Yes, No, Maybe: Should brands tackle social issues?

Yes, No, Maybe: Should brands tackle social issues?
SHARE
THIS



Reactive advertising is nothing new. But Coke has taken it a step further and moved to patch up relations between India and Pakistan with vending machines that allow the countries’ residents to communicate in realtime based on the brand’s ‘happiness’ message. Is this something brands should do more of?

This 'Yes, No, Maybe' first appeared in the June 7 2013 issue of B&T Magazine. More details on the debate raging around 'Small World Machines' can be found here. 

Nick Davis, executive director, Interbrand Melbourne

Yes – "If you've got a clear purpose and belief system, you will be ok"

It’s clear that the opportunity for brands to have a voice and role in people’s lives and social concerns is greater than ever these days.

For brand owners, it’s a classic Catch-22. You can get more airtime, but you can also be more exposed. One response is to stick to your core business and steer clear. Stay focused on your category position battles and don’t aspire to stand for more than a product or service promise.

An alternative response is to be active, if not proactive, on social issues.

The brand owners that do this best are those with a view that a clear purpose trumps a category position. They recognise that category positions can be disrupted daily by copycats and innovators.

A strong purpose and belief system not only helps fend off category competition, it also frees your brand to transcend such confines.

Ultimately the consumer will decide whether it’s relevant for your brand to have a voice on social issues. But their judgements will be fair if there’s integrity in your intent.

If you’ve got a clear purpose and belief system, you will be ok. If not, you should get one.

 

Dominic Walsh, managing director, Landor Associates

Maybe – "Reacting to social issues is a short-term gimmick"

In a world of social media, brands need to be socially aware. The web creates a new level of transparency for brands and this means they need to demonstrate they are good corporate citizens.

Brands, however, need to be certain that the social issue they are aligning themselves with has relevance to their brand. It was not so long ago that all brands were jumping on the ‘green’ bandwagon and being accused of ‘green washing’.

For a brand to align itself with a social issue it needs to demonstrate genuine intent. This goes beyond communications and needs to form part of the brand’s DNA.

If a brand is serious about the issue they need to put their money where their mouth is. Tom’s Shoes demonstrates this well with the one for one movement. For every pair of shoes you buy, Tom’s will give a pair to children living in poverty. IKEA is another example, referring to its social initiatives as ‘the never ending list’ and its social responsibility is central to its business philosophy.

In short, reacting to social issues is a short-term gimmick and, in the new world order, consumers expect substance.

 

Chris Jeffares, managing director, CumminsRoss

Yes – "Hell hath no furth like a consumer scorned"

Having just watched the richest-again man in the world, Bill Gates, deliver a very compelling Q&A episode around his amazing philanthropy and key world health issues, I was caught in a positive frame on this topic. Sure, he is doing this all on a more personal level now. But make no mistake, all those $Bs came from one of the world’s largest and most successful brands in Microsoft and he and they will be forever intertwined.

The caveats on this positive perspective on brand involvement are relevance and risks. ‘Relevance’ in that the brand should stay true to its values and essence in what it supports. Powerhouse brands can bring great contributions to these issues, but need to avoid the shallow meme-centric approach of just hijacking the latest topical issues. Same sex marriage? Green

Facebook avatars? Occupy Wall Street? And ‘risk’ in the foresight and management of these, because the modern consumer will gladly ridicule and flame the actions of any brand if they doubt the authenticity of this support and sense a less than altruistic motive.

They have the means, the technology, the social platforms and many seek the fame. Follow the sentiment trends in the Coke YouTube commentary and you can clearly sense the passion and polarisation around this social issue and Coke’s involvement.

It’s a brilliantly crafted three minutes that treads respectfully and joyfully. But hell hath no fury like a consumer scorned. (Especially if they have a Canon EOS 5D, After Effects and a big Klout score).

 

Andy DiLallo, chief creative officer, Leo Burnett Sydney (the agency is behind Coke's Small World Machines)

Yes – "'Small World Machines' is a real-world example of the power of creativity"

‘Small World Machines’ highlights in the most beautiful way the positive role in society that a brand can play, and there should be more of it.

I think the significance of this project transcends being attached to this year alone.

Instead, the real significance of this project has more to do with the journey Coke as a company has been on to get to this point. Coke has now demonstrated that it is willing to live up to the courage of its convictions by attempting something of this nature. Its demonstration of strength and confidence in who it is as a brand is a very rare and powerful thing in this business.

‘Small World Machines’ is an initial step in the positive direction to bring greater appreciation of commonalities and to encourage the letting go of differences. Although it is a small step, it is a forward step, and that can only be a good thing.

To be able to take two countries that have been divided and to unite them through the world’s most iconic brand, and see the purity of the experience, was amazing. Hopefully it works as a symbol of how people can overcome differences and come together with a simple act of joy. Without a doubt, ‘Small World Machines’ is a real-world example of the power of creativity.

