metadata personal, viewed 29.5.2015

[10] SMH, What is metadata and should you worry if yours is stored by law? viewed 29.5.2015

Please login with linkedin to comment

Latest News

Mobiddiction Wins Innovation Award At IABCA 2018
  • Media

Mobiddiction Wins Innovation Award At IABCA 2018

Sydney based tech consultants, Mobiddiction, has been crowned with the  Excellence in Innovation Award at the 2018 India Australia Business & Community Awards. Held at Brisbane  City Hall for the second consecutive year, the awards celebrate the Australia India relationship while honouring migrant entrepreneurship and community leadership and aims to raise awareness of Indians in […]

Indie Agency Edge Up Creative Recruits After A Series Of Wins
  • Media

Indie Agency Edge Up Creative Recruits After A Series Of Wins

Following recent new business wins including WW (formerly Weight Watchers), NGS Super and BASF, indie creative and content agency Edge has hired creative duo Peter Mountford (left in photo) and Salvatore Cavallaro (right). Copywriter Mountford was previously at Leo Burnett and R/GA, having worked on clients such as Telstra and McDonald’s, while art director Cavallaro was […]

Luminoso Launches Of Revolutionary Business Model
  • Media

Luminoso Launches Of Revolutionary Business Model

Marketing, technology and creative recruitment firm Luminoso is disrupting the recruitment industry with the launch of a new business model that puts its customers’ interests above short-term revenue. Under the new business model, Luminoso will no longer bill its clients on the first day a successful candidate starts work. Instead, it will share the risk […]

Former Dentsu Exec Kym Pfitzner Joins Six O’Clock Advisory As Chairman
  • Marketing

Former Dentsu Exec Kym Pfitzner Joins Six O’Clock Advisory As Chairman

Australian-owned strategic communication firm Six O’Clock Advisory has announced the appointment of Kym Pfitzner as chairman. The 25-year media and marketing veteran will take up the non-executive post at the company from 14 January 2019. Pfitzner joins Six O’Clock Advisory as a highly-regarded adviser and director who has held senior leadership roles in the Asia […]

WPP AUNZ Study: Aussies Found To Regularly Lie About Money, Family & Happiness
  • Advertising
  • Marketing
  • Media

WPP AUNZ Study: Aussies Found To Regularly Lie About Money, Family & Happiness

Australians regularly lie about money, family, finances, their job and happiness, new research shows. They also keep big secrets from their partners, family and friends a new study by WPP AUNZ had revealed. The study, called Secrets & Lies, Uncovering the Underbelly of Australia, analyses the difference between what Australians say and what they think […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Sydney Airport Lands Massive Advertising Partnership
  • Advertising

Sydney Airport Lands Massive Advertising Partnership

Sydney Airport has partnered with large-format outdoor innovators, Wideopen Platform, to unveil one of Australia’s largest advertising building wraps across the Western face of the T1 International multi-storey car park. Sydney Airport general manager of retail Glyn Williams said the new wrap spanning 1,957sqm delivers another significant media opportunity for advertisers at Australia’s gateway, beyond the existing portfolio. “We’re excited […]

Sunday TV Wrap: A Resurgent 60 Minutes Gives Nine A Big Win
  • Media

Sunday TV Wrap: A Resurgent 60 Minutes Gives Nine A Big Win

An emotional tell-all interview with NRL player Johnathan Thurston has delivered big numbers for Nine’s 60 Minutes last night. Thurston – who retired at the end of this season to become a Nine commentator – opened up about alleged rape allegations that have dogged his career way back when be played for Canterbury Bankstown in 2002. […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
APN Outdoor Brings The Invictus Games To XtrackTV
  • Campaigns
  • Media

APN Outdoor Brings The Invictus Games To XtrackTV

APN Outdoor, the official Outdoor Media Partner of the Invictus Games Sydney 2018, has revealed the next phase of its partnership with the Games, launching coverage through its XtrackTV national digital rail network. The industry-leading XtrackTV network operated by APN Outdoor is delivering content from the games in Sydney to rail commuters, direct from the official broadcast partner, […]

Japanese Cosmetic Firm Unveils Surreal Ad With Cool LGBTQI+ Twist
  • Campaigns

Japanese Cosmetic Firm Unveils Surreal Ad With Cool LGBTQI+ Twist

Japanese cosmetic firm Shiseido has unveiled its latest campaign that’s epic as it is stunning. The three-and-a-half minute spot is called “The Party Bus” and goes from the surreal to the bizarre all while highlighting the power of make-up. It follows a young Japanese girl who falls for what appears to be a samurai, before ending with a […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Engaging.io Appoints Blockchain Specialist To Lead Business Development
  • Media

Engaging.io Appoints Blockchain Specialist To Lead Business Development

Technology and digital agency Engaging.io has appointed Siva Gounder as senior business development manager as the independent agency continues to invest in technology. Gounder joins Engaging.io from CRDZ, a decentralised platform addressing issues preventing widespread adoption of blockchain and cryptocurrencies. For more than two years he was charged with developing blockchain partnerships and marketing. Prior to […]

Ten Pictures That Will Make You Feel Good About Living Down Under
  • Co-Lab
  • Media

Ten Pictures That Will Make You Feel Good About Living Down Under

The photo aficionados at Getty Images Sydney have curated some of their favourite images from the ‘This is Australia’ collection, capturing all that is great about our lifestyle Down Under. We could be every one of these people. The photo aficionados at Getty Images Sydney have curated some of their favourite images from the ‘This […]

Partner Content

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Study: Sydney FC Most Popular A-League Club, As Support For The Phoenix Plummets
  • Marketing

Study: Sydney FC Most Popular A-League Club, As Support For The Phoenix Plummets

A-League Premiers Sydney FC have topped the Roy Morgan A-League supporter ladder for 2018 with 613,000 supporters an increase of 11.7 per cent over a year ago following the clubs back-to-back wins as A-League Premiers in 2016/17 and 2017/18. Defending A-League grand final champions Melbourne Victory were second with 526,000 supporters, down 8.7 per cent on a […]