Do Fails Like #YourTaxis Hurt Twitter More Than Brands?

Melbourne, Australia - April 6th, 2012 : The Flinders station in the afternoon and the  traffic around it
SHARE
THIS



Carat social media manager, Alexander Southwick (pictured below), ponders the impact on the medium, as well as the brands behind some of this year’s biggest social media fails.

This month we had one of the more notable social media fails of 2015, the Victorian Taxi Association’s #YourTaxis campaign. Setup to allow the people of Melbourne to share their (ideally positive) Taxi stories on Twitter, the tag quickly spiraled out of control, with many users sharing their Taxi horror stories instead.

Alexander Southwick

Ultimately the campaign was deemed a failure, with the social agency responsible reportedly being taken off the account after an awkward and inappropriate follow up Tweet on Remembrance Day. Even so, I’m left wondering – were The Victorian Taxis Association and / or their social agency the real losers last week? Or was it Twitter?

PR disasters like the #YourTaxis fail aren’t all that uncommon on the platform, with brands like Qantas and McDonalds also recently facing the ire of users.

As marketers, there’s always a certain degree of risk associated with opening up your brand to the kind of two way customer conversation that social platforms like Twitter facilitate. You have to wonder just how far incidents such as the #YourTaxis fail go toward proving the old adage, ‘once bitten, twice shy’, from a client perspective.

Even if it’s not your client directly caught up in the mess, the halo effect of such a public humiliation is widely felt. The end result is that brands and clients retreat to the relatively security of more traditional platforms; ones where consumer’s voices and concerns aren’t necessarily so easily aired.

Surely this problem can’t just be limited to Twitter though; users on Facebook are just as capable of sharing complaints. Facebook, however, just doesn’t feel nearly as public.

Why?

Firstly, the format of Facebook encourages more direct communication – you write on a brand’s page, for example – rather than the general broadcast format of Twitter. This ‘broadcast’ element is facilitated largely by the enormous uptake of hashtags. Facebook also allows brands to exert more control over what is said about them through functionality such as ‘approved posts’, which gives a greater sense of security.

As an agency, it’s also a more difficult argument to make to remove Facebook from the channel mix with their reach sitting at around the 14m mark in Australia, versus Twitter’s 3m.

The fact is, Twitter still has a little of the ‘Wild West’ about it for brands. With this is mind, when it comes to selecting one platform over the other, the client and agencies tend to lean towards Facebook, as the perceived ‘safer’ option.

Despite these issues, I would still assert that Twitter has its place in any business. I think the role that it plays as a marketing platform, however, may change.

Perhaps it will evolve into the new customer service channel for brands, as opposed to a marketing one, allowing brands to transition negative feedback away from Facebook to a separate environment. It may also be that Twitter has to change the way that advertising functions on the platform, as ad products should be designed for advertisers and not for users to abuse, something that promoted trends and hashtags are currently susceptible to.

I’ve heard people say that these problems could’ve been avoided through better tag selection or proper risk mitigation strategies, however I think that this kind of thinking also limits the opportunities for brands on Twitter.

It’s worth noting that almost any tag or ad can be misconstrued in such a way that it causes brand headaches. Take Susan Boyle’s album launch in 2012 for example. I refuse to believe that the hashtag #susanalbumparty made it through PR, Creative, Media and the Twitter teams without someone at least raising an eyebrow.

In 2015, where everything is abbreviated, turned to emoji, or #tagged, brands and individuals need to be conscious of what they’re creating. When brands get it wrong with these tags or ideas, the platform ends up suffering as much as they do, making it harder for all of us in the long run to get exciting and engaging social campaigns off the ground and onto the plan.

Latest News

Media Execs Weigh In On TV Upfront Season: Starcom Australia CEO Toby Barbour
  • Media

Media Execs Weigh In On TV Upfront Season: Starcom Australia CEO Toby Barbour

The upfront season may have wrapped up, however, media execs in adland are still wrapping their heads around the plethora of new content and programming. With each network promising jam-packed slates for 2019, B&T wanted to find out what media agency executives made of the upfronts, those who the networks are essentially pitching to. So, […]

Chris Bath To Join Network 10 As National Weekend News Anchor
  • Media

Chris Bath To Join Network 10 As National Weekend News Anchor

Network 10 has announced the appointment of Chris Bath as its national weekend news presenter for 10 News First. Bath is one of Australia’s most respected news and current affairs presenters and seasoned journalists. Her career includes 20 years at the Seven Network, where she presented Seven News and hosted Sunday Night from its launch, […]

DDB Sydney & Volkswagen Release Censored Version Of ‘Too Powerful For TV’ Ad
  • Advertising
  • Campaigns

DDB Sydney & Volkswagen Release Censored Version Of ‘Too Powerful For TV’ Ad

During the weekend of the Bathurst 1000 in October, Volkswagen Commercial Vehicles premiered its ‘Too Powerful For TV’ campaign for the new Amarok V6 Ultimate 580. However, Ad Standards found the commercial to be “unsafe” for showing reckless driving that would breach road rules, and it was subsequently discontinued. Volkswagen and DDB Sydney have since […]

The Dangers Of An Outside-In Approach To Improving A Business
  • Opinion

The Dangers Of An Outside-In Approach To Improving A Business

Peter Shields (pictured below) is expert at assisting individual and collective leadership and author of Leadership Alchemy – a book about transforming business value from the inside out. In this guest post for B&T, Shields takes a look at the “outside-in” approach to assessing any business and the dangers it brings… According to a 2016 report by Consultancy […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
DrinkWise & Clems Melbourne Launch ‘The Internet Remembers’ For Xmas Partying
  • Campaigns

