Why Gen Y Doesn’t Aways Get Gen Y

Why Gen Y Doesn’t Aways Get Gen Y
SHARE
THIS



B&T’s favourite marketers to the Millennials, Brian Mitchell PhD and Evan Mitchell (Love & Wine and howandy.net), are back with their latest column. This time around they argue that Millennials might think they’re changing the world but, in reality, there’s more a herd mentality at play…

“Know Thyself” has come a long way from the Temple of the Delphic Oracle in ancient Greece. The Matrix movies emblazoned this existential exhortation over the door of their own wise-cracking Oracle. And Sense8’s trans hacktivist Nomi wears it as a tattoo, an indelible reminder of self-judgement and self-knowledge.

Really knowing thyself, however, presents specific challenges to history’s most paradoxical generation – which is why Gen Y doesn’t always get Gen Y.

The generation who demanded autonomy, independence and self-determination at earlier and earlier ages, lives at home for longer and longer. Half claim “economic infertility” while the other half are having kids much earlier than Gen X did. Idealistic social justice warriors grapple with the image of # slacktivist selfie-obsessed narcissists. And the generation that obsessed over FOMO (fear of missing out) now despairs at FOGO (fear of going out).

Generational paradoxes are what make Gen Y so heterogeneous. The heterogeneity of a generation, however, does not equal heterogeneity of individual tastes. So much social media has become an echo chamber, rewarding conformist thinking within social cliques. It’s harder and harder for dissenting opinions and tastes – and the wider perspective that comes with them – to cut through. Voices of difference are crushed before they get to express themselves.

Social media has become a magic mirror in which Millennials see idealised images of themselves and their chosen peers. This becomes self-reinforcing, and therefore more self-constraining. The more time spent on social media, the more compelling the image becomes.

So Gen Y don’t get Gen Y because they’re inclined to see the entire generation as a homogenous macrocosm identical to their peer-circle microcosm.

This is especially so in the case of those Gen Y-ers who stand as both taste-makers and taste-interpreters of their generation – those who work in media and marketing. It’s increasingly remarked on that these gigs are more and more dominated by white hipster males. They see the world through a narrow and specific prism – inner-urban dwelling, bearded with retro-tats, café-culture by day and hole-in-the-wall bespoke-spirits-bars by night… It’s a legit sub-culture, sure. How dangerous, though, to have this singular mindset increasingly influential in defining Gen Y tastes and creating the messages aimed at mass-generational appeal.

No previous generation came of age believing they held the sum of all human knowledge, literally, in the palm of their hand. This generational certainty, however, has eliminated one of the great sources of perspective and enlightenment for earlier generations – happy accident. Compare the limitations of Pandora-listening to old-time radio channel-surfing. Compare discoveries made flipping through LPs in a record store with taste-reliance on the recommendations of like-minded peers. Archaic library card catalogues revealed new books and ideas in ways a Google key-word search won’t. Especially since over time such searches accentuate existing tastes.

We can’t ever, of course, go back to all that. But it’s useful to be mindful as much of what’s been lost as of what’s been gained.

Or maybe not, for Gen Y anyway. They’re happy to indulge themselves in the notion that the world is precisely how they and their friends see it. They don’t ever have to think how limited their individual tastes have become – paradoxically, by the very devices, apps and platforms that should have expanded those tastes beyond belief. They can afford to conclude that their entire generation is exactly as they are in every way.

They have that luxury.

For marketers who need to read this increasingly significant demographic, however – that’s a luxury they don’t have.

Latest News

Apostrophe Copywriters Is Landing In Amsterdam
  • Marketing

Apostrophe Copywriters Is Landing In Amsterdam

Apostrophe, Melbourne’s first copywriting collective, is launching a pop-up office in Amsterdam this September with Lauren Brumley, Apostrophe’s Head Strategist, at the helm. Since its inception in 2012, Apostrophe has continued its steady growth trajectory, expanding globally to accommodate clients in cities as diverse as Helsinki, NYC, Los Angeles, Kuwait and the Netherlands. In 2014 […]

NGEN Winners Create World-First Virtual Mentoring World For Deaf Teenagers
  • Media

NGEN Winners Create World-First Virtual Mentoring World For Deaf Teenagers

The winners of last year’s MFA Awards NGEN category have brought their unique idea to life and built a world-first virtual mentoring world for deaf teenagers inside Minecraft, called League of Hearoes. After months of testing, the world has launched weekly live events, attracting more than 50 deaf or hard of hearing (DOHH) teenagers.

Wednesday TV Wrap: The Block Sees Off The Bachelor (Just)
  • Media

Wednesday TV Wrap: The Block Sees Off The Bachelor (Just)

Nine’s The Block was the most watched entertainment show of Wednesday night, narrowly seeing to Ten’s The Bachelor by 881,000 to 854,000, respectively. Ten’s latest attempt at a homegrown drama, Playing For Keeps, debuted last night with a promising 583,000. The Block was enough to give Nine the biscuits, winning last night with 28 per cent audience […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Cummins&Partners Wins Media Account For Red Cross Blood Service
  • Advertising
  • Media

Cummins&Partners Wins Media Account For Red Cross Blood Service

The Australian Red Cross Blood Service (ARCBS) has appointed Cummins&Partners as its new media partner following an extensive competitive pitch review. The media remit has been added to creative services at Cummins&Partners, creating more of a full-service partnership with ARCBS. Samantha Bartlett, marketing director at ARCBS, said: “We are absolutely delighted to appoint Cummins&Partners as […]

Diesel Turns Online Hate Into Cool New Fashion Campaign Littered With Stars
  • Advertising
  • Campaigns

Diesel Turns Online Hate Into Cool New Fashion Campaign Littered With Stars

Italian youth fashion brand Diesel has unveiled its latest campaign that uses social media hate and turns it into a clever new campaign. The ad stars Nicki Minaj, Gucci Mane, Bella Thorne, Tommy Dorfman, Miles Heizer, Yovanna Ventura, Barbie Ferreira, Yoo Ah-In and Jonathan Bellini. Each celebrity chose some of the worst comments they’d received, and Diesel designed exclusive items for each […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Infographic: How Sponsoring An Event (Like Goat Yoga Or A Garlic Festival) Can Grow A Business
  • Marketing

Infographic: How Sponsoring An Event (Like Goat Yoga Or A Garlic Festival) Can Grow A Business

A common malady of marketers is how to best spend their marketing dollars and get the best outcomes (ie. sell more stuff). But a new study suggests that going “hyper-local” could be an easy and effective place to start. The study, by US marketing firm Zipsprout, says that micro-targeting local consumers via corporate sponsorships can be one of […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Clemenger BBDO’s ‘Exceptions To The Rule’ Recruitment Program Now Open
  • Advertising

Clemenger BBDO’s ‘Exceptions To The Rule’ Recruitment Program Now Open

The annual search for Australia’s best and brightest talent has launched today through Clemenger BBDO’s ‘Exceptions to the Rule’ program, with applications open for placements across Clemenger BBDO Melbourne and Sydney. ‘Exceptions to the Rule’ is a commitment to the agency’s belief that the future leaders of the creative industry aren’t solely coming through traditional […]