Reaction To Ritson Shows An Industry In Crisis: Robert Strohfeldt

Reaction To Ritson Shows An Industry In Crisis: Robert Strohfeldt
SHARE
THIS



If you have not seen, or at least heard about, Professor Mark Ritson’s presentation to the AANA then you must have been in a coma, says Strohfeldt Consulting founder and creative director, Robert Strohfeldt. But instead of joining the whingers, Strohfeldt says get off your high horses and help fix the situation.

The reactions have covered the spectrum from outraged self- righteousness to strong agreement, with the critics of Ritson receiving the most coverage.

And the questions he’s asking are not just being asked here in Australia.  The recent damming report in the US by the ANA on media transparency makes for interesting reading.

So what did he really say? Watch this:

No one can argue that Professor Ritson is not a highly entertaining and engrossing presenter. And his approach is anything but diplomatic.

But a closer inspection of the critics and their criticism, shows they are the ones with the most to lose from an evidence based assessment of social and online media effectiveness as advertising mediums.

The criticism of Ritson is a classic case of “shoot the messenger”. (Admittedly, a sarcastic one). You can read about the issues he addresses in not only industry, but more recently in the general business media, nearly every day.

Instead of acting offended and taking a “how dare you” approach, get off your high horses and do something to help fix the situation. I have been a part of this industry for over 30 years and never have I seen it so fragmented and suffering from such a lack of respect and trust.

Rather than work in the present, so much of the industry focus is on the future, trying to predict what the landscape will look like in five or 10 years. Development of strategies and executions for a hypothetical future, rather than the present, has been the result.

Google, Facebook and co. have been instrumental in creating and perpetuating the “tsunami of bullshit” that has washed over the industry.  They have seduced marketers with claims they are “the future of communications” using bullshit metrics to support their claims.  “Digital” is not confined to marketing and advertising.

Computers and the internet have dramatically changed the way we work and live. As a consequence, everyone wants “digital” – if you are not digital, you are a dinosaur. (The fact TV and radio are digital, print is read on tablets and outdoor signage is becoming predominately digital is over looked).

In addition, ad agencies have morphed into a series of mutually exclusive silos of “specialist services” staffed by people who want to be part of the future, which does not include “legacy media”.

The role of an ad agency has evolved since they first appeared. But if we want to maintain our relevance and standing in the business community, we should always provide advice (which can manifest in many ways, be it a media schedule, YouTube video, banner ad, a plain old TVC or a strategic plan) based on rigorously derived fact.

Let’s look at some of the key issues he raised:

  • Social media is “over rated” as a mass market medium

As he says, “it is social media”. It is about people, not brands. Brands, with all of their millions to spend on marketing and advertising, have only a fraction of followers that people do (be they music or sport stars, or just popular bloggers).

Yes, it does have its uses and a role to play in the mix. But that role is determined by the type of product or service for which it is being used; it is not a one size fits all.

Social media practitioners are blind to the realities of the limited commercial benefit of social media because don’t work on it; they live in it. Social media is a big part of their daily activity and as such find it difficult, if not impossible, to be objective about its efficacy. And of course, everyone is seduced by the huge numbers of social media users.

But there is a big difference between media viewing and advertising viewing.

Anthropomorphism has also become a major issue, with social media supporters treating brands as people. One of the major goals of his presentation was to get people to start asking questions about social media’s effectiveness as an advertising medium. And it is about time.

When two thirds of marketers are unsure of their ROI from social but intend to increase the spend, it is obvious that the right questions have not been asked.

  • He not only talks about a “tsunami of bullshit” in relation to online video, he clearly shows why

An online video view is any piece of video, with or without sound, that is seen for at least 3 seconds – conveniently the time that elapses before a person can skip an ad.  It is very funny, but obviously embarrassing to media people who have been promoting the “huge numbers” online video generates, versus TV.

That the industry has not picked up on this crazy metric and advised clients its meaning is useless and looked for a viable alternative that allow an “apples to apples” comparison to TV, is an indictment on the advertising industry as a whole.

Again, there are no tricks or the distorting of numbers. The distortion again comes from the people who stand to gain from advertising dollars flowing online.

  • There have been underhanded tactics being played out…

…in which some media agencies are booking and buying schedules which are financially beneficial to them as opposed to the clients’ best interests. Low margins have always plagued the media planning and buying business.  When digital came on the scene it was like mana from heaven.

Unlike the 10 per cent offered by traditional media, there were commissions and rebates at 20 and even 30 per cent. So of course there were unscrupulous people who promoted media solutions that provided them with a far greater pay off. Throw in the dodgy metrics used to support their claims and it is no wonder clients were misinformed.

When a business is remunerated by commissions, there will always be the potential for a conflict of interest.

