Instagram Worse For Body Image Than Billboard Ads: Study

Instagram Worse For Body Image Than Billboard Ads: Study

This story was originally published by

As it turns out, those giant billboard ads with gorgeous models aren't nearly as bad for our self esteem as social media. The Conversation explores.

SHARE
THIS



In this piece from The Conversation, Jasmine Fardouly, Macquarie University; Lenny R. Vartanian, UNSW Australia, and Rebecca T. Pinkus, University of Sydney, look at the comparison of billboard ads and social media in relation to body image.

Many modern celebrities are known for being excessive sharers on social media. For instance, the Kardashians are notorious for posting daily glamorous and often lingerie clad images on Instagram that attract several million likes.

But it’s not just images of attractive celebrities that flood social media. Friends, acquaintances and strangers post images of themselves too, often editing them to disguise face blemishes, make cheeks rosier or to make their nose look smaller.

When people look at these attractive images on social media, research shows they often compare their own appearance to those images and think they’re less attractive than the images they see.

We know these comparisons can make women unhappy with their appearance and put them in a bad mood. Given body dissatisfaction is an important predictor for eating disorders, we need to know if some types of comparisons are worse for people’s body image than others.

Most research on appearance comparisons has focused on people comparing their own bodies to models in magazines, on billboards or on television.

But our recent research found women rarely compare their appearance to others’ in magazines or on billboards, and only sometimes compare their appearance to others’ on TV. We found social media comparisons better reflect the types of comparisons young women make every day.

In our study, 150 female undergraduate students answered online surveys five times a day for five days. For each survey, they reported if they had compared their appearance with someone else’s, and whether they made that comparison after looking at social media, traditional media or in person.

They also reported whether they thought the person looked better, the same or worse than them. They then rated their body image, mood and thoughts of dieting and exercising.

Social media is the key

Women mostly thought others looked better than them on social media. This is likely due to women selectively posting the most attractive images of themselves on social media and enhancing those images to look like images in magazines, which are routinely edited.

Comparisons made between their own appearance and attractive others on social media were particularly harmful for women in our study.

Women reported being in the worst mood after social media comparisons relative to other comparisons. When women made social media comparisons, they also reported being unhappier with their appearance and more motivated to start unhealthy weight-loss activities, like going on a diet, than when they made comparisons in person.

These findings are consistent with other research linking social media appearance comparisons or envy with depression and body dissatisfaction. Our findings also add to research that suggests certain activities such as comparisons on social media may be harmful to women’s body image and mood, rather than just overall use.

What don’t we know?

Because we only measured the immediate impact of appearance comparisons, we do not know how long these effects last. One comparison is unlikely to have long lasting effects but chronically comparing your appearance may well have negative outcomes. One study found women who make more appearance comparisons to others in general are more vulnerable to the effects of social media on body image.

Although we only tested young women in our study, research suggests there may be similar patterns for men and people of different ages.

And the effects might be different depending on the social media platform, as some are more image-based than others. Those that rely on images, like Instagram and Snapchat, provide people with more opportunities to make appearance comparisons and may be more harmful to women’s body image and mood.

How to reduce the impact?

We need to find ways to reduce the impact of social media comparisons. People could detox from social media if they notice it is making them feel badly about themselves or their body. However, to do this, people need to be aware of the impact social media has on them.

People could unfollow or avoid people who post highly edited, idealised images of themselves, like the Kardashians. This may reduce how often people think others look more attractive than them on social media.

Unfollow people who doctor their images.
Screenshot Instagram

It may also be helpful to follow accounts that deconstruct these images, like comedian Celeste Barber, or post realistic everyday images.

When browsing social media it may be helpful for people to stop and think about the motivation behind each post and question how realistic each image is. It is important to think critically about how edited or staged images or videos are on social media.

Although we are starting to understand the impact of how we use social media, there is still a lot we don’t know.

For example, we don’t know if comparisons to friends or celebrities have different impacts on women’s mood and body image. And we don’t know if some people are more negatively impacted by these comparisons than are others.

But we do know we need to find ways to reduce the number and impact of appearance comparisons we make on social media.

Authors: Jasmine Fardouly, Postdoctoral research fellow, Macquarie University; Lenny R. Vartanian, Associate professor, UNSW Australia, and Rebecca T. Pinkus, Lecturer, University of Sydney. This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.

