Is This The Worst Government Ad Ever?

Is This The Worst Government Ad Ever?
SHARE
THIS



The federal government has done itself no favours in trying to recruit graduates to work in the Department of Finance, releasing a new ad that is just plain hard to watch.

The video, titled ‘The Game Changers’, is designed to promote the Department of Finance’s graduate program, and features a number of real-life staff who interact awkwardly in some terribly-scripted scenes that would have NIDA graduates doubling over in pain.

Government tenders obtained by Fairfax show the ad cost $37,400 and was created by Together Creative, and agency that describes itself as “famously good” with the ability to develop “head-turning campaigns”.

Speaking to Fairfax, Campaign Edge creative director Dee Madigan described the ad as “truly terrible”.

“I always say real people are terrible at playing real people. No one will watch that to the end,” she said.

“It’s probably one of the worst recruitment videos I’ve ever seen.

“This idea that you have to show the target market to appeal to them is incorrect. Having people in situ having fake conversations has very little cut through. If you actually need real people in an ad, you cast actors.

“Any department that approved that ad, you just wouldn’t want to work for. They should be asking for their money back.”

Cummins & Partners’ Adam Ferrier said the ad was cringeworthy and “unfortunate” given the time and money that went into the campaign.

“This I’m pretty sure would make many people who work in finance cringe,” he told Fairfax.

“People need to realise that everything, everything communicates. From the length of the video, the low production values, the clichéd language – it all communicates.”

Latest News

Remarkable Marketers: Meet Velocity Frequent Flyer’s Dean Chadwick
  • Marketing
  • Partner Content

Remarkable Marketers: Meet Velocity Frequent Flyer’s Dean Chadwick

There are some pretty remarkable people in our industry, each offering their own unique perspective to adland. While we spend so much time learning about our peers’ career highlights, B&T thought it high time to dig a little deeper, and find out what makes the shining stars of our industry tick and, at times, tock. So, for […]

Partner Content

by Carat

BBC Studios Announces First Australian Commission With SBS
  • Media

BBC Studios Announces First Australian Commission With SBS

BBC Studios has announced its first commission since setting up a production arm in Australia, with SBS ordering 85 x 30 minute episodes of TV’s toughest and most enduring quiz show, Mastermind. Synonymous with the catchphrase “I’ve started so I’ll finish” and the fearsome, black, spotlighted chair for its contestants, the series was announced by SBS […]

Surf Life Saving QLD & Romeo Digital Launch World-First Beach Safety Tech ‘Life-Fi’
  • Campaigns
  • Technology

Surf Life Saving QLD & Romeo Digital Launch World-First Beach Safety Tech ‘Life-Fi’

Digital innovation Life-Fi is set to save lives this summer by breaking down the communication barriers between surf lifesavers and international tourists. The new technology provides access to unlimited free wi-fi between the flags and enables beachgoers of different nationalities to receive live surf patrol instructions in their own language, without requiring app download. Romeo […]

What Every Business Needs To Know About Influencer Marketing
  • Opinion
  • Technology

What Every Business Needs To Know About Influencer Marketing

In this guest post, Charles Tidswell, JAPAC vice president at Socialbakers, takes a look at influencer marketing and offers his panic-free tips on improving yours… In recent times, the reputation of influencer marketing has taken a few hits and its credibility has quickly diminished. With a few high profile and costly mistakes, including the Federal Health […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Zenith: 65% Of Digital Media To Be Programmatic In 2019
  • Technology

Zenith: 65% Of Digital Media To Be Programmatic In 2019

Sixty-five per cent of all money spent on advertising in digital media in 2019 will be traded programmatically, according to Zenith’s Programmatic Marketing Forecasts, published today. Advertisers will spend US$84bn programmatically next year, up from US$70bn this year, which represents 62 per cent of digital media expenditure. We predict that in 2020 advertisers will spend […]

Sugar Agency Wins Fairfax’s ‘Ads Are Better Rich’ Competition For 2018
  • Advertising
  • Media

Sugar Agency Wins Fairfax’s ‘Ads Are Better Rich’ Competition For 2018

Digital player Sugar Agency has been crowned the winner of this year’s ‘Ads Are Better Rich’ competition by Fairfax Media. Launched by Fairfax’s chief revenue officer, Matt Rowley, at the company’s 2018 Agency Symposium, the challenge aims to encourage agencies to push creative boundaries by using rich media formats to develop a campaign that promotes their agency. […]

Former APN Outdoor Sales Boss Launches OOH Consultancy
  • Advertising
  • Media

Former APN Outdoor Sales Boss Launches OOH Consultancy

An ex-sales director from APN Outdoor is trying his hand at consulting to advertisers looking to spend some coin in the out-of-home market. After 13 years at APN leading its national direct sales and then its NSW agency sales teams, Tim Rose resigned from the business in shortly before it had agreed to be sold […]