Apple ‘startup’ claim unlikely to get off ground

Apple ‘startup’ claim unlikely to get off ground
SHARE
THIS



Apple will need to produce significant evidence of prior use to even come close to winning it’s trade mark application for the term ‘startup’, it has been claimed.

Apple’s application, lodged in Australia with the help of law firm Baker & McKenzie on Tuesday (27 August), will have to satisfy an examiner that it’s capable of distinguishing a range of Apple’s products and services.

“They’d want to have quite a bit of evidence up their sleeve because startup is such a common word, particularly in the technology space,” said Tim Hemingway, an IP and technology partner at Swaab Attorneys.

Apple is seeking to use the trade mark in relation to all retail store services, including computer hardware, software and other digital devices, as well as educational services like classes, workshops and seminars and computer diagnostics, often carried out through its in-store Genius Bar.

“Even if for the last three years the word startup has been plastered all over every Apple store in the country, and various uniforms and devices and the rest of it, well that’s one thing, but the public’s perception of that is another,” said Hemingway.

IP Australia’s trade mark examiner will consider the potential inconvenience caused should the trade mark application be successful; while it would not give Apple a total monopoly on the word startup, it would prevent others from using it to distinguish similar goods and services.

“The risk is getting into an argument about whether somebody’s use of the word startup is as a brand,” said Hemingway.

“It would be a tremendous waste of everyone’s time and resources if [people] had to sit back and think twice about whether to use the word startup in their marketing activities because it was Apple’s.”

Apple previously filed for trade marks over the word in the US and Australia in April 2011. The initial Australian filing was rejected, but Apple received a preliminary trade mark in the US, pending a consultation period. Numerous US parties filed objections and Apple reportedly has until mid September to respond to those objections. 

Parties can object on a number of criteria, including by showing ‘”concurrent or co-existent” use of the term startup.

“Even if Apple can show use and reputation in the term, equally, others may show they’ve used it for longer and in a similar way,” said Hemingway.

If Apple passes the examination phase in Australia, anyone can oppose the application within a two month period.

An IP bully?

Apple has not made its intentions clear, but it has been suggested the global corporation could be trying to use the phrase as a marketing tool to push out mobile operators and sell contracts to customers directly.

The official Apple website refers to its operating system turning on as Startup (with a capital letter) and late last year it was granted the US trade mark for its startup chime – the sound a Mac computer makes when switched on.

Apple has a reputation for trying to trade mark generic terms in an effort to marginalise competitors or extract licensing dollars from individuals and companies.

Last month it dropped its lawsuit against Amazon over the phrase ‘app store’ when success looked doubtful; earlier in August it lodged another trade mark application in Australia for the phrase ‘multi-touch’, covering various electronic devices.

“The branding is as important as the technology itself and products they sell,” said Hemingway.

Please login with linkedin to comment

Latest News

Made In Katana Appoints Dylan Adams As Head Of Production
  • Advertising
  • Marketing
  • Media

Made In Katana Appoints Dylan Adams As Head Of Production

Australian-owned creative agency Made In Katana (MIK) has announced the appointment of Dylan Adams as head of production to support its growth in Asia. Adams is an ARIA award-nominated record producer, mix engineer, audio engineer and audio specialist. He joins MIK after a stint as head of music at post-production house Sound Reservoir. In his […]

Mamamia Media Group Appoints Howard Wilbury As Head of Partnerships
  • Media

Mamamia Media Group Appoints Howard Wilbury As Head of Partnerships

Mamamia has announced the appointment of Howard Wilbury to lead its premium partner division M+. Tony Prentice, chief revenue and operations officer said: “Howard is the perfect fit for Mamamia, and matching our high value partners with access to our proprietary content, social, creative and marketing IP. With his unique mix of commercial and advertising […]

Former Agency Boss Andrew Baxter Joins University Of Sydney’s Business School
  • Marketing

Former Agency Boss Andrew Baxter Joins University Of Sydney’s Business School

The University of Sydney Business School has announced the appointment of Andrew Baxter as an adjunct Professor of Marketing. Baxter is currently a senior adviser for KPMG’s entrepreneurial Customer, Brand and Marketing Advisory (CBMA), and previously headed agencies Ogilvy and Publicis here in Australia. In his new role, Baxter will work to establish a dialogue […]