2DayFM: ACMA least of SCA's worries as lawyers say DJs may have broken laws

2DayFM: ACMA least of SCA's worries as lawyers say DJs may have broken laws
SHARE
THIS



Southern Cross Austereo and its station 2Day FM may have committed a criminal offence by recording nurse Jacintha Saldanha without her consent and broadcasting the prank, media lawyers said.

Justine Munsie of law firm Addisons told B&T that the DJs behind the prank, Mel Greig and Michael Christian, may have breached the NSW Surveillance Devices Act and NSW Listening Devices Act.

“There seem to be two issues one is the potential breach of the NSW Surveillance Devices Act which makes it illegal to record telephone conversations without consent,” Munsie said.

“The criminal offence is whether they should have been recording a telephone conversation with a person without their consent in the first place.

“It’s an issue that if the other person is overseas it is not all in Australia but the relevant recording is being done in NSW so that could be problematic.”

This comes after Rhys Holleran, SCA’s chief executive, said the company was “confident” it had not done anything illegal and London’s Metropolitan police contacted NSW Police yesterday.

The issue under debate is the prank phone call 2DayFM’s DJs made to the King Edward VII hospital in London last week in which they impersonated the Queen and tricked a nurse into sharing details about the Duchess of Cambridge’s health.

Saldanha, who transferred the call through to the hospital ward, later apparently committed suicide.

Asked whether she thought it was likely criminal proceedings would be brought against the station or the DJs, Munsie said it was a “possibility” as media organizations have been prosecuted for similar acts in the past.

But she said the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) would take in to account the fact that SCA sought legal advice before broadcasting the pre-recorded call.

“Because the DPP would be thinking ‘well what is the point in securing the conviction if on sentencing no judge in the world is going to punish these people if they got legal advice and acted in according with that legal advice.

“The criminal justice system only has so many resources but it is a possibility.”

The second issue at play, according to Munsie, is whether the station breached the Australian Communications and Media Authority’s (ACMA) Commercial Radio Codes of Practice.

 The sticking point for Munsie and Hamish Fraser, a partner at Truman Hoyle Lawyers, is the media authority’s sixth code of practice.

Code 6.1 states: “A licensee must not broadcast the words of an identifiable person unless:

a)      That person has been informed in advance or a reasonable person would be aware that the words may be broadcast; or

b)      In the case of the words which have been recorded without the knowledge of the person, that person has subsequently, but prior to the broadcast, expressed consent to the broadcast of the words.”

Holleran, SCA’s CEO, reportedly said the station attempted to contact London’s King Edward VII Hospital which was treating the pregnant Duchess of Cambridge multiple times before broadcast.

Munsie highlighted the Code’s use of the word “identifiable” as “tricky” as at the time of original broadcast Saldanha may not have been able to be identified but was later identified through the subsequent coverage.

“I could see the ACMA saying ‘well you didn’t give her name, however, you did broadcast the fact that she was a nurse on duty at the Prince Edwards VII Hospital and you broadcast her voice’.

“Now those two facts made her identifiable at least to people who knew her and they might even say it was reasonably foreseeable in the age of the internet that this would be further circulated.”

However, Fraser told B&T that it is not automatically a breach of the code just because the station failed to comply.

There are four exclusions in 7.1 which mean it wouldn’t be a breach if SCA had either reasonable grounds to believe it wouldn’t be a breach, it was a reasonable mistake, reliance on information supplied by other people and an act or default of another person.

 “6.1B appears to have been breached but you have to read that in conjunction with 7.1 which says that a failure to comply with the code…is not a breach if it is due to, in this case, either reasonable grounds to believe it didn’t breach or a reasonable mistake,” Fraser said.

Either way, Fraser believes an investigation is “almost inevitable” given the furor surrounding the case.

“It will trigger an investigation by the ACMA. If the investigation finds there has been a breach then there will be consequences.”

A likely consequence could be the imposition of another licence condition. Earlier this year, SCA was slapped with a second licence condition following shock jock Kyle Sandilands’ on-air outburst about a female journalist.

“They are not going to lose their licence immediately over it but there are a whole lot of things that could be put in place as result,” Munsie added.

Meanwhile, ACMA is reportedly considering circumventing its complaints procedure, which allows broadcasters to respond to complaints first, and instead kick off its own investigation into the issue. 

For more on this story see:

-2DayFM: Scandal could make media more conservative.

-2DayFM: PR experts urge SCA to bring presenters out of hiding.

