Oz brands just can’t buy love, study finds

Oz brands just can’t buy love, study finds
SHARE
THIS



Australia’s top advertisers are failing to build meaningful relationships with their customers, new research has found.

The study, carried out exclusively for B&T by innovation agency UDKU and research firm Stokes Mischewski, has revealed that despite continued major investment in advertising, some of Australia’s most iconic brands still have their work cut out in building sustainable relationships with consumers.

The research by Stokes Mischewski involved 2017 customers, 211 brands, 15 categories and 33 subcategories with over 22,000 responses evaluated.

As Colin Jowell, partner at UDKU, explains: “We wanted to create a tool to draw together two vital but different metrics for customer habits and attitudes into a single understanding.”

By doing this, the approach defined four relationship types: Advocates (customers with a strong usage habit and who recommend the brand highly), Habituals (customers with a strong usage habit but who are less likely to recommend it), Aspirants (customers with a weaker usage habit BUT who are likely to recommend it), and Switchers (where neither strong habits nor positive attitudes exist).

The research found that the top 20 advertisers in Australia are dominated by supermarkets, banks and telco’s, yet almost all brands in these categories fell into the switching or habit space.

"This result was not entirely unexpected,” said Dawn Mischewski, joint MD at Stokes Mischewski. “But where the data became interesting was that in almost every case, there was an exception to the category rule, or a segment for whom the relationship with the brand was quite different. It’s in these exceptions that the real insights lie. It gives clarity to the task at hand for marketers and examples of how others are succeeding.”

Failure to connect

So, does a telco have more in common with Apple or Energy Australia?

According to the study, when it comes to customer relationships, telco brands are more like a utility than a technology company.  Habits are relatively well-established in both utilities and telcos, but the proportion of customers willing to recommend them is relatively low.

“For telco brands to start enjoying the type of relationship that technology brands already enjoy with their customers, they need to create stronger emotional connections, but the data shows it might be more about the basics than the ‘wow’ factor,” said Mischewski.

“The evidence for this is that despite telcos’ efforts to align with the positive associations of technology brands and avoid becoming the “dumb pipe”, the only player measured to break out of the habit/switching space was Amaysim, whose offer of pure simple pricing has clearly been backed up by an equally simple on-boarding process.”

She added that another point of proof might be Optus’ relative strength in the sub-$50k pa. income market – given its historical dominance in prepaid, that would seem to make sense.

Buying deal, not loving deals

The telco example might lead some to believe it’s simply a matter of keen pricing, but that’s where the two dimensional view of the customer relationship is vital. For example, in the airline industry, it’s experience, not value, that drives a customer’s willingness to recommend an airline.

Singapore Airlines and Emirates drive the most positive attitudes. While the strength of habit using those brands may not be as strong due to more limited destinations within Australia, with a Singapore Airlines customer is 40% more likely to recommend their airline of choice than a Qantas customer. 

Conversely Tiger and Jetstar drive the least amount of recommendation – lower price is not enough of a compensation for people to actively recommend the brand.

Loyalty programs aren’t the answer to engagement either, or at least not in their current form. Qantas Frequent Flyer and Velocity both fall into the habit space with high usage, but low likelihood to recommend.

The answer lies in keeping one’s offer fresh and relevant, which is easier said than done,” said the study.

Virgin Australia Airlines has a relatively lower connection with its younger audience and is relatively weaker with female customers. Customers under 40 rate Virgin Australia and Jetstar similarly, both with far fewer customers prepared to recommend the brand.

Focus is the secret of success

The real success stories in customer relationship building can be seen in brands who have clearly segmented their market.

APIA’s single-minded focus on its demographic has delivered valuable and true advocates for the business that have been using the brand for as long as they have been able to, and have very high likelihood to recommend scores, especially with their newer customers.

Commonwealth Bank and Westpac both have notably stronger relationships with women, which may in part be credited to prominent and well executed “Women In Business” programs (and the fact the latter has one of Australia’s few high profile female CEO’s may also play a role).

That Nespresso’s strongest relationship is with its customers earning under $50k p.a. seems on the face of it, surprising, but could be evidence of one of the best text book cases of a “mass-tige” offer: something special, but not totally out of reach.

“At the end of the day, a marketing future that is more data-driven will require a multi-dimensional view of the customer. But for now, a two dimensional view may be a great place to start,” said Jowell.