  • The blind rush to online, at the expense of traditional media

The Magpie Generation, Ritson called them. I cannot name the person for obvious reasons, (he is well known as one of the country’s foremost media strategists), who recently said to me, “If I am given a brief and respond with a print solution as being the impactful and cost effective, I will be shown the door.

“The client wants a digital solution as they believe it is the future and they do not want to be seen by their peers as using old fashioned media. And why would I get the client offside when online pays me two to three times what traditional media does?”.

So it is not purely a case of media agencies pushing a solution that is financially better for them. They have the clients demanding a digital media/online solution, so of course they will go with what the client requests. When the media approach demanded by the client pays two to three times what may be the better alternative, why would you argue and risk the relationship?

So in Conclusion…

Just as trust is the major criteria for a successful brand, clients must be able to trust us to provide them the most effective communications solutions. Once trust is lost, it is almost impossible to get back.

But it is a two- way street. As client procurement departments have “hacked away” at agency fees for so long, it is little wonder that agencies need to find additional revenue sources. If clients want agency partners they can trust to best serve their interests, they can’t keep cutting the fees they pay.

It is a classic case of cause and effect. We can’t expect to change the effect, without first addressing the cause.

 

Please login with linkedin to comment

Latest News

Retail Software Player Vend Moves Into AI As Part Of Platform Revamp
  • Marketing
  • Technology

Retail Software Player Vend Moves Into AI As Part Of Platform Revamp

Point-of-sale (POS) retail software company Vend has taken its first steps into AI to help retailers grow and compete as part of a major platform refresh. Dott aims to help retailers make better decisions about their stores and how to grow, bringing the much talked-about promise of AI to life for retail. Neither male nor […]

One-on-one With Pacific Magazines’ Wendy Moore
  • Media

One-on-one With Pacific Magazines’ Wendy Moore

With audiences consuming more media than ever before, Wendy Moore, general manager of Pacific Magazines’ homes and food titles, sat down with Magazine Networks to outline two unique projects in her portfolio. When she’s not gracing our TV screens as a judge on Seven’s House Rules, Wendy Moore oversees Pacific Magazines’ portfolio of homes and […]

Enough With Your Shitty Videos Already
  • Opinion

Enough With Your Shitty Videos Already

In this opinion piece, Mike Cardillo (pictured below), co-founder, executive creator director and resident frustrated soul at Sydney-based production company Sixteen Corners, argues why making a video for the sake of making a video will never do, and offers some words of wisdom to those looking to create a clip. So, the solution to every marketing, comms, […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
The Amazon Effect! Study Shows 88% Of Aussies Hate Local Retailers
  • Marketing
  • Media

The Amazon Effect! Study Shows 88% Of Aussies Hate Local Retailers

Amazon’s Australian launch is imminent and if you had any concerns about its ability to succeed Down Under you only need to look at a new survey that reveals a whopping 88 per cent of Australian shoppers say they’re no fans of local bricks and mortar retailers. The study, by tech solutions firm Pitney Bowes, showed a […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Bauer’s Christian Fricke Resigns As MD Of Xcel Media
  • Media

Bauer’s Christian Fricke Resigns As MD Of Xcel Media

Further to today’s news that Bauer Media will close three of its magazine titles, the publisher has announced the resignation of Christian Fricke, managing director of Bauer Xcel Media. According to a statement sent to media, Fricke, who had been in the role a mere 18 months, will return to Germany for family reasons. Commenting on Fricke’s departure, Bauer Media […]

WWF Campaign Labelled “The Saddest Christmas Ad Ever”
  • Campaigns

WWF Campaign Labelled “The Saddest Christmas Ad Ever”

The World Wildlife Fund (WWF) has unveiled its annual Christmas ad campaign that has been labelled as “one of the saddest Christmas adverts ever produced. The global campaign aims to daw attention to the devastation caused by Africa’s ivory trade and the tremendous cruelty inflicted on its elephants. It was produced by the WWF’s as part of their Just Like Us campaign and […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Former Aussie Cricket Captain and photography enthusiast Steve Waugh for SnapSydney.  Picture: John Appleyard
  • Campaigns
  • Media

News Corp Expands ‘Snap Australia’ Campaign To Regional Titles

News Corp’s award-winning Community Media’s ‘Snap Australia’ campaign continues to build momentum. ‘Snap Australia’ is a social media movement that celebrates what Aussies love about where they live. The feel-good factor of the initiative has extended into each capital city and into News Regional Media, with an additional 18 regional publications joining the initiative. Today […]

Virgin, Yellow Brick Road & GoSwtich Flock To Sports Content Platform PlayersVoice
  • Marketing
  • Media

Virgin, Yellow Brick Road & GoSwtich Flock To Sports Content Platform PlayersVoice