Please login with linkedin to comment

Latest News

P2P Transport Limited Becomes Australia’s Largest Taxi Advertising Network
  • Media

P2P Transport Limited Becomes Australia’s Largest Taxi Advertising Network

The acquisition of Nonstop Media by ASX-listed P2P Transport Limited will create Australia’s largest taxi advertising network. Adflow, P2P Transport’s advertising division, will take control of all acquired media assets to complement its growing fleet of digital rooftop signage, vehicle wraps and in-vehicle entertainment products across Australia. The acquisition grows Adflow’s footprint substantially by adding […]

Nine Reveals New Sales Team Structure Post-Fairfax Merger
  • Advertising
  • Marketing
  • Media

Nine Reveals New Sales Team Structure Post-Fairfax Merger

Media giant Nine has moved to align its newly combined sales structure with Fairfax following the merger. Under the new integrated sales structure, Nine will co-locate all of the 500-plus sales staff from Nine and Fairfax into its Nine sales offices in Sydney, Melbourne, Brisbane, Adelaide and Perth. This process is expected to be completed […]

Fearless Girl Plants Her Feet In Front Of Iconic New York Building
  • Media

Fearless Girl Plants Her Feet In Front Of Iconic New York Building

The world-famous Fearless Girl statue has taken a walk through New York City and found herself plonked in front of the city’s Stock Exchange. Fearless Girl was unveiled in March of last year and was made by artist Kristen Visbal and was funded by McCann’s client State Street Global Advisors (SSGA). Since she arrived on Wall Street, staring […]

Network 10 Forced To Rebrand ‘10 Boss’ To ‘10 Bold’ Following Fairfax Court Action
  • Marketing
  • Media

Network 10 Forced To Rebrand ‘10 Boss’ To ‘10 Bold’ Following Fairfax Court Action

The rebrand of Network 10’s channels is finally complete, after Fairfax Media (now Nine) kicked up a stink about the similarity of the ‘10 Boss’ channel to one of its own brands. Last month, Fairfax sought a temporary injunction against 10 to stop the TV network from using ‘Boss’ in the name and logo of […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
J.Walter Thompson Melbourne Named Baby Bunting’s Lead Creative Agency
  • Advertising

J.Walter Thompson Melbourne Named Baby Bunting’s Lead Creative Agency

Following a competitive pitch process, baby goods retailer Baby Bunting has appointed J. Walter Thompson Melbourne and its in-house creative partners from Girl, to be its lead creative agency. J. Walter Thompson Melbourne managing director Michael Godwin said: “While it’s so tempting to frame this news as us being entrusted with a new bundle of […]

Isobar & Foot Locker Invite Customers To Custom Design Nike Tuned Air Max Plus
  • Campaigns
  • Media

Isobar & Foot Locker Invite Customers To Custom Design Nike Tuned Air Max Plus

Isobar Australia has partnered with Foot Locker Asia Pacific to celebrate the 20th-anniversary drop of the Nike Air Max Plus. Better known as the ‘TN’ or ‘Tuned’, The Nike Air Max Plus remains one of the boldest, most polarising sneakers Nike has ever released, inspiring a cult following to this day. To hype the 20th […]

The Chaser Crew Score Sydney Brekkie Radio Gig On Triple M
  • Media

The Chaser Crew Score Sydney Brekkie Radio Gig On Triple M

After hosting the 3pm to 4pm timeslot on Triple M Sydney this year, the Radio Chaser team have been chosen to handle the coveted breakfast slot in the lead-up to Christmas. Commencing their brekkie duties yesterday, Craig Reucassel, Chris Taylor, Charles Firth, Dom Knight and Andrew Hansen (pictured above) have taken over from The Grill […]

BMW Teams Up With The Story Lab To Showcase BMW Genius
  • Campaigns
  • Technology

BMW Teams Up With The Story Lab To Showcase BMW Genius

The Story Lab has created a new series of content to showcase the BMW Genius program and engage customers with vehicle features and technology. The content features real BMW Geniuses – the dedicated experts who set BMW dealerships apart from other luxury car brands by guiding customers through every aspect of the vehicle. View the […]

UNSW Partners With Adobe To Transform Its Digital Ecosystem
  • Marketing
  • Technology

UNSW Partners With Adobe To Transform Its Digital Ecosystem

Computer software giant Adobe has announced a partnership with UNSW Sydney that will see Adobe Experience Cloud implemented across the university’s global digital ecosystem. The partnership with Adobe is part of a five-year overhaul of UNSW’s digital ecosystem designed to boost its reputation as a top 50 global university through improved integrated marketing capabilities and […]

Done & Dusted! 90% Of Aussies Say They’ve Finished The Christmas Shopping
  • Marketing