Please login with linkedin to comment

Latest News

RXP Group Launches ‘Making Happier Humans’ To Simplify Digital Transformation
  • Campaigns
  • Media

RXP Group Launches ‘Making Happier Humans’ To Simplify Digital Transformation

ASX listed RXP Group today launched their new positioning ‘Making Happier Humans’ to reduce the increasing complexity faced by a growing number of businesses wanting to deliver effective and meaningful customer experiences. RXP Group CEO Ross Fielding said: “It’s critical that digital consultancies focus on the people aspect of technology-enabled solutions. “Making Happier Humans is our commitment […]

BikeExchange And Saatchi & Saatchi Launch First Global Brand Campaign
  • Campaigns
  • Media

BikeExchange And Saatchi & Saatchi Launch First Global Brand Campaign

The world’s largest online bike marketplace, BikeExchange, will launch their first global brand campaign today to unify the business across ten markets around the world. The new campaign – Where the world rides – is led by a new brand film and has been developed in partnership with award-winning creative agency Saatchi & Saatchi, Melbourne […]

Finecast Appoints Nicole Turley As Client Consultant
  • Media
  • Technology

Finecast Appoints Nicole Turley As Client Consultant

GroupM, the media investment group of WPP, has announced the appointment of Nicole Turley to the Finecast Australia team. Finecast is the Addressable TV business launched by GroupM in October 2018. Nicole has been the chief investment officer for MediaCom for the past five years, most recently holding the title chief investment and growth officer. Nicole has […]

Revealed: Influencer Marketing Is Ineffective For Brands’ Online Ranking
  • Media
  • Technology

Revealed: Influencer Marketing Is Ineffective For Brands’ Online Ranking

Influencer marketing has risen to the forefront in recent years, particularly when harnessed with live video trends on social channels. Where previously celebrity endorsements were potentially only available to companies with larger budgets, influencers with blogs or social media presences are now present anywhere on the budgeting scale, and are more specific to any given […]

New App Help Agencies Make and & Share Creative Briefs
  • Media
  • Technology

New App Help Agencies Make and & Share Creative Briefs

With only 27 per cent of agencies declaring that their clients provide clear assignment briefings, the new Volve application offers a compelling solution to create and share briefs. Ad campaigns are never smooth processes, where all those involved in making creative briefs agree on every detail. In fact, they can become nightmarish feats. Agencies, companies […]

Fiftyfive5 & GalKal Merge To Create Independent Consumer Insights Company
  • Media

Fiftyfive5 & GalKal Merge To Create Independent Consumer Insights Company

Independent research companies Fiftyfive5 and GalKal will merge to create Australia’s largest and fastest growing, independent, insights-led consulting business. The combined business will have offices in Sydney, Melbourne, Auckland and Singapore, a team of 115 and more than 130 clients across 40 countries serving multiple industries including financial services, telecommunications, FMCG, media and entertainment, social […]

Starcom Rallies Adland To Help Lion Dairy & Drinks Raise $1M For Drought Relief
  • Media

Starcom Rallies Adland To Help Lion Dairy & Drinks Raise $1M For Drought Relief

Starcom Melbourne has helped rally a number of media partners to pledge their support and donate airtime and space to help Lion Dairy & Drinks raise $1 million. The funds will help dairy farmers impacted by drought in NSW, South East Queensland and Northern Victoria. Lion Dairy & Drinks’ “Be True Blue Farmer Drought Fund” […]

BBC Studios Announces First Australian Commission With SBS
  • Media

BBC Studios Announces First Australian Commission With SBS

BBC Studios has announced its first commission since setting up a production arm in Australia, with SBS ordering 85 x 30 minute episodes of TV’s toughest and most enduring quiz show, Mastermind. Synonymous with the catchphrase “I’ve started so I’ll finish” and the fearsome, black, spotlighted chair for its contestants, the series was announced by SBS […]

Surf Life Saving QLD & Romeo Digital Launch World-First Beach Safety Tech ‘Life-Fi’
  • Campaigns
  • Technology

Surf Life Saving QLD & Romeo Digital Launch World-First Beach Safety Tech ‘Life-Fi’

Digital innovation Life-Fi is set to save lives this summer by breaking down the communication barriers between surf lifesavers and international tourists. The new technology provides access to unlimited free wi-fi between the flags and enables beachgoers of different nationalities to receive live surf patrol instructions in their own language, without requiring app download. Romeo […]