Art versus science riles clashing creative directors

Art versus science riles clashing creative directors
SHARE
THIS



Tribal’s Darwin Tomlinson and Clemenger’s Paul Nagy locked horns last night over the role of science and technology in creativity at the most recent instalment of the Australian Planners Group Insight Series in Sydney last night.

Speaking on a panel of four under the topic of ‘Creative Directors on Unexpected Thinking From Planners’, the creative bosses of Tribal and Clemenger Sydney congenially argued over where creativity resides and who was responsible for it.

“Science is really the new creativity. It can be sometimes a bit of a hard pill to swallow for people with the word ‘creative’ in their title. But I really thought about that and I realised that a lot of the great ideas that I’ve ever been a part of making actually came from people who were technologists. Not creative people and frankly not planners . . . and I think that’s just the power of where an idea or an insight comes from,” said Tomlinson.

“If science is the new creativity and I think you can look at people like Malcolm Gladwell as a great example of that, people who are now influencing our culture are not necessarily the people with ‘creative’ in their title. I would put strategy into the bucket of science . . .

“My point is that it’s about collaboration and not to be afraid to break down the traditional structures of an agency. The places that still work along the model of a strategist providing an insight then the creative department taking it away and making something from it is an antiquated and fucked up model.”

Strategists shouldn’t be afraid to have ideas and equally and obviously technologists shouldn’t be afraid to have ideas, argued Tomlinson. To illustrate his point, Tomlinson pointed to the work of his new agency Tribal, which he didn’t work on, but said that while the insight for the campaign was questionable, the work was so strong that the weak insight didn’t matter. And this… However Clemenger Sydney’s executive creative director took exception to Tomlinson’s attribution of creativity to science. “I’ve got a real bug up my arse about this idea of technology and ideas and where the goal posts are there. Personally, I don’t think science is ever going to be a good idea in any way shape or form,” countered Nagy.

“Those ideas that Darwin showed are in my opinion are incredible ideas and blow me away kind of ideas . . . but they saw an idea behind the technology. It’s an idea. “There was a little while when judges across the world were giving awards to technology and technology alone, but I think that’s past and I hope we can get back to ideas.”

In other advice for the forty odd planners in the room Nagy reinforced that planners were part of the creative process and needed to come up with good ideas. “If you don’t come into work every day and think about doing something a little bit unexpected and something a little bit different, then you’re in the wrong industry. The flip side to unexpected thinking is expected thinking. We all know as humans that expected is fucking boring,” said Paul Nagy.

Nagy also said that collaboration cannot be forced. “Who’s responsible for collaboration? You can’t force it. Yes you should do what you can to make an environment to promote collaboration, but every good working relationship I’ve had has been based on chemistry. Chemistry drives collaboration . . . and culture eats strategy for breakfast.”

Image source: Shutterstock

Please login with linkedin to comment

Latest News

Western Australia Gets Its First Influencer Marketing Agency
  • Marketing

Western Australia Gets Its First Influencer Marketing Agency

Western Australia’s first dedicated social influencer marketing agency will launch next week to service the state’s new and rapidly growing digital industry. The Influencer Agency – TIA – brings strategy, accountability and measurement to influencer marketing for WA brands using WA influencers. TIA will also assist influencers wanting to grow their brand by developing new […]

One-on-one With Marie Claire Editor Nicky Briger
  • Media

One-on-one With Marie Claire Editor Nicky Briger

Following the launch of the revamped marieclaire.com.au, editor Nicky Briger spoke to Magazine Networks about all it can offer readers. In September, Pacific Magazines unveiled an all-new digital experience for Marie Claire. Led by design thinking, the new look marieclaire.com.au was crafted to provide a better reader experience across all devices. It’s a testament to […]

Women’s Health Unveils Its New Premium Digital Experience
  • Media

Women’s Health Unveils Its New Premium Digital Experience

Pac Mags’ Women’s Health has unveiled an all-new premium digital experience. With a faster, cleaner, more intuitive and visually consistent brand experience across all devices, the new look is designed to optimise the user’s journey with less clutter, discoverable content and seamless integration for commercial partners. Will Everitt, head of product and technology said: “The digital evolution of […]

Digital Agency Inlight Secures Two Key Client Wins
  • Marketing
  • Technology

Digital Agency Inlight Secures Two Key Client Wins

Independent agency Inlight has announced it has won the digital account for Benetas, a not-for-profit aged care provider in Victoria. Following a competitive pitch process, Inlight was chosen to handle Benetas’ new website design, build and ongoing optimisation. Richard Barker, marketing manager at Benetas, said: “We wanted an agency that could be our true digital […]

AMI Awards 2017 Winners Revealed!
  • Marketing

AMI Awards 2017 Winners Revealed!

With almost 30 awards handed out, B&T predicts plenty of numb bottoms at last night's AMI Awards in Melbourne.