Latest News

SAP Acquires Experience Management Player Qualtrics In Multi-Billion Dollar Deal
  • Technology

SAP Acquires Experience Management Player Qualtrics In Multi-Billion Dollar Deal

Enterprise software giant SAP has has entered into a definitive agreement to acquire experience management software provider Qualtrics. Under the terms of the agreement, SAP will acquire all outstanding shares of Qualtrics for US$8 billion in cash. The purchase price includes unvested employee incentive compensation and cash on the balance sheet at close. Subject to […]

Why You Should Invest In A Healthy Team
  • Opinion

Why You Should Invest In A Healthy Team

Dr Ron Ehrlich (pictured below) delivers keynotes and wellness workshops and is the author of A Life Less Stressed; the 5 Pillars Of Health & Wellness. In this guest post, the goodly Doctor says investing into employee health typically returns on the bottomline too… A business focused on the health of its team, is a business people […]

Tuesday TV Wrap: Bride & Prejudice Puts The Ring On Seven’s Ratings Finger
  • Media

Tuesday TV Wrap: Bride & Prejudice Puts The Ring On Seven’s Ratings Finger

A strong showing from Bride & Prejudice – the most watched entertainment show of last night – and the always strong news/Today Tonight has handed Seven a convincing Tuesday night win. Seven took off with 31.8 per cent of last night’s eyeballs, Nine had 25.6 per cent and the ABC and 10 tied for third with 17 […]

Staff Made Redundant By JWT Melbourne To Explore Other Opportunities Within WPP
  • Advertising

Staff Made Redundant By JWT Melbourne To Explore Other Opportunities Within WPP

J. Walter Thompson Melbourne has confirmed a small number of staff have left the agency following a review of client demand against its resources. In a statement to B&T, the WPP-owned creative agency said: “Client needs of the agency have evolved, and while in response we’ve made several new hires across CRM/CX, social, design and […]

Remarkable Marketers: Meet Adobe’s Clare Cahill
  • Marketing
  • Partner Content

Remarkable Marketers: Meet Adobe’s Clare Cahill

There are some pretty remarkable people in our industry, each offering their own unique perspective to adland. While we spend so much time learning about our peers’ career highlights, B&T thought it high-time to dig a little deeper, and find out what makes the shining stars of our industry tick and, at times, tock. So, for the […]

Partner Content

by Carat

Conceptual image with word Disloyalty being changed into Loyalty. With retro filter or instagram effect.
  • Marketing
  • Opinion

How To Stop Customers From Breaking Up With You

In this guest post, Fjord’s Bronywn van der Merwe (pictured below) identifies eight ways for brands to keep customers coming back for more. Once upon a time, winning over a customer’s loyalty was simple. You made the sale, you gave them perfectly adequate customer service, and customers stuck with you. The difficulty and uncertainty of […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
News.com.au Unveils New Homepage
  • Media

News.com.au Unveils New Homepage

Australia’s leading national news website news.com.au today unveiled a new homepage. As the gateway to Australia’s largest news website, the news.com.au homepage delivers 135 million page impressions per month. The redevelopment of the news.com.au homepage has been designed to evolve the brand into the next decade with plans to roll out continued updates across the […]

Study: Startup Mentality Defined By Culture More Than Age Or Size
  • Marketing
  • Media

Study: Startup Mentality Defined By Culture More Than Age Or Size

The lines between startups and corporates should no longer be defined by organisation size, but by the kind of culture they foster, a panel of top marketers have agreed. Some of Sydney’s top marketers – including Guzman y Gomez CMO Lara Thom, Outdoria CEO Nick Baker, Menulog’s head of marketing Tasman Page and Facebook ANZ’s […]

Cupcakes on a cake stand with sparklers
  • Media

The New Daily Turns Five

Online news site, The New Daily, the brainchild of industry super fund boss Garry Weaven and former Age and Herald Sun editor Bruce Guthrie, turns five this week. It boasts a monthly Google audience of more than two million and close to 500,000 daily subscribers. It’s impressive climb up the Nielsen news site rankings – from outside […]

Nielsen: Aussies Aged 50-Plus Spent Most Time Online With News
  • Media

Nielsen: Aussies Aged 50-Plus Spent Most Time Online With News

Nielsen Digital Content Ratings monthly-tagged data for October 2018 revealed that more than half (52 per cent) of the total time spent online consuming news-related content during October 2018 was by Australians aged 50 plus. Desktop was the device of choice for Australians accessing news stories online, contributing to close to half (49 per cent) […]

Haystac Shakes Up National Leadership Team
  • Marketing

Haystac Shakes Up National Leadership Team

Haystac, part of the BWM Dentsu Group, has announced three key changes to its national leadership team as the agency evolves to service the needs of major national and global brand clients. Haylie Marchant moves into a new national role as head of strategy at Haystac. Formerly the general manager of Haystac Brisbane, Marchant will drive Haystac’s new business […]