Please login with linkedin to comment

Latest News

Apple Revists Muhammad Ali’s ‘I Am the Greatest’ Speech In New Ad For The X
  • Campaigns

Apple Revists Muhammad Ali’s ‘I Am the Greatest’ Speech In New Ad For The X

Apple has gone for a simple but highly effective campaign to promote the selfie taking ability of its new iPhone X, employing boxing great Muhammad Ali’s famous 1963 “I Am The Greatest” speech. The ad shows simple selfie photos taken by the phone as Ali’s hubris plays over the top. Ironically, the ad plays on the narcissism of […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Comexposium Takes Over NZ Partner MTS To Become Largest Trans-Tasman Events Group
  • Marketing

Comexposium Takes Over NZ Partner MTS To Become Largest Trans-Tasman Events Group

Marketing events group Comexposium has absorbed its New Zealand joint venture partner MTS to deliver an expanded event solutions business across the Trans-Tasman. The deal will see Ryf Quail (pictured above) return to Sydney to lead Comexposium Australian and Kiwi team, while his current MTS team remains in place as Comexposium employees. While the business […]

Eyeota Kick-Starts 2018 With $15.6 Million In Additional Funding
  • Marketing

Eyeota Kick-Starts 2018 With $15.6 Million In Additional Funding

Audience data provider Eyeota has announced a $15.6 million Series B capital raise to spearhead additional growth in 2018. The company was founded simultaneously in Singapore, Australia and Europe in 2010, and has remained independent and enjoyed strong growth locally, as well as launching into the US. Peter Hunter (pictured above), Eyeota’s general manager for […]

Poem Wins Four New Clients
  • Marketing

Poem Wins Four New Clients

Sydney-based PR and social agency Poem has announced it has won four new clients following another strong year of growth. The four clients are Property NSW (The Rocks and Darling Harbour), Fantastic Furniture, Ovolo Hotels and Purpose (a conference on purpose-driven business). Poem co-founder Matt Holmes said: “We’ve hit a nerve with clients who are […]

Facebook Makes Another News Feed Change
  • Media

Facebook Makes Another News Feed Change

Social media behemoth Facebook has announced its second major update for News Feed to make sure the news people see, while less overall, is high quality. This week, Facebook announced that the platform will launch a small test in the US focused on prioritising news from publishers that users find trustworthy. Facebook is also exploring ways […]

Attention! B&T’s Inaugural Bootcamp Launches!
  • Advertising
  • Marketing
  • Media
  • Technology

Attention! B&T’s Inaugural Bootcamp Launches!

B&T announces its new industry bootcamp! And, if you're like us & didn't know anything about it, all's revealed here.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Domain Boss Antony Catalano Exits
  • Media

Domain Boss Antony Catalano Exits

Mystery surrounds Domain boss's surprise exit, although the Mystery Machine nor a talking dog not spotted at Fairfax.

PHOTOPLAY Offers A Ghost Train Ride Like No Other At Sydney Festival
  • Media

PHOTOPLAY Offers A Ghost Train Ride Like No Other At Sydney Festival

Jasmin Tarasin, director at boutique production company PHOTOPLAY, is inviting invites audiences to take a trip through the inner-workings of the mind in ‘Ghost Train’, her latest multi-sensory VR project set to feature at this year’s Sydney Festival. Working in collaboration with musician and co-creative director Jonnine Standish, Tarasin’s uniquely immersive ‘Ghost Train’ is a […]

March One To Rebrand Fundraising Institute Australia
  • Marketing

March One To Rebrand Fundraising Institute Australia

Independent advertising and branding agency March One has been appointed to oversee the rebrand and repositioning of Fundraising Institute Australia (FIA). FIA is the national peak body representing professional fundraising in Australia. It was established to advance advocacy and professional standards, and has identified the need to better promote its role as the industry self-regulator, […]

Victorian Government Launches VR Bushfire Experience Via The Fuel Agency
  • Advertising
  • Campaigns
  • Technology

Victorian Government Launches VR Bushfire Experience Via The Fuel Agency

As part of its summer fire campaign, the Victorian government has launched a virtual reality (VR) bushfire experience and content series via The Fuel Agency. The VR experience places the user in the midst of a large bushfire, and is designed to encourage people to leave early on high-risk days before it’s too late. The […]

Local Ad Tech Company VeNA Partners With RugbyPass
  • Advertising
  • Media
  • Technology

Local Ad Tech Company VeNA Partners With RugbyPass

ad tech company VeNA has signed an exclusive reseller partnership covering Australia and New Zealand with digital rugby network RugbyPass. Across Asia and parts of Europe, RugbyPass is the exclusive digital rights holder and over-the-top broadcaster for live rugby, including the Super Rugby, the Rugby Championship and autumn internationals, the Six Nations, the Aviva Premiership, […]