Done & Dusted! 90% Of Aussies Say They’ve Finished The Christmas Shopping

New research has revealed that nine in 10 Aussies have already done their Christmas shopping, with just 11 per cent leaving their shopping to December and only four per cent leaving it to the week before Christmas. The findings come from a survey of1021 Australians[ commissioned by parcel delivery service CouriersPlease (CP). In the survey, CP […]

Seven-Year-Old Tops YouTube’s Top 10 Earner List For 2018
  • Marketing
  • Technology

Seven-Year-Old Tops YouTube’s Top 10 Earner List For 2018

The top 10 YouTube earners for 2018 have been revealed with (get ready to feel really depressed) a seven-year-old who reviews toys online coming in at the number one spot. According to the list compiled by Forbes, Ryan, who’s site is called Ryan ToysReview, pulled in a staggering $22 million ($A30.6 million) from reviewing toys […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Report: Aussie Consumers Want Brands To Stand Up For Local Causes
  • Marketing

Report: Aussie Consumers Want Brands To Stand Up For Local Causes

A new study has found that three-quarters of Australians want brands to get more involved with the issues they care about. This is the insight from Purpose in Asia, a new report from Kantar revealing a disconnect between the causes that dominate global media and international brand campaigns, and issues that matter to consumers across the region. […]

New Idea Goes Royals Crazy With Mini Mag Devoted To Her Maj & Family
  • Media

New Idea Goes Royals Crazy With Mini Mag Devoted To Her Maj & Family

Pacific’s New Idea has launched New Idea Royals, a mini magazine driven by unprecedented interest in all things royal that completes the brand’s multiplatform approach to royal coverage.   Inserted into the weekly edition of New Idea, the mini magazine joins the New Idea Royals podcast, an online dedicated royal vertical and the rapidly-growing Facebook page, […]

How To Present In A World Of Growing Technology & Jargon
  • Opinion
  • Technology

How To Present In A World Of Growing Technology & Jargon

Emma Bannister (pictured below) is the founder and CEO of Presentation Studio, APAC’s largest presentation communication agency, and author of the book Visual Thinking: How to transform the way you think, communicate and influence with presentations. In her latest post for B&T, Bannister shares her tips on how to make your next presentation tech savvy without boring […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Eliza O’Hare Named Editor Of Bauer’s Inside Out Magazine
  • Media

Eliza O’Hare Named Editor Of Bauer’s Inside Out Magazine

Bauer Media has announced the appointment of Eliza O’Hare as editor of Inside Out magazine. O’Hare joins Inside Out from Bauer Media’s Harper’s BAZAAR, where she was associate editor for three years. O’Hare has nearly 30 years’ experience in the media and publishing industry, having started her career as a cadet at ACP magazines before working […]

Infographic: Where Aussies Plan To Shop This Christmas (And It’s Bad News For David Jones)
  • Marketing

Infographic: Where Aussies Plan To Shop This Christmas (And It’s Bad News For David Jones)

A study into the Christmas shopping habits of Aussies has again found that we’re eschewing the big chain retailers and increasingly going online to buy the presents. The research, by Melbourne market research and insights agency Honeycomb, found that 60 per cent of us will do all our shopping digitally this year. When it comes to the […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Aussie Pooch Mobile Embracing Localised Approach To Its Online Presence
  • Advertising
  • Marketing

Aussie Pooch Mobile Embracing Localised Approach To Its Online Presence

Aussie Pooch Mobile recently took out the number one spot in the Marketing category of this year’s Topfranchise Awards organised by 10 Thousand Feet Research and online marketplace SEEK Business. B&T sat down with Aussie Pooch Mobile’s marketing manager, Tracy Sullivan, to chat about the strategy behind their success. Why have you focused on online […]

B&T’s Research Agency Of The Year, Nature, Unveils Sydney Move
  • Marketing
  • Media

B&T’s Research Agency Of The Year, Nature, Unveils Sydney Move

Independent research consultancy, Nature, has announced an interstate expansion with the establishment of a Sydney office in the New Year. The announcement comes off the back of the business being recognised as Research Agency of the Year at the B&T Awards in November. According to Nature’s founder and managing director, Chris Crook, the move is a natural […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Paper Moose & Skillsroad Tackle Youth Unemployment
  • Campaigns
  • Technology

Paper Moose & Skillsroad Tackle Youth Unemployment

The NSW Business Chamber’s Skillsroad initiative has teamed up with independent makers agency Paper Moose to create an immersive, multi-touchpoint virtual reality experience. The initiative is an  effort to raise young Australians’ awareness of apprenticeships and traineeships for various careers. The digital experience, funded by the NSW Government Department of Industry, brings viewers into the […]