Six weeks after its launch, sports content platform PlayersVoice is winning the hearts and minds of consumers and brands. Established as a platform for rich and raw first-person sports storytelling, PlayersVoice has created an environment where elite sportspeople feel comfortable sharing their thoughts, hopes, dreams and fears, shining a light on ‘The Human Behind the […]

Red Agency Grows Partnership With The Whiddon Group
  • Marketing

Red Agency Grows Partnership With The Whiddon Group

NSW aged care specialists The Whiddon Group – a longstanding PR and social client of Red Agency – have widened their remit to include content, paid social and SEO in line with the evolution of the aged care sector. Whiddon, which celebrates its 70th birthday this year, delivers care services that enable quality of life […]

Image lead story Toby’s Estate Taps Influencers To Launch First Concept Coffee Range
  • Campaigns
  • Marketing

Toby’s Estate Taps Influencers To Launch First Concept Coffee Range

Toby’s Estate Coffee Roasters has launched its first ever concept coffee range – the Underdog Series. The series shines a spotlight on the world’s relatively unknown, but emerging specialty coffee producing regions. The Australian business leads the local market in selling specialty coffee from regions including Uganda, Malawi, Mexico and Myanmar. For the first time, […]

Image lead story Our Revolution Shows Off Packaging For New Smallgoods Player The Smokeman Brothers
  • Marketing

Our Revolution Shows Off Packaging For New Smallgoods Player The Smokeman Brothers

Locally-sourced Australian brand The Smokeman Brothers, has hit shelves with packaging mastered by independent creative agency Our Revolution. The Smokeman Brothers is different to your average deli meat. It is a range of premium crafted meats, made in Australia, and authentically smoked using sustainable timber sourced from the Victorian Highlands and The Riverina regions. Our […]

Yarra Trams & Icon Agency Introduce ‘Tram Coach’ For New Passenger Safety Campaign
  • Advertising
  • Campaigns

Yarra Trams & Icon Agency Introduce ‘Tram Coach’ For New Passenger Safety Campaign

Yarra Trams has appointed Icon Agency to deliver a new passenger safety campaign, following a competitive three-way pitch. The campaign aims to reduce the incidence of slips, trips and falls on trams via Melbourne’s latest safety ambassador, ‘Tram Coach’. Commencing today, Tram Coach will be travelling the Yarra Trams network throughout the week. His mission […]

The Red Republic Appoints New General Manager
  • Marketing

The Red Republic Appoints New General Manager

The Red Republic has strengthened its management team with the appointment of Mai Aristoteli (pictured above) as general manager. Aristoteli joins The Red Republic from Talk PR in London, where she has worked for nine years as a board director. The appointment of Aristoteli follows The Red Republic managing director Lynn Mooney’s relocation to head-up […]

PR Deadlines Inks Deal With GlobalCom PR Network
  • Marketing

PR Deadlines Inks Deal With GlobalCom PR Network

Sydney-based agency PR Deadlines has extended its global reach after inking a partnership agreement with the GlobalCom PR Network. The agreement gives PR Deadlines’ clients access to some 70 independent agencies covering all European Union states, as well as 60 more in countries worldwide. In turn, clients of affiliated agencies will have access to PR […]

Fintech Start-up InstaReM Names Aussie Cricketer Matthew Wade As Brand Ambassador
  • Marketing

Fintech Start-up InstaReM Names Aussie Cricketer Matthew Wade As Brand Ambassador

InstaReM, which offers international money transfers to individuals and businesses, has signed on Australian wicketkeeper Matthew Wade as the sports face of the brand. InstaReM lists Australia as its founding market, having begun life here in 2014. Since the company’s modest start in Australia, InstaReM has since successfully spread its wings to other corridors by […]

Australia Is Diverse… Does Your Brand Have An Inclusive Digital Presence?
  • Marketing
  • Opinion

Australia Is Diverse… Does Your Brand Have An Inclusive Digital Presence?

As Australia continues to grow and the population becomes more ethnically diverse, it is important that marketers ensure digital environments are more inclusive, especially for those who don’t speak English as a first language, writes Siteimprove’s Haley Doel (pictured below). Having a readable and accessible website is no longer just a high priority for large […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Pepsi MAX Teams Up With PHD & Time Out For New Data-driven Campaign
  • Advertising
  • Campaigns

Pepsi MAX Teams Up With PHD & Time Out For New Data-driven Campaign

Pepsi MAX has partnered with PHD and Time Out to not only inspire Australians, but also enhance their ability to ‘MAX’ out their summer this year. Through the use of a live dynamic data feed, consumers will be served ads by the brand on events taking place around them that are relevant to their personal […]

AI – To Join It Or To Beat It
  • Media
  • Opinion

AI – To Join It Or To Beat It

I'm afraid we can't let you read this piece Dave! That's a joke about A Space Odyssey 2001, young B&T readers.

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine