How Customer Empathy Is Damaging Your Brand

rgain
SHARE
THIS



Getting into the mind of the consumer is widely seen as an imperative for high performance brand marketing. But, says a ground breaking study from Imperial College London, by trying to empathise with consumers, marketers may in fact be doing themselves more harm than good.

Being able to ‘think like the customer’ is a highly vaunted skill amongst marketers, and conventional marketing wisdom – in both academia and commercial practice – is that developing empathy for the consumer and being able to put oneself in their shoes is essential to developing and marketing consumer goods and services.

This conventional wisdom is also ingrained in the corporate psyche at the highest levels: a 2012 PWC study of over 1200 CEOs across 60 countries found that two thirds of business leaders believed that incorporating the ‘voice of the customer’ in management decision making is critical to business performance.

But a recent study led by Prof. Johannes Hattula (pictured) from Imperial College of London has rather set the cat amongst the pigeons. In a set of four quantitative experiments, Prof. Hattula and his colleagues put forth a robust challenge to the idea that ‘think like the fish… be the fish…’ is the key to effective management decision making.

Some description

We know that conventional wisdom suggests higher empathy should mean more accurate predictions of consumer preferences. But does it? Although 76.7% of participants in Prof. Hattula’s study were convinced that putting themselves into the customer’s shoes would make them less susceptible to projecting their own preferences onto customer decisions, the research showed precisely the opposite.

Across a range of experiments in which managers were challenged to get into the mind of the consumer under various scenarios, Prof. Hattula and his colleagues found that, irrespective of whether they were discussing product features or celebrity endorsement, trying to empathise with the customer “activated managers’ own consumer identities and thus their personal consumption preferences”.

In other words, the more the study’s participants tried to get into the mind of the customer, the more their egos got in the way.

The cause of this, Hattula suggests, is deeply embedded in human psychology and our tendency to unconsciously take an egocentric view of the world. The human tendency towards situational or ‘role based’ identity also factors into this phenomenon.

So, whilst the managers in the study started the experiment in their ‘manager’ identity, as soon as they were asked to think like a consumer, their personal consumer identity was activated.  And because (lets be realistic), the average senior manager has little similarity to the ‘average consumer’ in most purchase categories, their projected consumer preferences showed a significant bias from the target market’s norm.

So, attempting to intuitively understand the customer has some distinct pitfalls – but businesses have the fall back of objective research, which should – given marketers’ articulated dependence on it – come into play to give a picture of ‘real’ consumers. Interestingly, the egocentrism generated by empathy has no bounds.  Not only did the participants in the study impose their preferences on the ‘consumer’, they also showed a tendency to ignore, discount or reframe any objective research they were provided that contradicted their own worldview. This mix of implicit bias and reframing of objective information can be very dangerous for brand positioning, taking brands down a path away from rather than towards their target market.

Whilst fascinating as an academic investigation in its own right (if you’re interested in such things, the full 55 page report is well worth a read), there are a couple of key take outs from this clever piece of research that can have immediate commercial benefit.

Firstly, the tendency to impose one’s own consumer identity when predicting consumer preferences is a naïve reaction that can be effectively overridden. This means, Hattula clarifies, that decision makers ‘can reap the benefits of empathising with consumers without generating self-referential predictions’ if they are reminded to avoid bias before attempting to predict consumer preferences. How to execute this in practice remains a topic requiring discussion; acquiring a new habit, after all, takes between 4 to 6 weeks of constant practice, something that may be hard to enforce in the average enterprise.

Assuming that intentionally ‘switching off’ bias could be a ‘hit or miss’ solution, an alternate way to translate the findings of this research into commercial value is by instituting a requirement for less emotive areas of the organisation to be involved in brand marketing, and encouraging the avoidance of unilateral decisions. Bringing in employees with strong analytical skills and a more quantitative/ less empathic approach may be extremely beneficial to ensure marketing’s decision making stays on track.

We have started to see this to some extent in more sophisticated players in the advertising sector, where data planners and quantitatively skilled planners are becoming more prevalent, but this is still something of a gap on the client side. One of the key signals this research conveys is that it is important for the intuitive executive to ‘buddy up’ with her more calculated counterparts in order to keep the ego out of empathic decision-making, and ensure any objective resources available are correctly taken into consideration.

This article originally appeared on www.which-50.com

Anna Russell is a director at Polynomial, a Sydney-based analytics and strategy consultancy. Polynomial works with businesses to drive value from technology investment and develop effective data driven strategies for marketing and customer engagement

 

Latest News

US Cult Brand Yeti Enlists Alley To Drive Australian Expansion
  • Marketing

US Cult Brand Yeti Enlists Alley To Drive Australian Expansion

American cult brand Yeti has its international expansion sights on Australia and has enlisted digital marketing agency Alley to make its mark. The Texas-based company has reinvited the luxury cooler and outdoor accessories market, and Yeti’s partnership with Alley has already begun. Clayton Anderson, content and marketing manager at Yeti Australia, said: “We have big […]

The Five Annoying Habits You Need To Break
  • Opinion

The Five Annoying Habits You Need To Break

Scott Stein (pictured below) is a leadership and productivity specialist and author of Leadership Hacks: Clever shortcuts to boost your impact and results. In this guest post, Stein looks at the bad habits we all need to ditch to get our lives motoring once again… Do you ever feel like there are not enough hours in the […]

Motivation & Commitment: Why The Two Are Not The Same
  • Opinion

Motivation & Commitment: Why The Two Are Not The Same

Lisa Stephenson (pictured below) is a global speaker, leadership consultant success coach and author of life strategy book Read Me First. In this guest post for B&T, Stephenson says understanding how motivation and commitment differ could be a good way to achieving your goals… Working as a success coach has shown me that motivation happens on the inside and for […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Thinkerbell Combine Cooking And Cabs In New Work For 13Cabs
  • Advertising

Thinkerbell Combine Cooking And Cabs In New Work For 13Cabs

A new TV series featuring celebrity cook, Anna Gare, and a team of real-life cabbies, hits the screens this week. The show, Anna Gare’s Cab Fare, follows the TV cook as she gathers stories and recipes from 13cabs’ diverse network of cab drivers – culminating in the creation of delicious dishes inspired by Australian drivers […]

Made In Katana Appoints Dylan Adams As Head Of Production
  • Advertising
  • Marketing
  • Media

Made In Katana Appoints Dylan Adams As Head Of Production

Australian-owned creative agency Made In Katana (MIK) has announced the appointment of Dylan Adams as head of production to support its growth in Asia. Adams is an ARIA award-nominated record producer, mix engineer, audio engineer and audio specialist. He joins MIK after a stint as head of music at post-production house Sound Reservoir. In his […]

Mamamia Media Group Appoints Howard Wilbury As Head Of Partnerships
  • Media

Mamamia Media Group Appoints Howard Wilbury As Head Of Partnerships

Mamamia has announced the appointment of Howard Wilbury to lead its premium partner division M+. Wilbury’s background spans both media owners and creative agencies, with stints at Channel [V], Westfield, DDB and M&C Saatchi. His most recent role was leading a full-service creative and production agency within the M&C Saatchi Group. Tony Prentice, chief revenue […]

Former Agency Boss Andrew Baxter Joins University Of Sydney’s Business School
  • Marketing

Former Agency Boss Andrew Baxter Joins University Of Sydney’s Business School

The University of Sydney Business School has announced the appointment of Andrew Baxter as an adjunct Professor of Marketing. Baxter is currently a senior adviser for KPMG’s entrepreneurial Customer, Brand and Marketing Advisory (CBMA), and previously headed agencies Ogilvy and Publicis here in Australia. In his new role, Baxter will work to establish a dialogue […]