Clems Sydney CEO Andy Pontin Quits
  • Advertising

Clems Sydney CEO Andy Pontin Quits

Sure, B&T flashed the news of Andy Pontin quitting this morning. White lies aside, he's actually still got six months.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Adobe MAXes Most Creatives In A Room Record
  • Advertising
  • Media

Adobe MAXes Most Creatives In A Room Record

B&T's journo is reporting live from the annual Adobe Summit in Vegas. Although, "reporting" is somewhat of a stretch.

Opinion

by David Hovenden

David Hovenden
Digital Women’s Network & The Australian College Of Marketing Unveil Latest Short Courses
  • Marketing

Digital Women’s Network & The Australian College Of Marketing Unveil Latest Short Courses

The Australian College of Marketing is collaborating with the Digital Women’s Network to bring new short courses aimed to provide the latest skills across all aspects of the Digital landscape, kicking off in Melbourne and Sydney in 2018. Course content will focus around various topics related to the digital marketing landscape. All courses will run […]

Man working at office desk, looking at computer and scratching head
  • Technology

Where Are Digital & Tech Skills & Salaries Headed?

The rapid pace of technological change in the digital sector is seeing demand for those with the right skill sets outstrip availability, both locally and globally. The individuals who have kept their skills up to date are being well-rewarded financially. Now, Digital + Technology Collective’s expanded annual Skills and Salary Survey will put some numbers and context […]

Disney & ESPN Unify Sales & Partnerships Teams
  • Advertising
  • Marketing
  • Media

Disney & ESPN Unify Sales & Partnerships Teams

Disney and ESPN have formed an even closer bond, announcing a new alignment of the two properties through their media sales and partnerships teams. Instead of entering through three doors, Disney ESPN Media Sales & Partnerships will give media buyers and marketers a refined, singular point of entry for Disney, ESPN Digital and Maker. Nik […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Sydney Start-up Muzaara Partners With Commission Factory To Turbocharge Digital Ad Spends
  • Advertising
  • Marketing

Sydney Start-up Muzaara Partners With Commission Factory To Turbocharge Digital Ad Spends

Sydney-based adtech start-up Muzaara has announced a new strategic partnership with performance marketing platform Commission Factory. Together, Muzaara and Commision Factory are providing SMEs with a secret weapon to skyrocket their online brand visibility and effectively manage and maximise their online advertising campaigns. This partnership will allow both online marketing companies and their impressive roster […]

Kellogg’s Creates AR Halloween Trick Or Treat Experience Via Shazam & Orchard
  • Campaigns
  • Marketing
  • Technology

Kellogg’s Creates AR Halloween Trick Or Treat Experience Via Shazam & Orchard

Breakfast cereal manufacturer Kellogg’s has joined forces with Shazam and digital agency Orchard to deliver a first-of-its-kind augmented reality (AR) Halloween Trick or Treat experience for families. The campaign, which leverages Shazam’s visual recognition platform and recently-launched AR platform, sees Kellogg’s pilot the replacement of physical gifts in cereal packs with a digital experience that […]

Kraft Heinz Appoints Cummins&Partners As New Creative Agency
  • Advertising

Kraft Heinz Appoints Cummins&Partners As New Creative Agency

Kraft Heinz today confirmed the appointment of Cummins&Partners as its new Creative agency after an extensive pitch process. They will be responsible for brand strategy and integrated creative across the expanding Kraft Heinz portfolio including Kraft, Heinz and Golden Circle. A Kraft Heinz spokesperson said: “After an exhaustive search involving a competitive pitch, we have made […]

Patrick Delany (CEO, Fox Sports), Hugh Marks (CEO, Nine Entertainment Co), Miranda Devine (Columnist, News Corp), Michael Miller (Executive Chairman, News Corp Australasia), Grant Blackley (CEO & Managing Director, Southern Cross Austereo) at Radio Alive 2017
  • Media

Media Bosses Weigh In On Ten-CBS Deal

Do you enjoy articles featuring industry big-wigs? Well, it doesn't come much bigger and wiggier than this, we say.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Kantar TNS’ Ali Dexter Joins T Garage As Director Of Insights & Strategy
  • Marketing

Kantar TNS’ Ali Dexter Joins T Garage As Director Of Insights & Strategy

Melbourne-based market research consulting agency T Garage has announced the appointment of Ali Dexter as its director of insights and strategy. Dexter joins T Garage from Kantar TNS, where she was the director of its Qualitative division. Prior to that, Dexter held a number of senior roles at Kantar TNS in the US and Vietnam.  “After […]

XXXX on Tuesday, March 21, 2017, in Las Vegas. (Jeff Bottari/AP Images for Adobe)
  • Advertising

Adobe Releases Advertising Cloud App

Not one, but two Adobe announcements. The tech elves have been busy this week, not that we're inferring Adobe is Santa.