DrinkWise & Clems Melbourne Launch ‘The Internet Remembers’ For Xmas Partying

DrinkWise and Clemenger BBDO Melbourne have launched a campaign for the responsible drinking organization titled ‘The Internet Remembers’. Launched to coincide with the Christmas party season, the campaign has been developed to encourage young Australian drinkers to adopt a responsible attitude to alcohol by reminding them that The Internet Remembers what happens when they’re drunk. […]

QMS NZ Finalises MediaWorks Merger
  • Media

QMS NZ Finalises MediaWorks Merger

QMS Media Limited has finalised terms for the merger of its New Zealand out-of-home, digital media and production business (QMS NZ) with MediaWorks, New Zealand’s leading independent radio, TV and digital business. The merger on completion will establish the newly combined QMS and MediaWorks as the largest multi-media advertising group in the country. In late […]

Suncorp Chooses Leo Burnett Sydney To Handle Creative For APIA
  • Advertising

Suncorp Chooses Leo Burnett Sydney To Handle Creative For APIA

Financial services group Suncorp has announced the appointment of Leo Burnett Sydney as the new creative agency for over-50s insurance brand APIA. Leo Burnett replaces DDB Melbourne on the account, with the latter left off Suncorp’s creative agency roster following a review earlier this year. Suncorp recently implemented a masterbrand strategy which brings together the […]

Headspace Australia Launches Instagram Campaign For Year 12 Students
  • Media

Headspace Australia Launches Instagram Campaign For Year 12 Students

Australian celebrities and creators are sharing their support for Year 12 students this week, in a new initiative from Instagram and headspace Australia. Launched today ahead of end-of-school exam results, #GramFam Australia features messages from ARIA winner Amy Shark, TV presenters including Lisa Wilkinson and Sandra Sully, comedian Peter Helliar, Home & Away star Olivia […]

oOh!media & Adshel Combined Business Reaches 90% Of Aussie Audiences
  • Media

oOh!media & Adshel Combined Business Reaches 90% Of Aussie Audiences

oOh!media’s audience reach has extended to well above 90 per cent of the Australian population with the integration of Adshel’s assets into the business, according to analysis of audience data. The audience reach data was announced as oOh! rebrands the Adshel assets to Commute by oOh!. Audience data from MOVE shows oOh!’s reach is unmatched […]

iHeartRadio & Surf Life Saving NSW Revive ‘Surf Life Sounds’ For Summer
  • Media

iHeartRadio & Surf Life Saving NSW Revive ‘Surf Life Sounds’ For Summer

The Australian Radio Network’s iHeartRadio Australia has teamed up with Surf Life Saving NSW (SLS NSW) for another year of ‘Surf Life Sounds’. The digital radio station features a mix of this summer’s hits, providing the official soundtrack to a safe summer at the beach while celebrating Australian beach culture. The Surf Life Sounds name […]

Sky News Bolsters Editorial Team With Two New Hires
  • Media

Sky News Bolsters Editorial Team With Two New Hires

Sky News today announced further expansion and investment in its editorial leadership team with the appointment of two new roles across its newsroom operations. Experienced television news director, Chris Willis has been appointed to the newly created leadership position of executive editor of news and talk. In this senior editorial role, Willis will have overall responsibility […]

Remarkable Marketers: Meet Airtasker’s Alexandra Aguirre Tully
  • Marketing
  • Partner Content

Remarkable Marketers: Meet Airtasker’s Alexandra Aguirre Tully

There are some pretty remarkable people in our industry, each offering their own unique perspective to adland. While we spend so much time learning about our peers’ career highlights, B&T thought it high time to dig a little deeper, and find out what makes the shining stars of our industry tick and, at times, tock. So, we’ve recently […]

Partner Content

by Carat

Vince Usher Wins Top Dog Award At Miami Ad School Account Planning Boot Camp
  • Advertising

Vince Usher Wins Top Dog Award At Miami Ad School Account Planning Boot Camp

Ikon Communications strategist and account planner Vince Usher has been named Top Dog at Miami Ad School’s 2018 Account Planning course. Usher, who worked in teams throughout the course, also won three ‘Best Campaign’ awards for his work on live briefs by craft beer client 4 Pines, Tourism Australia and Ford. His team partner on […]

Drummond Golf Unveils ‘For The Love Of Golf’ Via JWT Melbourne
  • Advertising
  • Campaigns

Drummond Golf Unveils ‘For The Love Of Golf’ Via JWT Melbourne

Drummond Golf has launched its first brand campaign via J. Walter Thompson Melbourne.  The campaign speaks to golf lovers of all ages and skill levels about the benefits and frustrations of the game. Reinforcing that no-one understands and loves the game quite like Drummond Golf. Drummond Golf marketing director Ravi Abeyaratne said: “Our business and franchisees were […]

“Every Brand Does Need A Podcast Strategy”: Mamamia Creative Chief Mia Freedman
  • Marketing
  • Media

“Every Brand Does Need A Podcast Strategy”: Mamamia Creative Chief Mia Freedman

Brands have been advised to sharpen their plans for podcasts in the media mix, as audiences and creativity continue to explode in Australia and abroad. Speaking at Mamamia’s Podcasts Unplugged event in Sydney last Wednesday, chief creative officer Mia Freedman said not every brand needs a podcast, “but every brand does need a podcast strategy”. “We’ve […]

Clems Sydney Unveils Festive Spot For HP
  • Campaigns

Clems Sydney Unveils Festive Spot For HP

Get set to get all festivey with this fun Christmas spot. Or, alternatively, get drunk on eggnog. We don't mind.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine